Offshoreonly.com

Offshoreonly.com (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/)
-   General Q & A (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q-20/)
-   -   Name that failure! (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q/296985-name-failure.html)

Tinkerer 05-29-2013 09:29 PM

I have had mud plug up the water hose going to just one header tube thus that header tube runs much hotter than all of the others. Hotter means better scavenging. Lean condition on just that cylinder.

That piston melted due to a lean condition. I never said that the bearings were damaged. I said IF it was detonation that destroyed that piston I felt the bearings would have been hammered.
The top ring came off WHEN the top of the piston melted off. I have melted pistons many times and they were NOT caused by detonation. That piston melted and coated the cylinder with it. That one cylinder ran lean for a lot longer than 10 seconds. If the head lifted off of the block it would have melted the head gasket also. I run EGT gauges on my engines for a reason.

Mtuned 05-29-2013 10:11 PM


Originally Posted by articfriends (Post 3933531)
As far as your injector "size" being too small, it is common for fuel press to be bumped up on these procharged applications, a 42lb injector becomes a 53lb injector when press is raised from 43.5 to 70 psi which will very easily support 600 hp at .55 bsfc, ideal, no but has been used on LOTS of stuff.I don't believe your injectors suddenly became "too small" with no other changes in past 3 years. IF you were reusing tjose injectprs (which your not) I would STILL throw away the one that was on the cyl that melted down even IF it tested good juct in case it is a intermittent problem. Are your new 1000 cc (96lb) injectors also high impedance, I just started seeing some high impedance injectors that big in past year or so but still hard to find, Smitty

Yes High Impedance, and they will be controlled by a tuned flash in the ECU. We now have 2200CC HIGH Z injectors that can idle stoich at IPW of 1.10-1.20 MS Amazing how technology has progressed!

Mtuned 05-29-2013 10:12 PM


Originally Posted by GPM (Post 3933576)
What cylinder did that piston come out of ?

Number 6 Sir. 3rd Back on left side of engine.

Mtuned 05-29-2013 10:17 PM


Originally Posted by articfriends (Post 3933525)
"Injectors have been tested and flowed at FIC and were SPOT on.

Leaning towards possible injector driver."
I am going to assume that because you are running 42 lb injectors that you are also running a factory merc /delphi mefi3 ecu. If so your probably NOT going to find a problem with the injector driver because- Mefi's are BATCH fire, your ECU is firing a batch of FOUR injectors everytime it fires, if there was a problem with one of the 2 injector drivers, you would have problemss with four injectors, Smitty

Its an MEFI4, still fire the same though.

GPM 05-29-2013 10:32 PM


Originally Posted by Mtuned (Post 3933651)
Number 6 Sir. 3rd Back on left side of engine.

Thanks, I was just curious where that piston was when number 4 fired.

mike tkach 05-29-2013 10:32 PM


Originally Posted by Tinkerer (Post 3933623)
I have had mud plug up the water hose going to just one header tube thus that header tube runs much hotter than all of the others. Hotter means better scavenging. Lean condition on just that cylinder.

That piston melted due to a lean condition. I never said that the bearings were damaged. I said IF it was detonation that destroyed that piston I felt the bearings would have been hammered.
The top ring came off WHEN the top of the piston melted off. I have melted pistons many times and they were NOT caused by detonation. That piston melted and coated the cylinder with it. That one cylinder ran lean for a lot longer than 10 seconds. If the head lifted off of the block it would have melted the head gasket also. I run EGT gauges on my engines for a reason.

maybe you should stick to correcting spelling&grammar,or be a spelling b captian,you are better at that than you are understanding what is going on inside a cylinder.now flame away tough guy.

