Offshoreonly.com

Offshoreonly.com (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/)
-   General Q & A (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q-20/)
-   -   MSD..... marine or no..?? (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q/223474-msd-marine-no.html)

bigfarmer 01-27-2010 01:41 PM

MSD..... marine or no..??
 
Has anybody used the MSD-6AL over the marine MSD 6m-2L..??? does the 6AL stand up to the marine environments..??

JohnSchiavarelli 01-27-2010 01:50 PM

I have been using the MSD Digital 6 Plus box (Pn 6520) since Oct 2006.. no issues yet.. (Knock on wood)..
Also run MSD crank trigger, MSD Pro-Billet distributor. MSD Starter. and lock timing out at 34..

Throttle Fever 01-27-2010 02:08 PM

Using them for the past 6 years. Pro billet dist. 6M and rev box. No issues. Freshwater applications on mine...

picklenjim 01-27-2010 02:20 PM


Originally Posted by bigfarmer (Post 3032771)
Has anybody used the MSD-6AL over the marine MSD 6m-2L..??? does the 6AL stand up to the marine environments..??

Wouldn't recommend it . I had a piece break off the circuit board in one and left me stranded. The marine version is filled with a polyurethane resin to keep moisture out and everything in place. It's worth the $150 more.

FIXX 01-27-2010 04:20 PM

Been running a 6al box in mine for 10 yrs,never a issue! their all waterproof at some point,i also have a 6al boxunder the hood of my truck mounted to the fan shroud for the past 13+ yrs,itsbeen trough all the salt,rain,snow and no issues.

picklenjim 01-27-2010 05:38 PM


Originally Posted by mrfixxall (Post 3032877)
Been running a 6al box in mine for 10 yrs,never a issue! their all waterproof at some point,i also have a 6al boxunder the hood of my truck mounted to the fan shroud for the past 13+ yrs,itsbeen trough all the salt,rain,snow and no issues.

On the 6AL non marine box the bottom is only riveted to the main case by 4 rivets on the corners. There is no kind of seal whats so ever between the 2.There is no way they could ever be considered water proof. The marine version is completely potted with polyurethane resin so there is no way the circuit board or any of the parts inside can get wet and are secure from vibration and shock. My 6AL failed from shock and vibration in the middle of the first season on the boat. Replaced it with the 6m and have had no problems for 8 years now.

FIXX 01-27-2010 08:56 PM

fixx
 

Originally Posted by picklenjim (Post 3032916)
On the 6AL non marine box the bottom is only riveted to the main case by 4 rivets on the corners. There is no kind of seal whats so ever between the 2.There is no way they could ever be considered water proof. The marine version is completely potted with polyurethane resin so there is no way the circuit board or any of the parts inside can get wet and are secure from vibration and shock. My 6AL failed from shock and vibration in the middle of the first season on the boat. Replaced it with the 6m and have had no problems for 8 years now.

Like i said some what waterproof! :) you must have got a lemon..mines not mounted on the engine,its mounted on the transom away from the vibrations..maybe thats why its lasted so long....Per the tech at msd he told me that all the msd components in the box's are sealed in polyurethane..

anewway 01-27-2010 09:00 PM


Originally Posted by picklenjim (Post 3032800)
Wouldn't recommend it . I had a piece break off the circuit board in one and left me stranded. The marine version is filled with a polyurethane resin to keep moisture out and everything in place. It's worth the $150 more.


Only bad thing with that is that if the box fails, there is no repairing it. It is now a throw away item.

picklenjim 01-27-2010 09:51 PM


Originally Posted by mrfixxall (Post 3033074)
Like i said some what waterproof! :) you must have got a lemon..mines not mounted on the engine,its mounted on the transom away from the vibrations..maybe thats why its lasted so long....Per the tech at msd he told me that all the msd components in the box's are sealed in polyurethane..

Mine's mounted on the transom also, same place the first one was mounted. Works well there, out of the way. After reading your post I went out to the garage and got down that old box and your right, it looks like they dipped the entire circuit board with all the componets on it in polyurethane. I don't know if you could ever have one of those fixed either.

formulaok 01-27-2010 10:11 PM

Ive had both 6m's and 6al's. track records for both for me is about the same. They work most of the time, but sometimes they just fry on you for no apparant reason. I have friends that have had more 6m problems and replaced with 6al and lived.

My experience is use either one of them and either run a ready to run dist. as your mag pickup so that it can be jumpered in the event of a failure or, what I do is keep a spare box in the boat and wire the box with a quick connect harness.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:49 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.