![]() |
The pin has been removed.....
|
Well I'll post back in September how it is holding up and we'll see then who knows what they are talking about and who is paranoid.
|
I'd run it too. If it blows. He'll have all new motor when rebuilt. If it doesn't, might require more machine work. It's a win win situation. :)
Where do some of you guys get this couple of months time frame to rebuild a basically stock motor? |
Originally Posted by US1 Fountain
(Post 3688074)
I'd run it too. If it blows. He'll have all new motor when rebuilt. If it doesn't, might require more machine work. It's a win win situation. :)
Where do some of you guys get this couple of months time frame to rebuild a basically stock motor? |
Originally Posted by blue thunder
(Post 3687996)
I think you guys are over stating the risk. What exactly is the real risk here? Death, bankrupcy, divorce, job loss? Probably none of those. This is simply a hobby for most. He risks getting towed in and having from zero to a few thousand dollars in incremental expense to fix it. The benefit is getting to boat all year if all goes well which I suspect it will given no metal in the filter. Pulling an engine and starting the pro rebuild now will take a couple months start to finish at minimum. If he pushed it maybe he could get some boating in August. Now if he was building a mars lander we might want to be a little more prudent and converative, but honestly fellas, its just a boat. It even appears that he has a second boat which takes 1/2 the percieved "risk" away... of not being able to go boating.
|
Guys, all i was trying to do, is give friendly advice. Same advice i'd give any of my local boating buddies . If any of you, have every had to rebuild/replace, a engine that has thrown a rod, or busted a crank, you would know it costs ALOT more than just pulling it, doing a mild freshen up on bearings, gaskets, light machine work, etc.
My buddy had a rod let go in his 468 a few years back. It took out his cast aluminum beautiful oil pan, snapped his camshaft in half, F'd up his cylinder head when the piston got jammed, along with the taking out some valves, not too mention ruined the block. He does all his own stuff, and it still cost him a ton just in parts. Worse case you say an add'tl 2-3000 bucks. I'd say at little more than that. Just getting a new "used" block to replace the broken one, with proper machine work, boring, line honing, decking, etc, its very easy to have 1500 just in a GM production block. Then a new roller cam, and probably lifters if a few get destroyed, another 1000 bucks. Havent even got into heads, pistons, crank, rebalancing, valves, or anything like that. He has a 30 hour engine right now. His repairs may be as simple as opening it up, checking the crank/rods and so on, resetting clearances, maybe a polish on the crank, and put it back together, if he's lucky and no major damage has been done yet. If it was a tired old 1000 hour 330hp 454, then ya, i'd say run it till she blows. But, a stroker cranked 489 with eagle rotating assemblies and probably decent pistons, a bob m cam, good lifters, is actually a real nice engine, or can be. Hey, its just my opinion, its your motor. I'd be pleasantly surprised if you prove me wrong, and your engine keeps running strong. As much as I disagree, and you insinuate I don't know what Im talking about, I dont wish you bad luck. Happy Boating. :coolcowboy: |
Originally Posted by MILD THUNDER
(Post 3688121)
Guys, all i was trying to do, is give friendly advice. Same advice i'd give any of my local boating buddies . If any of you, have every had to rebuild/replace, a engine that has thrown a rod, or busted a crank, you would know it costs ALOT more than just pulling it, doing a mild freshen up on bearings, gaskets, light machine work, etc.
. Happy Boating. :coolcowboy: |
Originally Posted by blue thunder
(Post 3688141)
I'll be sea trialing my port engine this weekend that I broke a crank in last sept between 4 and 5 main cap at 5000rpm. Imagine that carnage. The worst case for redstinger is a knock develops which he will immediately shut down and discontinue operation if wise.
OP, and I say run it and see what happens. If it lasts, it lasts. If not, well then you have a good reason to giver er some more HP. |
Originally Posted by Philm
(Post 3688629)
You breakin it in this Saturday? I will be out all day weather permitting. Maybe I will see you out there. :party-smiley-004:
OP, and I say run it and see what happens. If it lasts, it lasts. If not, well then you have a good reason to giver er some more HP. |
2mos since orig post. Boat still runs great with no noises, but I did pull oil filter and cut it open last week...Some small copper glitter in the bottom...This fact coupled with the 10 psi oil at hot idle is enough convince me to play it safe. I am pulling the motor tomorrow and taking it back to the builder. Hopefully will have it back by Labor day and can enjoy Sept and Oct. In the meantime I guess we'll just ride the jetskis.
Thanks to all for your opinions. |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:43 AM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.