Offshoreonly.com

Offshoreonly.com (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/)
-   General Q & A (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q-20/)
-   -   Piston pic. (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q/332936-piston-pic.html)

mike tkach 12-07-2015 10:55 PM

i get a pretty good deal on j&e shelf pistons.

SB 12-08-2015 04:39 AM


Originally Posted by MILD THUNDER (Post 4382549)
Dan, if you were to use the piston rings JE suggests with those inverted dome 4.500 bore pistons, these would be them.

http://www.summitracing.com/parts/jep-j100f84500-5

http://www.jepistons.com/Products/257942.aspx

Summit Price $214.23

Amazon has 8 sets in stock. $167.31
http://amzn.com/B002VI2IYA

sutphen 30 12-08-2015 05:34 AM


Originally Posted by mike tkach (Post 4383261)
i get a pretty good deal on j&e shelf pistons.

those we won't work,,you need custom,,custom everything or the engine won't run right.:D

benjen 12-08-2015 08:51 AM


Originally Posted by sutphen 30 (Post 4383275)
those we won't work,,you need custom,,custom everything or the engine won't run right.:D

Very good..........that's actually pretty funny.

Bawana 12-08-2015 09:54 AM


Originally Posted by ICDEDPPL (Post 4383255)
Mike @ high Flow likes Flat top pistons .. his explanation was something to the effect of



I can`t swing new pistons so I`ll stick with what I have as along as they are still ok.

Dan I would use the pistons you have. What I do with my stuff & others ,is coat them. I have a blast cabinet that is only used for pistons. I ceramic coat the tops & teflon the skirts. The light scuffing on the skirt is gone after blasting and coating. I use a specific blast media per cal-coat, and then bake the pistons.

Bawana 12-08-2015 10:14 AM

1 Attachment(s)
[ATTACH=CONFIG]548531[/ATTACH] Here are some that I did that were slightly scuffed.

ICDEDPPL 12-08-2015 10:27 AM

Wow, nice work! Can I send you my pistons ?? :D
I`ll wait to see what needs to be done to the bores then decide coat pistons or 548ci. Might be nice to start with a fresh bores.

apollard 12-08-2015 10:28 AM


Originally Posted by MILD THUNDER (Post 4382533)
2010 Ford Supercharged 5.4L

Plasma Moly Carbon Steel Top ring

Mahle part 42112CP

http://catalog.mahle-aftermarket.com...rId=784222&d=t

6.0 LS GM Engine

Plasma Moly Carbon Steel top ring

Mahle #41858CP

http://catalog.mahle-aftermarket.com...rId=615547&d=t


6.4L SRT Hemi engine

Mahle #42156CP

Plasma moly Carbon Steel top ring

http://catalog.mahle-aftermarket.com...Id=1206357&d=t







Isnt "MOLY" a coating on the face of the ring, and "plasma" the process used to apply the coating? I've always assumed a top ring is either Steel, or iron, with a "MOLY" coating applied to the face. Pretty sure OEM's have been using moly faced steel top rings for some time now.

While what the car makers use is informative, one factor has to be considered - they absolutely do not use the same costing criteria we do. Another $20 (or even $200) for rings for us isn't an issue. Another $20 per engine for them better show another 20+ hp OR a reduction in warranty that more than offsets the cost.

Otherwise, the engineers are stuck using the cheapest ring that will get the job done.

Bawana 12-08-2015 10:28 AM

I don't put together a blower motor without coating the pistons. That stuff is Da bomb . I rebuilt a motor that a spring broke, piston hit the valve, put a big smiley in the piston. I thought oh ****, have to get new pistons, but after blasting the ceramic off, the smiley was only in the coating and slight mark on the piston. After recoating, it looked brand new. I have also noticed that the bottom of the pistons don't show any signs of burnt oil. I also used coated bearings on everything, The bearings are just a insurance thing, but I really think coating pistons helps a lot.

articfriends 12-08-2015 10:34 AM


Originally Posted by Bawana (Post 4383376)
I don't put together a blower motor without coating the pistons. That stuff is Da bomb . I rebuilt a motor that a spring broke, piston hit the valve, put a big smiley in the piston. I thought oh ****, have to get new pistons, but after blasting the ceramic off, the smiley was only in the coating and slight mark on the piston. After recoating, it looked brand new. I have also noticed that the bottom of the pistons don't show any signs of burnt oil. I also used coated bearings on everything, The bearings are just a insurance thing, but I really think coating pistons helps a lot.

