Marine Gas Engine Synthetic Race oil?
#31
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 9
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Joe Gibbs is a very successful well respected Nascar Team. Some of the more wise and respected members of this board can confirm that their oil is a high quality custom blended race specific oil, not a cheap marketing gimmic. However if you have some "real" evidence to the contrary, I would be happy to see it.
Last edited by Riverracer; 03-21-2008 at 01:37 PM.
#32
Gold Member
Gold Member
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Grosse ile michigan
Posts: 2,369
Likes: 0
Received 79 Likes
on
32 Posts
I have done a little research on the joe gibbs oil..From everything i have read they make a awsome oil and stand behind there product...A lot of guys love the break in oil they have formulated, i for one cant afford to put 12 quarts into my engine when it costs 160.00 a oil change not including the filter...
#34
Registered
I run a 50/50 mix of Mobil One and 10W50 racing oil .
I read testing showed synthetic oil boosted the mineral oil's characteristics while the mineral oil improved film density .
I dont think oil temperature is an issue in a properly rigged boat , if anything the problem keeping the oil adequately warm .
I believe the major difference between the two oils is temperature breakdown , as far as friction goes you'd probably need extremely sophisticated sensitive equipment to determine any measureable gain .
Save your money .
I also ran Mobil One in the stern drives and transmissions with no issues .
I read testing showed synthetic oil boosted the mineral oil's characteristics while the mineral oil improved film density .
I dont think oil temperature is an issue in a properly rigged boat , if anything the problem keeping the oil adequately warm .
I believe the major difference between the two oils is temperature breakdown , as far as friction goes you'd probably need extremely sophisticated sensitive equipment to determine any measureable gain .
Save your money .
I also ran Mobil One in the stern drives and transmissions with no issues .
#35
Registered
Are the additive chemistries compatible?
Is the 10w50 a petroleum? If it is why don't you just run a syn/pet blend out of the blocks instead of playing blender? What viscosity Mobile 1 are you using and what is the final viscosity of the "blended" product.
If you are going to "blend" products, stay with the same oil manufacture, hopefully they use the same additive technology in all their different types of engine oils.
Ken
Is the 10w50 a petroleum? If it is why don't you just run a syn/pet blend out of the blocks instead of playing blender? What viscosity Mobile 1 are you using and what is the final viscosity of the "blended" product.
If you are going to "blend" products, stay with the same oil manufacture, hopefully they use the same additive technology in all their different types of engine oils.
Ken
#36
Registered
[QUOTE=minxguy;2495342]Are the additive chemistries compatible?
Is the 10w50 a petroleum? If it is why don't you just run a syn/pet blend out of the blocks instead of playing blender? What viscosity Mobile 1 are you using and what is the final viscosity of the "blended" product.
If you are going to "blend" products, stay with the same oil manufacture, hopefully they use the same additive technology in all their different types of engine oils.
If you are going to "blend" products, stay with the same oil manufacture, hopefully they use the same additive technology in all their different types of engine oils.
Minxguy , they are compatible , I'll typically run 10w50 Mobil One and the Valvoline , Pennzoil or any premium racing oil .
I'm positive my blend is 50/50 and not some marketing gimmick , besides you need to run " RACING OIL" because of it's low ash content in a high compression motor.
After 20 years of doing this , a few wins and a few championships , I'm not playing
Is the 10w50 a petroleum? If it is why don't you just run a syn/pet blend out of the blocks instead of playing blender? What viscosity Mobile 1 are you using and what is the final viscosity of the "blended" product.
If you are going to "blend" products, stay with the same oil manufacture, hopefully they use the same additive technology in all their different types of engine oils.
If you are going to "blend" products, stay with the same oil manufacture, hopefully they use the same additive technology in all their different types of engine oils.
Minxguy , they are compatible , I'll typically run 10w50 Mobil One and the Valvoline , Pennzoil or any premium racing oil .
I'm positive my blend is 50/50 and not some marketing gimmick , besides you need to run " RACING OIL" because of it's low ash content in a high compression motor.
After 20 years of doing this , a few wins and a few championships , I'm not playing
Last edited by aex; 03-22-2008 at 06:35 PM.
#37
Registered
If you have to run a low ash oil in your high compression engines why do you mix it 50/50 with an alleged high ash product like Mobile 1? From what i have read about oils if you want low ash use aircraft oils with their organic detergent package and then follow an engine rebuild schedule a la Lycoming.
And why do I need to run a low ash oil in a high compression motor?
Ken
And why do I need to run a low ash oil in a high compression motor?
Ken
#38
Registered
If you have to run a low ash oil in your high compression engines why do you mix it 50/50 with an alleged high ash product like Mobile 1? From what i have read about oils if you want low ash use aircraft oils with their organic detergent package and then follow an engine rebuild schedule a la Lycoming.
And why do I need to run a low ash oil in a high compression motor?
Ken
And why do I need to run a low ash oil in a high compression motor?
Ken
The ash in motor oils lead to combustion chamber deposits which promote detonation . I started this practice quite a while ago but still break them in with conventional oil . On another point I like to keep the pressure down and volume high , run the lightest viscosity oil you can .
I think it's pretty common knowledge the various lubricants do mix successfuly .
Just my way I guess , I do concede I'm no expert .
I copied the following from a Mobil 1 ad .
Mobil 1 5W-30 is especially suitable for extreme conditions, where conventional oil often cannot perform
It is not recommended for 2-Cycle or aviation engines, unless specifically approved by the manufacturer
Features and Benefits:-
Low Ash Content
Low Sulphur and Phosphorous content
Active cleaning agents
Outstanding thermal and oxidation stability
Low oil consumption
Enhanced frictional properties
Excellent low temperature capabilities
#39
Registered
I want believe that you can come up with a balanced finished lubricant better than say Mobile. You state that Mobil 1 is also low ash, so why would you take a state of the art synthetic and ruin it's chemical and oxidative properties and mix it with a conventional (petroleum) lubricant.
Just what is the extreme conditions are you using the oil in?
Oil temps in excess of 300 degrees, extreme cold say -25F, or are you shooting for 50-100 hours of use between changes?
I am just curious and I am sure that there are people on this board who are just as curious.
Ken
#40
Registered
I run a 50/50 mix of Mobil One and 10W50 racing oil .
I read testing showed synthetic oil boosted the mineral oil's characteristics while the mineral oil improved film density .
I dont think oil temperature is an issue in a properly rigged boat , if anything the problem keeping the oil adequately warm .
I believe the major difference between the two oils is temperature breakdown , as far as friction goes you'd probably need extremely sophisticated sensitive equipment to determine any measureable gain .
Save your money .
I also ran Mobil One in the stern drives and transmissions with no issues .
I read testing showed synthetic oil boosted the mineral oil's characteristics while the mineral oil improved film density .
I dont think oil temperature is an issue in a properly rigged boat , if anything the problem keeping the oil adequately warm .
I believe the major difference between the two oils is temperature breakdown , as far as friction goes you'd probably need extremely sophisticated sensitive equipment to determine any measureable gain .
Save your money .
I also ran Mobil One in the stern drives and transmissions with no issues .
A I had stated , that product description came directly from a Mobil ad . Please read my original post , quoted above .
Film density is what protects your roller valve train when you have the excessive spring pressures associated with high lift cams .
The greatest advantage of synthetic oil is it's ability to withstand high temperatures , again not an issue in a properly rigged boat , save your money .
Synthetic oil is a luxury item , if you can afford it use it but you'll only see an advantage under the most extreme conditions .
Keep the oil volume high , keep the pressure and viscosity as low as you can get away with and obviously keep it clean