I wonder how well the racing PWC jackets work? Those suckers are pretty fast these days (70mph) and getoffs are pretty common. It is highly likely that they expect to contact the PWC during a getoff so they should be protective (the racing vests at least). I would hope that they came up with some reasonable priced vests that provide floatation and protection. Anyone know about it?

I will need to buy something so I am paying close attention to this thread.

Sorry to have started such a controversy over PFD's.....I hoped that this would help others find a good jacket for a reasonable price. Did I say Apache?????

I think it's a great thread.
Anytime people can learn something about safety on the water that they didn't realize before, it's a GREAT thread, IMO

I agree, I learned that I can't wear a 100mph rated PFD and expect my ribs to be protected in an impact... I guess ya learn something new every day!

Looked into the PWC racing vests and found out they are "100mph impact tested for strength but not for personal imjury from impact". This seems like a similar rating to the Stearns vest above. They do look a little better if that matters.

Interestingly, they called it a Type 5 coast guard approved vest, not a type 3. Not sure what that means.

Here is a website that describes all five styles of PFD

http://www.dcnr.state.al.us/MP/pfd.htm



TYPE V: Special-Use Devices

These windsurfing vests, deck suits, hybrid PFDs and others are designed for specific activities, such as kayaking or water skiing. Some Type V PFDs are designed to inflate when you enter the water. Inflatable Type V PFDs must be worn when underway to be acceptable.

one more thing.....

If I remember right, the phrase above is why Lifeline jackets don't meet the CG requirements. Because they take too long to put on. They don't meet specs.

But people who buy Lifeline jackets most likely will be wearing them when they need them. So the point is moot.

Here's the link:

http://www.rocknrescue.com/acatalog/...tearns_75.html

Dave

The type 5 is not required to turn you upright if you are unconcious. Many will however. You are not allowed to operate a PWC in Maryland if you are not wearing a 100 mph vest. I suspect many other states are the same.

I was told one time that LL did not want to pay $75k to get the jackets certified.