I do same thing, swain tech gold coat top and std skirt coating, i used diamonds in house coating, was weak and wore off fwiw

MILD THUNDER 12-08-2015 05:15 PM


Originally Posted by apollard (Post 4383375)
While what the car makers use is informative, one factor has to be considered - they absolutely do not use the same costing criteria we do. Another $20 (or even $200) for rings for us isn't an issue. Another $20 per engine for them better show another 20+ hp OR a reduction in warranty that more than offsets the cost.

Otherwise, the engineers are stuck using the cheapest ring that will get the job done.

I hardly think the supercharged engine in LSX engine in the COPO camaro, that the engineers are worried about saving few bucks by going with a sub par piston ring package. I'm not talking about dodge caravans or a jeep liberty. If price was a concern for the supercharged COPO, would they be using a Callies Dragonslayer crankshaft? ATI TH-400 fully built transmission? Callies Ultra H beam rods? PSI Valvesprings? Titanium Valves? Fabricated Aluminum oil pan? ATI damper? They didn't cut corners there, and certainly could have used ANY piston ring they wanted, or piston for that matter. They used a Ductile Moly ring, and a 2618 Forged piston from Mahle.

Engineers working on the Hellcat Hemi, Vette engines, Copo engines, Viper engines, SVT teams, Mercury Racing, and so on, were some pretty sharp guys. IF there was a ring that lasted long, offered less oil consumption, more horspower, less emissions, they'll be using it. Do you honestly think, that IF GM went to Total seal, and said "hey, we want to offer you a contract to use your rings, in all our production vehicles (into the millions of vehicles), that they would pay the price you or I would in the summit catalog for them? Heck no. These guys aren't some redneck working out of a storage facility, with a harbor freight leakdown tester, claiming how they just chose the best rings ever, because they leaked down at 3 percent.

At the end of the day, my current hemi just had the engine replaced at 193,000 miles last week, due to a valve seat dropping. Up until that point, it didn't burn a drop of oil, a loss of power, smoke on decel, or anything like that. Whatever rings they used, at whatever price they paid, worked! That to me is what counts, and thats also what counts to them. They can't have a ring package that goes to chit by 100k miles, this isn't 1970 anymore. Cars are coming with 100k mile powertrain warrantys, and its in their best interest to use a quality part. they are not going to save a few bucks by putting in an inferior ring, that will cost them 10 times that down the road. They have to use what works.

So, my post in regards to what they are using, was to kind of show what works for them. I personally find that information, better than what I read on internet forums where guys blame ring styles for their issues, when in reality, it was nothing regarding the ring itself that failed, but their tune up, machine work, or installation methods that ultimately caused the failure.

abmotorman 12-08-2015 09:37 PM


Originally Posted by Bawana (Post 4383376)
I don't put together a blower motor without coating the pistons. That stuff is Da bomb . I rebuilt a motor that a spring broke, piston hit the valve, put a big smiley in the piston. I thought oh ****, have to get new pistons, but after blasting the ceramic off, the smiley was only in the coating and slight mark on the piston. After recoating, it looked brand new. I have also noticed that the bottom of the pistons don't show any signs of burnt oil. I also used coated bearings on everything, The bearings are just a insurance thing, but I really think coating pistons helps a lot.

Just curious, you coat over the babbitt? Wonder how that changes oil retention. I build large electric motors for power plants and we've recently seen direct concerns with using Chrome in a metalizing due to not being porous enough. Admittedly we are talking very large shafts with nonpressured oil systems. Uses oil rings as slingers. Do you have any technical data regarding this practice?

Bawana 12-08-2015 11:14 PM

I only do the pistons myself, I buy the bearings already coated. I do think there is a different procedure to do bearings.

sutphen 30 12-09-2015 06:02 AM


Originally Posted by MILD THUNDER (Post 4383501)
read on internet forums where guys blame ring styles for their issues, when in reality, it was nothing regarding the ring itself that failed, but their tune up, machine work, or installation methods that ultimately caused the failure.

very true,,to many dinosaur machine shops out there still.they just don't want to change w/ the times/machining processes and set up of the engine.

frickstyle 12-09-2015 08:40 AM

Dan, how many hours on those engines when this all went down?

ICDEDPPL 12-09-2015 09:15 AM

I never got around to putting an hour meter on the boat yet. GPS says 1750 miles.
Besides some old bilge/engine footage this was the last run of the year. Boat ran great!
Later I check the compression on the motor with the loose rotor, the first plug I pull has no ground strap and compression it`s 30, 60, 90, 95 on that side .. ..:traurig001:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_pedGaEyKdQ

I LOVE BOATS!

