Offshoreonly.com

Offshoreonly.com (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/)
-   General Boating Discussion (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-boating-discussion-51/)
-   -   Correct Engine Oil w/Roller Cam (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-boating-discussion/231353-correct-engine-oil-w-roller-cam.html)

253 05-26-2010 07:31 AM

Correct Engine Oil w/Roller Cam
 
I read an article several months ago about the danger of using Synthetic Oil with roller cam engines ,something about it's too slick ,and the roller lifters will not roll but wear flat spots, does anyone have advise or proof of this, I don't want to ruin my cam. Thanks.

Knot 4 Me 05-26-2010 07:56 AM

Stock motors with hydraulic rollers, I've seen zero problems in 12 years using 15W-50 Mobil 1.

Griff 05-26-2010 08:44 AM

Never had a problem with synthetic oil and roller cams

253 05-27-2010 06:47 PM

Thanks, for the info.

GETTINBYE 05-28-2010 12:50 PM

If synthetic is so slick that a roller will not roll with it then wouldn't that be slick to the point that it would not create a flat spot in the first place?

Just my thoughts.

Zone 5 05-28-2010 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by 253 (Post 3120111)
I read an article several months ago about the danger of using Synthetic Oil with roller cam engines ,something about it's too slick ,and the roller lifters will not roll but wear flat spots, does anyone have advise or proof of this, I don't want to ruin my cam. Thanks.

Break it in on Mineral, then run good syn oil. Powerboat Mag had an article a few years back claiming that syn was too slipery. Its BS. If it was wrong, I'd guess that the ZO-6 and ZR-1 Vette's that come from the factory with it wouldn't have it.

Biggus 05-29-2010 07:51 AM


Originally Posted by Zone 5 (Post 3122470)
Powerboat Mag had an article a few years back claiming that syn was too slipery. Its BS. If it was wrong, I'd guess that the ZO-6 and ZR-1 Vette's that come from the factory with it wouldn't have it.

...yeah until Teague got a sponsorship from Amsoil.:lolhit:

Zone 5 05-29-2010 10:41 AM


Originally Posted by Biggus (Post 3122720)
...yeah until Teague got a sponsorship from Amsoil.:lolhit:

Yea, you think :eek::eek::eek:

DareDevil 05-29-2010 10:45 AM


Originally Posted by 253 (Post 3120111)
I read an article several months ago about the danger of using Synthetic Oil with roller cam engines ,something about it's too slick ,and the roller lifters will not roll but wear flat spots, does anyone have advise or proof of this, I don't want to ruin my cam. Thanks.

CORRECT !!!!!!

DO NOT USE SYNTHETIC OIL ON ROLLER CAMS....
its to slick and the rollers can slide and cause wear !

I only use valvoline VR 1 racing oil on a roller ! Never had a problem !!!!

I did use Mobil 1 before and it wore the cam and rollers !

GO4BROKE 05-29-2010 11:46 AM

If you took out a cam and lifters it wasn't due to Mobil 1. As stated above, if its too slick to turn a roller, it's way too slick to cause wear. You had a lifter failure. I have run mobil 15w50 in my roller cam boats since 1996. No issues except when walmart runs out of 5 qt jugs.
Nearly every premium engine in cars gets M1 for a factory fill. all of them are roller cams.
NOW if we're talking M1 starting oil leaks conventional didn't, I agree with that.

Zone 5 05-29-2010 07:09 PM

My roller cam motor has had nothing but Amsoil series 2000 Syn in it for 6 years. It has never had anything done to it except regular stuff (oil change/filter etc). Syn oil does NOT hurt cams. In fact if you wipe out a roller cam odds are that it was installed wrong or the owner did something wrong.

ROTAX454 05-30-2010 08:28 AM


Originally Posted by Biggus (Post 3122720)
...yeah until Teague got a sponsorship from Amsoil.:lolhit:

Chevrolet has been filliing Corvette crankcase's with Mobil 1 for many years.

Biggus, Ain't that the fact. The power of the American Magazine advertiser and supporter. How about a Consumer Report style publication for Marine Performance boating. Boy, that would have some companies running for cover.

Sorry. Now to the question. IMHO a good syn oil of your choice is what you should use. Stick with the forumla that still has a high zinc value. Very important to use this for ALL break-in conditions. Especially for any valvetrain new part installations.
http://www.summitracing.com/parts/NAL-88862586/

sunchaser796 05-30-2010 09:59 AM

Now that I have read all the threads about what oil to run, I would run amsoil15w50 racing oil. Yes Bob Teague does run his skater with amsoil and after Mercury did a refresh on his engines they said they have have never seen an engine so clean. There was no discoloration on the cam or the rollers. The crack looked there wos no major wear at all. Do I beleive it ? Yes I do when it comes from Mercury Racing Division. I just like Teague use asmoil in my Dodge Durango and have other people switch over to it as well. And amsoil has a bettter oil for drives as well. And I am also an AMSOIL dealer as well. Zone 5 is living proof that amsiol is a product you can live by. Pm me if you want to know more about amsiol products.

chris@uga 05-30-2010 12:31 PM


Originally Posted by sunchaser796 (Post 3123095)
And I am also an AMSOIL dealer as well.

Now there's a shock. lol

ROTAX454 05-30-2010 09:59 PM


Originally Posted by chris@uga (Post 3123165)
Now there's a shock. lol

Is it just me, or is trying to purchase some Amsoil products like dealing with an Amway salesman?

Everyone is a dealer or should I say "order takers". No one that I have found actually stock anything. If I am wrong, then who does stock the products? In the Metro Detroit area.

