The Hustler is a little faster in the flat but the PP is a better riding boat in the rough, I've been on both.
The pro's and con's of both the Hustler and PP for "me" would be a coin toss.
The cost to run the PP and Huster was nearly identical to what it cost for me to run my 30' Scarab. However, the cost to run my 36' Apache and mike to run his 37' OL is nearly double. Unless it's stock power, the Cafe's cost of operation will be incramental IMHO... It doesn't seem like a lot but the Cafe is a much bigger boat and needs more power to run. My 36' Apache was designed to compete in the same market at the Cafe.
But hey, you're paying the money so I'd just get what you like!
I was dead set on an Apache or Top Gun, went with the Apache because the cabin blew away the TG and I knew I'd be building a family.