MILD THUNDER 12-09-2015 09:58 AM

Rotor coming loose is never a good thing. Combine a loose rotor, small cap distributor, and a electronic ignition box that pulls timing, it can turn into a real chit show inside the distributor.

Black Baja 12-09-2015 12:04 PM


Originally Posted by ICDEDPPL (Post 4383702)
I never got around to putting an hour meter on the boat yet. GPS says 1750 miles.
Besides some old bilge/engine footage this was the last run of the year. Boat ran great!
Later I check the compression on the motor with the loose rotor, the first plug I pull has no ground strap and compression it`s 30, 60, 90, 95 on that side .. ..:traurig001:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_pedGaEyKdQ

I LOVE BOATS!

What happen to the Stainless Marine exhaust?

apollard 12-09-2015 01:37 PM


Originally Posted by MILD THUNDER (Post 4383501)
I hardly think the supercharged engine in LSX engine in the COPO camaro, that the engineers are worried about saving few bucks by going with a sub par piston ring package. I'm not talking about dodge caravans or a jeep liberty. If price was a concern for the supercharged COPO, would they be using a Callies Dragonslayer crankshaft? ATI TH-400 fully built transmission? Callies Ultra H beam rods? PSI Valvesprings? Titanium Valves? Fabricated Aluminum oil pan? ATI damper? They didn't cut corners there, and certainly could have used ANY piston ring they wanted, or piston for that matter. They used a Ductile Moly ring, and a 2618 Forged piston from Mahle.

Engineers working on the Hellcat Hemi, Vette engines, Copo engines, Viper engines, SVT teams, Mercury Racing, and so on, were some pretty sharp guys. IF there was a ring that lasted long, offered less oil consumption, more horspower, less emissions, they'll be using it. Do you honestly think, that IF GM went to Total seal, and said "hey, we want to offer you a contract to use your rings, in all our production vehicles (into the millions of vehicles), that they would pay the price you or I would in the summit catalog for them? Heck no. These guys aren't some redneck working out of a storage facility, with a harbor freight leakdown tester, claiming how they just chose the best rings ever, because they leaked down at 3 percent.

At the end of the day, my current hemi just had the engine replaced at 193,000 miles last week, due to a valve seat dropping. Up until that point, it didn't burn a drop of oil, a loss of power, smoke on decel, or anything like that. Whatever rings they used, at whatever price they paid, worked! That to me is what counts, and thats also what counts to them. They can't have a ring package that goes to chit by 100k miles, this isn't 1970 anymore. Cars are coming with 100k mile powertrain warrantys, and its in their best interest to use a quality part. they are not going to save a few bucks by putting in an inferior ring, that will cost them 10 times that down the road. They have to use what works.

So, my post in regards to what they are using, was to kind of show what works for them. I personally find that information, better than what I read on internet forums where guys blame ring styles for their issues, when in reality, it was nothing regarding the ring itself that failed, but their tune up, machine work, or installation methods that ultimately caused the failure.

I'm not saying what they use in any engine can't be informative.

I work for a supplier to the automotive industry. What we supply includes items that go into the cars you mentioned; exactly what I can't say due to agreements we have with them. I can say all of them do in fact worry about saving $2 on each one of the high end cars. Hell, they worry about saving 2 cents. EVERY car produced, including their flagship cars, is given a massive cost analysis; we've lost contracts because the accountants overruled the engineers.

Exactly the same argument you use could be made for Mercury Racing, but they use the Bravo which many on here believe had many cost compromises in the gears and casing.

ICDEDPPL 12-09-2015 02:51 PM


Originally Posted by black baja (Post 4383751)
what happen to the stainless marine exhaust?


besides some old bilge/engine footage

I got no new bilge footage:stooges:

Black Baja 12-10-2015 09:18 AM


Originally Posted by ICDEDPPL (Post 4383794)
I got no new bilge footage:stooges:

Gotcha. Was thinking maybe they didn't fit.

ICDEDPPL 12-10-2015 09:32 AM

Not so much bling but no leak worries


http://33outlaw.zenfolio.com/img/s12...92116456-3.jpg

frickstyle 12-10-2015 11:33 AM

Function over form.

Do you think your Avatar lady really exists? :drool1: x1,000hp

SB 12-10-2015 12:38 PM


Originally Posted by frickstyle (Post 4384065)
Function over form.

Do you think your Avatar lady really exists? :drool1: x1,000hp

Yup. https://www.instagram.com/rosieroff/


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:51 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.