Can a 496HO Freeze Damaged Heat Exchanger be Repaired?
#1
Gold Member
Gold Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Missouri
Posts: 1,987
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Can a 496HO Freeze Damaged Heat Exchanger be Repaired?
The area of freeze damage is a break/leak soemwhere between the sea water chamber and the antifreeze coolant chamber such that at high sea water pressure, sea water is pumped into the reservoir.
Does anyone know if a 2005 Merc 496HO heat exchanger that has been so damaged by sea water freezing can be repaired?
Anyone know specifically who has successfully repaired a freeze damaged heat exchanger for the 496HO?
Does anyone know if a 2005 Merc 496HO heat exchanger that has been so damaged by sea water freezing can be repaired?
Anyone know specifically who has successfully repaired a freeze damaged heat exchanger for the 496HO?
#2
Registered
Platinum Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: wisconsin
Posts: 688
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have three that froze. I even cut one apart. It would be very costly to repair, if even, at all possible. Ended up getting new ones. If you do find someplace that will fix at a reasonable $, let me know. The problem with these are as follows; just draining system will not always get ALL the water out. I found out the hard way. I now either blow the system out with compressed air, and/or put anti freeze in the system for extended periods of storage for below freezing conditions.
Also, if someone can fix, will they stand behind the work?? Down time can be a pain, and waiting to get new ones takes time. And even people standing behind there work can also take time.
Also, if someone can fix, will they stand behind the work?? Down time can be a pain, and waiting to get new ones takes time. And even people standing behind there work can also take time.
#3
Gold Member
Gold Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Missouri
Posts: 1,987
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The one you cut appart, can you describe in as much detail as possible what, where and how severe the freeze damage is that occurs. Is it just a cracked solder joint at a union or gaping holes or what? If just a simple split solder joint a solder reflow could be an easy repair. But anything with a major gap that would require cut appart and reassembly would likely be prohibative. You do not still happen to have the damaged HE you cut up or any of the other two damaged units?
I have three that froze. I even cut one apart. It would be very costly to repair, if even, at all possible. Ended up getting new ones. If you do find someplace that will fix at a reasonable $, let me know. The problem with these are as follows; just draining system will not always get ALL the water out. I found out the hard way. I now either blow the system out with compressed air, and/or put anti freeze in the system for extended periods of storage for below freezing conditions.
Also, if someone can fix, will they stand behind the work?? Down time can be a pain, and waiting to get new ones takes time. And even people standing behind there work can also take time.
Also, if someone can fix, will they stand behind the work?? Down time can be a pain, and waiting to get new ones takes time. And even people standing behind there work can also take time.
#6
Registered
I really don't think that you have much of a choice except to replace. The "disassembly" of the heat exchanger will be pretty destructive and will take a specialized craftsman several hours to tear it apart, find all of the leaks and solder/weld everything required. I doubt the work would come with a guarantee. You could always revert to raw water cooled.
Rene
Rene
#7
Lakeside Restorations.com
Commercial Member
Personally I would replace it. By the time you get done with repair you would have been better to replace it..
If you want to save some coin & Go new you can look them up on my web site under the Mercruiser parts look up application. All of our parts bought thru the site are discounted. They are also factory parts (not aftermarket).. Jamie
www.LakesideRestorations.com
.
If you want to save some coin & Go new you can look them up on my web site under the Mercruiser parts look up application. All of our parts bought thru the site are discounted. They are also factory parts (not aftermarket).. Jamie
www.LakesideRestorations.com
.
__________________
www.LakesideRestorations.com 570-639-2628
We Make Fast Toys Faster, Cool Toys Cooler and Old Toys New!.. Performance, Custom & OEM Parts & much MORE![/CENTER]
www.LakesideRestorations.com 570-639-2628
We Make Fast Toys Faster, Cool Toys Cooler and Old Toys New!.. Performance, Custom & OEM Parts & much MORE![/CENTER]
#8
Gold Member
Gold Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Missouri
Posts: 1,987
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If only soldered brass and copper it would seem that a radiator shop could acid "boil" off all the paint, desolder the pieces with a torch, solder repair the damage, reassemble and resolder together. If anything is truely welded then this approach would be a non starter. This is what I am trying to get a handle on. How is the HE put together and what is is made of? All brass/copper and soldered only or what? I would love to get a detailed drawing of the HE design from the manufacturer who ever that is.
If repair is not an option I will buy a new replacement to maintain the antifreeze protection for the engine. I just do not like throwing good money away. I can handle no "guarantee" if the repair cost is reasonable compared to buying new.
If repair is not an option I will buy a new replacement to maintain the antifreeze protection for the engine. I just do not like throwing good money away. I can handle no "guarantee" if the repair cost is reasonable compared to buying new.
I really don't think that you have much of a choice except to replace. The "disassembly" of the heat exchanger will be pretty destructive and will take a specialized craftsman several hours to tear it apart, find all of the leaks and solder/weld everything required. I doubt the work would come with a guarantee. You could always revert to raw water cooled.
Rene
Rene
#9
Registered
Platinum Member
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: BELGIUM EUROPE
Posts: 182
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dustin @ Whipple recommands for the 496 upgrading to a Sen-Dure heat exchanger for superior cooling (5" ID ) which is a direct bolt on / replacement exchanger
They also may be able to fix your damaged one
Why not give them a call ? www.sen-dure.com
Let us know if something worked out
They also may be able to fix your damaged one
Why not give them a call ? www.sen-dure.com
Let us know if something worked out
#10
Gold Member
Gold Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Missouri
Posts: 1,987
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Sen-Dure #15006-1-5 (5"dia) $925 list, $693 street, 3 - 4 weeks delivery.
Dustin @ Whipple recommands for the 496 upgrading to a Sen-Dure heat exchanger for superior cooling (5" ID ) which is a direct bolt on / replacement exchanger
They also may be able to fix your damaged one
Why not give them a call ? www.sen-dure.com
Let us know if something worked out
They also may be able to fix your damaged one
Why not give them a call ? www.sen-dure.com
Let us know if something worked out