Center Console vs. Traditional V w Stern Drive
#21
Registered
#23
Drive to arrive alive!!!
Platinum Member
It all depends on the center console. Beam makes a huge difference. The Cigarette 39 Top Fish has an 8'6" beam, and isn't near as stable as my 39 GTS with a 10' beam. The wider the beam the better it will ride, but I tow it a LOT and I don't want over a 10' beam. I want another loud go fast, but the console isn't going anywhere. If you can't have both, then in my opinion, the CC is the way to go. I've had mine and a 42MTI-V in some snotty water, and both ride great.
#24
Registered
So it really comes down to how you boat and where. As for reliable, I boat with two people that have single engine 29 foot go fasts with 496HO's. Those are about as reliable as you get, closed cooled, and the gas mileage is nuts. (3 mph) they can trim up and get to sand bars fine. 1 guy put 400 hours on his in the last year with just oil and drive fluid changes.
Also price, are the new Statements and NorTech nice,,,,,,,,,, sure but they are WAY more then I can afford. Like someone said are we talking about cheaper used Fish CC's?
For us I don't like a huge crew, one other couple is enough. That way I can go and do whatever without needing to know peoples schedule etc. Some like to take 12 of their closest friends.
I will say down here most have CC's. but most are in the 24-30 foot range also. The motor of choice is Yamaha. Another friend has a Yamaha direct injected 2 stroke that I didn't even know it was a two stroke until my 3rd time out and I happened to look at it!
LOL
Not the same class as statements, Cig, Nortechs, susations.
You could always have AT build you a 33 with egg beaters.
Also price, are the new Statements and NorTech nice,,,,,,,,,, sure but they are WAY more then I can afford. Like someone said are we talking about cheaper used Fish CC's?
For us I don't like a huge crew, one other couple is enough. That way I can go and do whatever without needing to know peoples schedule etc. Some like to take 12 of their closest friends.
I will say down here most have CC's. but most are in the 24-30 foot range also. The motor of choice is Yamaha. Another friend has a Yamaha direct injected 2 stroke that I didn't even know it was a two stroke until my 3rd time out and I happened to look at it!
LOL
Not the same class as statements, Cig, Nortechs, susations.
You could always have AT build you a 33 with egg beaters.
#25
Gold Member
Gold Member
in the water or under the t-top.....where do you hang out in your traditional Vee if you don't have cabin air?
a lot of bigger CC's have built in sun loungers now upfront...why need a sun pad when you have that? On older ones with a cuddy like the scarab 302 they make a pad that goes over the cuddy that is a sun pad.
I don't think we are talking about bare bones fishing CC'S are we?
a lot of bigger CC's have built in sun loungers now upfront...why need a sun pad when you have that? On older ones with a cuddy like the scarab 302 they make a pad that goes over the cuddy that is a sun pad.
I don't think we are talking about bare bones fishing CC'S are we?
#26
Registered
the rest like me toss out a raft and tie it to the rear cleat and float around and relax in the water.
#27
VIP Member
VIP Member
I took delivery, and ran my 39 Cigarette GTS last weekend, and I have to say, it was some of the most stress free boating I've done in years. If anyone tells you there's less cleaning, they have a hose-down fishing boat. My new ride must have 5000 yards of vinyl !! But the ease of moving around to clean it, makes it a breeze. I know I'll miss the high speed and noise as soon as someone goes blowing by me, but the fun and comfort level of the CC out weighs it..
#30
OK I have owned both for many years for the following reasons. Opinions are like well everybody has one and here are mine:
42 Fountain:
-freshwater only. Too expensive to maintain if used a lot in salt. Never any engine/drive work in 350 hrs.
-Trailer brakes perfect, never serviced in 10 years.
-looks way cool
-faster 85 mph
-smoother in the chop
-stabbin cabin for the girlie stuff. Vacu flush doesn't work right.
-sounds powerful and gets a lot of looks at the docks
-comfortable with 5 adults
-harder to keep clean and nice
-most friends ask to go out on this one
-no sun protection
35 Marlago:
-saltwater only. 2 cycle smokers. No engine work in 15 years. Always start every single time. Always. 425 hrs.
-Replaced lower gear cases 5 years ago due to water in oil.
-trailer brakes trash in 1 year. Never had them fixed.
-looks fine if you are a fisherman, well, it looks OK, pretty good when clean...
-55 mph. 60 mph with the wind...
-not as smooth but only 35 foot boat
-smaller cabin. Potty "stuff" pumps out of the boat when nobody's lookin'...
-smokes on start up but gets rid of mosquitoes. 250 EFIs use outboard oil and more gas than the 525s. But they NEVER break.
-comfortable with 8-9 adults and/or kids
-much easier to clean. Soft brush with suds in bucket and rinse and done in 10 mins.
-friends who fish like this boat, "what kind of person would want one of those dam show off ashole boats..."
-huge sun protection top that goes with the style of the boat and is lowerable, to look like the Powerplay boat in a later post
42 Fountain:
-freshwater only. Too expensive to maintain if used a lot in salt. Never any engine/drive work in 350 hrs.
-Trailer brakes perfect, never serviced in 10 years.
-looks way cool
-faster 85 mph
-smoother in the chop
-stabbin cabin for the girlie stuff. Vacu flush doesn't work right.
-sounds powerful and gets a lot of looks at the docks
-comfortable with 5 adults
-harder to keep clean and nice
-most friends ask to go out on this one
-no sun protection
35 Marlago:
-saltwater only. 2 cycle smokers. No engine work in 15 years. Always start every single time. Always. 425 hrs.
-Replaced lower gear cases 5 years ago due to water in oil.
-trailer brakes trash in 1 year. Never had them fixed.
-looks fine if you are a fisherman, well, it looks OK, pretty good when clean...
-55 mph. 60 mph with the wind...
-not as smooth but only 35 foot boat
-smaller cabin. Potty "stuff" pumps out of the boat when nobody's lookin'...
-smokes on start up but gets rid of mosquitoes. 250 EFIs use outboard oil and more gas than the 525s. But they NEVER break.
-comfortable with 8-9 adults and/or kids
-much easier to clean. Soft brush with suds in bucket and rinse and done in 10 mins.
-friends who fish like this boat, "what kind of person would want one of those dam show off ashole boats..."
-huge sun protection top that goes with the style of the boat and is lowerable, to look like the Powerplay boat in a later post
Last edited by On Time; 06-04-2017 at 12:22 PM.