Tinkerer 05-30-2013 09:29 PM

Always an A S S. Keep it up MIKE. - You don't know a thing about me but YOU know everything. If you are so smart - You tell me why car headers are so much better than boat headers when everything is the same. DUH
How many engines have you built? How many pistons have you seen melted?

mike tkach 05-30-2013 09:44 PM

:lolhit:

Originally Posted by Tinkerer (Post 3934264)
Always an A S S. Keep it up MIKE. - You don't know a thing about me but YOU know everything. If you are so smart - You tell me why car headers are so much better than boat headers when everything is the same. DUH
How many engines have you built? How many pistons have you seen melted?

arent you going to correct my spelling,i will keep it up,what are you going to do about it tough guy?i know by what you say that you dont know ****,just think you do,you are just a big mouth -no brain -PUNK.now go back to the spelling b.:lolhit:

mike tkach 05-30-2013 09:47 PM

and yes i am an ass AMERICAN SUPER STAR.

Tinkerer 05-30-2013 10:15 PM

HEY STUPID - You must have me confused with someone that cares about your spelling. I don't care. - It just proves how stupid you are.
You didn't answer my question... MR LOUD MOUTH KNOW IT ALL

mike tkach 05-30-2013 10:27 PM

:lolhit:

Originally Posted by Tinkerer (Post 3934299)
HEY STUPID - You must have me confused with someone that cares about your spelling. I don't care. - It just proves how stupid you are.
You didn't answer my question... MR LOUD MOUTH KNOW IT ALL

:thankyouthankyou:MAYBE IT,S TIME FOR YOU TO TINKER WITH YOUR DINKER!

MILD THUNDER 05-30-2013 10:40 PM


Originally Posted by Tinkerer (Post 3934264)
Always an A S S. Keep it up MIKE. - You don't know a thing about me but YOU know everything. If you are so smart - You tell me why car headers are so much better than boat headers when everything is the same. DUH
How many engines have you built? How many pistons have you seen melted?

I can attest that mike has probably built 15 engines in the last 2 years alone. Used to build and race blown alcohol, worked as an assembler at a machine shop, has a pair of blown 540 950hp engines in his cat he built that runs a buck and a quarter, and 1200hp whippled 598's he runs in his fountain at the moment. And he has seen his share of smoked pistons . Not trying to defend him, just stating facts. He isn't new to this stuff. You walk in his shop and you'll find every engine tool you can think of, big blowers , rods, heads, cranks, and all kinds of cool stuff to play with sitting on shelves. He's built everything from a 389 Pontiac resto engine, to a basic 502 build, to huge power blown alky stuff. He's just a hobbyist like the rest of us with a love of horsepower . Just sayin.

FIXX 05-31-2013 01:25 AM


Originally Posted by MILD THUNDER (Post 3934319)
I can attest that mike has probably built 15 engines in the last 2 years alone. Used to build and race blown alcohol, worked as an assembler at a machine shop, has a pair of blown 540 950hp engines in his cat he built that runs a buck and a quarter, and 1200hp whippled 598's he runs in his fountain at the moment. And he has seen his share of smoked pistons . Not trying to defend him, just stating facts. He isn't new to this stuff. You walk in his shop and you'll find every engine tool you can think of, big blowers , rods, heads, cranks, and all kinds of cool stuff to play with sitting on shelves. He's built everything from a 389 Pontiac resto engine, to a basic 502 build, to huge power blown alky stuff. He's just a hobbyist like the rest of us with a love of horsepower . Just sayin.

+1,, i have been their as well and all above is true..also i will be the first to admit that i have blown up a ton of stuff with the help of nos..that was before we had the data logger and all the egt's and o2 sensors in each tube of the header and i will still crush or peel a ring land off a piston even with a 7k data logger..

Tinkerer 05-31-2013 05:54 PM

Yes - He may be but HE doesn't need to be an A S S HOLE. He doesn't have a clue what MY capabilities are. He just likes to name call. I don't know why he has a thing about spelling - I don't care - I never have and have never called him out on it.

mike tkach 05-31-2013 07:07 PM


Originally Posted by Tinkerer (Post 3934833)
Yes - He may be but HE doesn't need to be an A S S HOLE. He doesn't have a clue what MY capabilities are. He just likes to name call. I don't know why he has a thing about spelling - I don't care - I never have and have never called him out on it.

read my and your posts and then tell me who did the name calling,you are pathetic!

Tinkerer 05-31-2013 08:36 PM

So YOU have a problem with reading too.

