Thanks for the info. It sounds like you and your wife got a great start on your lives together!!!
I have heard nothing but good things about Key West (particularly on OSO). We (my wife and I) are definately going to consider Key West as a possible anniversary destination. It sounds like the Hyatt is top-notch and THE place to stay. We would like to go 'nothing-but-first-class' like you guys did. We might just steal your itinerary.