Cable Assist Hydraulic Steering Vs Full Hydraulic
#21
Masher touches my
Gold Member
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Phoenix, Az
Posts: 2,280
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Cable Assist Hydraulic Steering Vs Full Hydraulic
If I added external add-on rams can I still at some point change my helm and use the same rams? Are these systems upgradable? I added on the steering this winter but have not used it at all. My boat never chine walked or had any problems what so ever except when I tried to run a Hydromotive prop that had so much stern lift that the boat felt like it had absolutely no steering what so ever above 70mph. The only reason I added the system is because I can run 75 or so and I wanted to be safe, fearing that the internal ram could passibly fail at that speed and cause the boat to go out of control. I know I have solved the problem with the add on steering, 75 is not 105 so it should suffice for what I need but after reading this thread if I cant steer it at idle or my wife cant steer it at idle that would pose a definant problem.
#23
Registered
Platinum Member
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: New Baltimore , M.I.
Posts: 320
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Cable Assist Hydraulic Steering Vs Full Hydraulic
My 26" scarab has the normal cable / Hydraulic steering, with a single external ram. Is it normal that both inter and outer rams are hooked up. Also at idle it can be a pain to steer does that mean that the pump pulley is to small??
#24
Re: Cable Assist Hydraulic Steering Vs Full Hydraulic
Originally Posted by BADKACHINA
but after reading this thread if I cant steer it at idle or my wife cant steer it at idle that would pose a definant problem.
Mine was only noticebly harder if I thought about it, otherwise it was not an issue. The wife would load the boat on the trailer, she never said anything. My only issue would be trying to turn it to fast at idle. Even then it was not a 2 handed operation. I wouldn't loose any sleep over it. Install the add-on now, then upgrade to the full at a later date if you decide you want it. Hardest part is drilling the holes in the transom.
#25
Masher touches my
Gold Member
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Phoenix, Az
Posts: 2,280
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Cable Assist Hydraulic Steering Vs Full Hydraulic
Originally Posted by US1 Fountain
Hardest part is drilling the holes in the transom.
#27
Masher touches my
Gold Member
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Phoenix, Az
Posts: 2,280
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Cable Assist Hydraulic Steering Vs Full Hydraulic
Originally Posted by US1 Fountain
You did level the boat 1st, right?
#28
Re: Cable Assist Hydraulic Steering Vs Full Hydraulic
I really don't know how they do the variable assist stuff. It's probably some type of ecu/speed/variable-port setup. Changing the pump rpm only varies the "available" volume of oil. The pump is always circulating oil, even when the wheel is not being turned. This flow rate determines the rate at which you can turn the wheel, hopefully at least as fast as you would like to turn it!
#29
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Beautiful Lake St. Clair,MI
Posts: 513
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Cable Assist Hydraulic Steering Vs Full Hydraulic
Nauti-Boy
I understand that the stock cable system with no hydraulic external cylinders has slop in it from side to side. Now, what if you had the "add on" system. The cable actuated hydraulic system. There should be no play in the drive because the hydrualic cylinders has it locked in place. So, we are getting back to my original question. Is the drive any more solid with the full system than it is the full hydraulic system? What makes the full system safer? Is the strain on the cable only due from steering wheel input or is the strain on the cable due to outside forces acting on the drive, which is the primary reason to change to external hydraulic cylinders in the first place.
It appears to me that the primary difference between the 1/2 system with the cable and the full system with the hydraulic helm is the method by which drive input is recieved by the shuttle valve. Is this correct? If the cable is in good condition, why would it be unsafe? I also understand there may be some inherent slop in the cable helm, resulting in some wheel play before the actual input is realized by the hydraulics.
I understand that the stock cable system with no hydraulic external cylinders has slop in it from side to side. Now, what if you had the "add on" system. The cable actuated hydraulic system. There should be no play in the drive because the hydrualic cylinders has it locked in place. So, we are getting back to my original question. Is the drive any more solid with the full system than it is the full hydraulic system? What makes the full system safer? Is the strain on the cable only due from steering wheel input or is the strain on the cable due to outside forces acting on the drive, which is the primary reason to change to external hydraulic cylinders in the first place.
It appears to me that the primary difference between the 1/2 system with the cable and the full system with the hydraulic helm is the method by which drive input is recieved by the shuttle valve. Is this correct? If the cable is in good condition, why would it be unsafe? I also understand there may be some inherent slop in the cable helm, resulting in some wheel play before the actual input is realized by the hydraulics.
#30
Re: Cable Assist Hydraulic Steering Vs Full Hydraulic
I asked that question to the sales rep at the Miami boat show. His reply was that by putting the external rams on, you get the safety factor. By going to the full hydraulic helm, you get the ease of steering. Again that is just sales rep talk.