Maybe YOU should reread post #46 - that is where YOU started calling ME names. I don't give a dam about your inability to spell.

mike tkach 05-31-2013 08:53 PM

what name did i call you in post 46

GPM 05-31-2013 08:57 PM

So, any news on the motor ? any pictures of the head gasket ?

Tinkerer 05-31-2013 08:57 PM

Read it again - after post #46 you just started calling me names. I don't know what your problem is with me - You don't know me or what I am capable of doing.

mike tkach 05-31-2013 09:09 PM

i know that you are confused about many facets of engine operation,and that you have an attitude,but i dont give a chit about you.im not going to waste any more of my time attempting to teach you anything because it,s evident that you know everything.truth is you dont recognise detonation when it is as clear as a bell.im done with this,and you.carry on with your rant if you feel the need.

mike tkach 05-31-2013 09:16 PM


Originally Posted by Tinkerer (Post 3934923)
Read it again - after post #46 you just started calling me names. I don't know what your problem is with me - You don't know me or what I am capable of doing.

so i did no name calling in post 46,but it,s ok for you to call me ASS ******* STUPID,dude,maybe that,s how you roll,like i said,you are pathetic.and i certianlly hope that you saying that i dont know what you are capable of is not a threat to me,if it is let me know.

Tinkerer 05-31-2013 09:26 PM

You have a problem - GET OVER IT. I don't give a dam about YOU - But when You come on here and start calling me names I am going to defend myself.
I would think that if that engine was running with low enough octane or too much advance to do that much damage to one piston it at least would have done some damage to other pistons. Did any eyebrows on other pistons get deformed? What caused just that one piston to melt or detonate like you say? Sounds like the injectors have been checked and it sounds like the ignition was not the problem. did the spark plug come loose. the only one offering an idea that could cause just one cylinder to melt down was my suggestion to look at the header.
If you are such an expert than tell us what caused the meltdown on just that ONE cylinder.

mike tkach 05-31-2013 09:43 PM

mtuned,after you repair the engine damage i suggest replacing the cap and plug wires,it is posible that the cap has an internal crack or carbon tracking causing that cylinder to fire at the wrong time causing the detonation,it is also posible that the energy from a plug wire is jumping into another wire,i know this sounds crazy but i have seen it hapen with msd wires that are 3 or more years old in a marine envirement.

abones 05-31-2013 10:05 PM

Ok guys after looking at the op pics, It looks like the damage started around the intake/eyebrow area and burned around the top of the piston toward the exhaust valve side, so why would it start there near the cooler side of the incoming air charge? I don't have the answer just bringing up an observation. Could it have a small crack in the cyl head? Steam jet cutting into the piston and once it penetrates to ring it self destructs? don't know what are your thoughts?

GPM 05-31-2013 10:13 PM

Might want to look at the head gasket between the cylinders.

Mtuned 06-02-2013 08:04 PM

What do you guys think about this for fuel setup.
3L Surge Tank Twin Fuel Pump Bracket Genuine 2 x Bosch 044 Fuel Pumps | eBay

And a single Walbro 255 feeding that?

teamsynergy 06-03-2013 11:24 AM

Mtuned... clean your PM inbox... its full :)

Mtuned 06-03-2013 11:14 PM

Cleaned ! Teamsynergy

MILD THUNDER 06-03-2013 11:18 PM


Originally Posted by Mtuned (Post 3935809)
What do you guys think about this for fuel setup.
3L Surge Tank Twin Fuel Pump Bracket Genuine 2 x Bosch 044 Fuel Pumps | eBay

And a single Walbro 255 feeding that?

Why not just run a single aeromotive or Weldon pump and eliminate all that poppycock?

Full Force 06-04-2013 04:12 AM


Originally Posted by abones (Post 3934955)
Ok guys after looking at the op pics, It looks like the damage started around the intake/eyebrow area and burned around the top of the piston toward the exhaust valve side, so why would it start there near the cooler side of the incoming air charge? I don't have the answer just bringing up an observation. Could it have a small crack in the cyl head? Steam jet cutting into the piston and once it penetrates to ring it self destructs? don't know what are your thoughts?