GO4BROKE 05-31-2010 07:17 AM

[QUOTE=ROTAX454;3123330]Is it just me, or is trying to purchase some Amsoil products like dealing with an Amway salesman?

QUOTE]

It does seem that way. I think they have a quality product, its just expensive and a bit of an effort to get. I also don't believe they have a better engineering dept than exxon. I like going to wally world anytime I need oil and grabbin a 5qt jug for $22.

Back4More 05-31-2010 07:55 AM

Saw a Crane roller rocker come out of a Flat tappet synthetic oil motor with a flat spot on the roller tip...go figure.

CNC 05-31-2010 09:20 AM

[QUOTE=GO4BROKE;3123428]

Originally Posted by ROTAX454 (Post 3123330)
Is it just me, or is trying to purchase some Amsoil products like dealing with an Amway salesman?

QUOTE]

It does seem that way. I think they have a quality product, its just expensive and a bit of an effort to get. I also don't believe they have a better engineering dept than exxon. I like going to wally world anytime I need oil and grabbin a 5qt jug for $22.

I agree, But not available (in Mi Wally's) not even on their on their order guide to special order. M-1 is available at advance auto(15w-50), just in quarts. How is Castrol's synthetic, 20w-50??.
I ran GTX in race bikes for years, never had a problem. Only reason I switched M-1 thirty years ago is because it was the latest and greatest.

rlj676 05-31-2010 10:21 AM

[QUOTE=CNC;3123479]

Originally Posted by GO4BROKE (Post 3123428)

I agree, But not available (in Mi Wally's) not even on their on their order guide to special order. M-1 is available at advance auto(15w-50), just in quarts. How is Castrol's synthetic, 20w-50??.
I ran GTX in race bikes for years, never had a problem. Only reason I switched M-1 thirty years ago is because it was the latest and greatest.

Are you saying there's no M-1 15W-50 at the MI Wal Mart's? The one on Van Dyke in Warren does.:drink:

There's some Amsoil also at Murray's/O'reilly's, but I don't think its a big selection.

Kurt Hamilton 05-31-2010 12:58 PM

I was told by my engine builder here in Australia several years ago to try and steer towards the good brand mineral racing oils for any motors he built us as he had several engines with worn rollers due to the synthetic oils being used. Once they got all there engines onto the mineral oil the problems stopped!
Im no oil expert but i trust my engine builder, he builds lots and lots of high load engines and has done for over 40 years. To me his experience outways what any oil company salesman would recommend.
How many oil companies test their engine oil range in high load high performance boat engines?

CNC 05-31-2010 01:01 PM

[QUOTE=rlj676;3123506]

Originally Posted by CNC (Post 3123479)

Are you saying there's no M-1 15W-50 at the MI Wal Mart's? The one on Van Dyke in Warren does.:drink:

There's some Amsoil also at Murray's/O'reilly's, but I don't think its a big selection.

I haven't hit every Walmart in Mi. ( I'm in W. MI...from R.O. btw)
I just took one of my old 5qt jugs let them scan it. The manager said unavailable on their order guide...

rlj676 05-31-2010 01:10 PM

[QUOTE=CNC;3123591]

Originally Posted by rlj676 (Post 3123506)

I haven't hit every Walmart in Mi. ( I'm in W. MI...from R.O. btw)
I just took one of my old 5qt jugs let them scan it. The manager said unavailable on their order guide...

That's weird they couldn't order it even? Could stock up then next time you're back here on this side of the state.

I was thrilled to buy that jug at Wal Mart for 23.50, especially after seeing it at Joe's here in RO for 10.99 a quart, or compared to the V Twin I used last year at 10 bucks a quart too!

Might be available around here because of all the racing/builders?

formula 382 sr-1 05-31-2010 05:13 PM


Originally Posted by ROTAX454 (Post 3123330)
Is it just me, or is trying to purchase some Amsoil products like dealing with an Amway salesman?

Everyone is a dealer or should I say "order takers". No one that I have found actually stock anything. If I am wrong, then who does stock the products? In the Metro Detroit area.

My guy has every thing in stock 2 cases of 15/50 sr 2000 and a case of drive oil every time I call .:drink::drink:

ROTAX454 05-31-2010 08:48 PM

[QUOTE=rlj676;3123597]

Originally Posted by CNC (Post 3123591)

That's weird they couldn't order it even? Could stock up then next time you're back here on this side of the state.

I was thrilled to buy that jug at Wal Mart for 23.50, especially after seeing it at Joe's here in RO for 10.99 a quart, or compared to the V Twin I used last year at 10 bucks a quart too!

Might be available around here because of all the racing/builders?

Was this the product that Wal Mart had?
http://www.amsoil.com/catalog.aspx?GroupID=741

Yes, I would be thrilled to have a dealer (or retailer) stock the Amsoil products that I use within a reasonable driving distance.

rlj676 05-31-2010 08:59 PM


Originally Posted by ROTAX454 (Post 3123869)

Was this the product that Wal Mart had?
http://www.amsoil.com/catalog.aspx?GroupID=741

Yes, I would be thrilled to have a dealer (or retailer) stock the Amsoil products that I use within a reasonable driving distance.

Wal Mart has the Mobil 1 15W-50, I don't think they carry any Amsoil.

07DominatorSS 05-31-2010 10:10 PM

For anyone looking for AMSOIL products in the Metro Detroit area, feel free to send me a PM or email. We have nearly 100k of product in stock, anything from a quart to a 55 gallon drum. Also, please don't hesistate with any questions you may have.

[email protected]


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:04 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.