Because that's the thinnest part of the piston and that's where it starts to melt.....

Full Force 06-04-2013 04:14 AM


Originally Posted by Tinkerer (Post 3934934)
You have a problem - GET OVER IT. I don't give a dam about YOU - But when You come on here and start calling me names I am going to defend myself.
I would think that if that engine was running with low enough octane or too much advance to do that much damage to one piston it at least would have done some damage to other pistons. Did any eyebrows on other pistons get deformed? What caused just that one piston to melt or detonate like you say? Sounds like the injectors have been checked and it sounds like the ignition was not the problem. did the spark plug come loose. the only one offering an idea that could cause just one cylinder to melt down was my suggestion to look at the header.
If you are such an expert than tell us what caused the meltdown on just that ONE cylinder.

You can melt down just one cylinder at a time, it happens all the time, some run leaner then others.... My buddy has 800+ hp procharged engines in his Formula, over last 7 years melted twice.... each time it was ONE piston.... its carbed also, no no per cylinder injectors.... it just happens that way...

Mtuned 06-04-2013 09:31 AM


Originally Posted by MILD THUNDER (Post 3936540)
Why not just run a single aeromotive or Weldon pump and eliminate all that poppycock?


Worried about the stock fuel line being able to supply the correct amount of volume to two bosch044 pumps. Surge tank will elimnate this issue.

MILD THUNDER 06-04-2013 12:34 PM


Originally Posted by Mtuned (Post 3936708)
Worried about the stock fuel line being able to supply the correct amount of volume to two bosch044 pumps. Surge tank will elimnate this issue.

Yes, I know what a surge tank is. I can see you're a car guy. A surge tank can help, but its not designed for continuous Full throttle, like a boat does. It can work in a drag race application because theres normally enough fuel stored in the surge tank to complete a pass. Theres no way around it, if you're fuel line is too small, at some point the engine can starve for fuel in a boat..

Theres a hundred thousand guys on here, who've done what you're doing, with probably 2, or 3 times the power your making. Replace the stock fuel line and pickup with larger lines, run a Aeromotive pump, or other marine style electric pump, call it a day. Unless of course this melted piston thing is up your alley, forget the car stuff for boats.

Full Force 06-04-2013 03:28 PM


Originally Posted by MILD THUNDER (Post 3936831)
Yes, I know what a surge tank is. I can see you're a car guy. A surge tank can help, but its not designed for continuous Full throttle, like a boat does. It can work in a drag race application because theres normally enough fuel stored in the surge tank to complete a pass. Theres no way around it, if you're fuel line is too small, at some point the engine can starve for fuel in a boat..

Theres a hundred thousand guys on here, who've done what you're doing, with probably 2, or 3 times the power your making. Replace the stock fuel line and pickup with larger lines, run a Aeromotive pump, or other marine style electric pump, call it a day. Unless of course this melted piston thing is up your alley, forget the car stuff for boats.

Agree!!!

articfriends 06-04-2013 05:49 PM


Originally Posted by MILD THUNDER (Post 3936831)
Yes, I know what a surge tank is. I can see you're a car guy. A surge tank can help, but its not designed for continuous Full throttle, like a boat does. It can work in a drag race application because theres normally enough fuel stored in the surge tank to complete a pass. Theres no way around it, if you're fuel line is too small, at some point the engine can starve for fuel in a boat..

Theres a hundred thousand guys on here, who've done what you're doing, with probably 2, or 3 times the power your making. Replace the stock fuel line and pickup with larger lines, run a Aeromotive pump, or other marine style electric pump, call it a day. Unless of course this melted piston thing is up your alley, forget the car stuff for boats.

Thunder is completely right, that surge tank deal is sure cool looking but will do nothing after about 12-15 seconds of WOT, could even make your fuel pumps suck air as tank level gets too low, it will only support as much hp as the pump supplying the tank can put out after sustained wot, I'm not sure how you drive your boat but I have ran my flatout (with over 1000 hp) for 5plus minutes before, when it only had 700-750 hp ran it at wot for 20plus minutes, think more like endurance or Nascar than drag race when you pick your parts, Smitty

Mtuned 06-04-2013 07:45 PM

We use surge tanks in alot of road race applications. Not sure of you guys are aware that the RETURN line from the fuel system is also plummed back into a surge tank to function properly. So any excess fuel the regulator bleeds off will also fill back the surge tank, once the surge tank if full it bleeds back into the fuel cell...

Either way, i am certain you guys are correct that i can work around the stock feed line just fine. Its just the factory line on my boat and fittings were very small.

Thanks for the advise, I guess i will just go with a single weldon fuel pump and call it a day. I am trying to plan the fuel system to be able to support large demand, as I will be tuning it on E85 at some point with much larger injectors.

Tinkerer 06-04-2013 08:09 PM

Full force - Yes I know that some cylinders run hotter than others. That is why I have my EGT probes in the header for #6. BUT I have run a little too lean and done damage to one or two pistons - BUT - To completely destroy one piston I would think there would be SOME damage to another. If there was a bad injector or blocked fuel line I could see it. But that was ruled out and the electronics I believe was ruled out.
If it was timing then again I would expect damage on another cylinder. I would have thought there would have been at least one eyebrow deformed. Is it possible that that cylinder had more compression than the others? Less Quench? Loose spark plug?

articfriends 06-04-2013 08:51 PM


Originally Posted by Mtuned (Post 3937096)
We use surge tanks in alot of road race applications. Not sure of you guys are aware that the RETURN line from the fuel system is also plummed back into a surge tank to function properly. So any excess fuel the regulator bleeds off will also fill back the surge tank, once the surge tank if full it bleeds back into the fuel cell...

Either way, i am certain you guys are correct that i can work around the stock feed line just fine. Its just the factory line on my boat and fittings were very small.

Thanks for the advise, I guess i will just go with a single weldon fuel pump and call it a day. I am trying to plan the fuel system to be able to support large demand, as I will be tuning it on E85 at some point with much larger injectors.

I don't want to dwell on the surge tank since you are going to a weldon single anyways but do you understand what I am saying, no matter how much extra the bosch pumps dump back to the tank , after a certain period of sustained wot the max flow from the 255 dumping into the tank would be the max fuel you could get to the motor as it would be the only supply to the surge tank unless I am missing something? Its a cool looking set-up and I could see it working good on something where you were in and out of the throttle. In my case whenI went from 600 to 700 hp a aeromotive a1000 could not keep up under boost and I went to a Essex. When I went from 700hp to 950 hp a while back, I couldn't get enough fuel from that and I went to a aeromotive eliminator. When I went from 950 hp to the 1050-1100 I currently am running the eliminator wouldn't keep up so I added a voltage booster that sends voltage up to about 16 volts after 4-5 psi of boost. A big weldon would be a better set-up for me BUT I didn't want to overload the return regulator and lines and have to replumb everything again to handle the extra return when not into the throttle, I see since then they have a tick toc voltage reducer for that now. What are your hp goals in the future, these blower motors are fun and some is good, more is BETTER, Smitty

Full Force 06-04-2013 09:01 PM


Originally Posted by Tinkerer (Post 3937111)
Full force - Yes I know that some cylinders run hotter than others. That is why I have my EGT probes in the header for #6. BUT I have run a little too lean and done damage to one or two pistons - BUT - To completely destroy one piston I would think there would be SOME damage to another. If there was a bad injector or blocked fuel line I could see it. But that was ruled out and the electronics I believe was ruled out.
If it was timing then again I would expect damage on another cylinder. I would have thought there would have been at least one eyebrow deformed. Is it possible that that cylinder had more compression than the others? Less Quench? Loose spark plug?

I totally get that, just saying I have seen just ONE do that a few times before, many small things could cause it to be more lean then others... crazy things happen real fast under boost...

abones 06-04-2013 09:07 PM

I would be interested in seeing the spark plug from that Cyl. It should be able to tell us something,


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:40 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.