Are electric winches worth it? Looking at a used Powerwinch rc-30 or AP3500
#1
My parents 242 Formula is sitting on a roller trailer and has a hand crank winch on it now. To me it is a pain in the ass to have to winch it up the trailer about 8 feet. If I dunk the trailer deeper the boat WILL NOT center itself on the trailer, I have to just keep 1/2 the trailer in the water so the boat will center itself when coming up. I have thought about getting an electric winch and found a guy that has two Powerwinch RC-30 for sale on CL for a good price. My question is an electric boat trailer winch like the Powerwinch worth it? I trailer the boat quite a bit since I do not keep it in a well.
Last edited by phughes69; 10-06-2013 at 10:56 AM. Reason: added text
#2
Registered

Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,361
Likes: 7
From: Delaware, OH
I personal don't think it's a good idea for bunk trailers unless there is a load setting, I'd be afraid it would pull the eyelet out if you don't have enough trailer in the water. Roller though seems like the way to go. I see a lot of trailers with electric jacks and only a few with electric winches. In your case I don't see why not. But don't know a whole lot about them, sorry.
#3
Registered

Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 3,648
Likes: 32
From: Oneida Lake NY
I personal don't think it's a good idea for bunk trailers unless there is a load setting, I'd be afraid it would pull the eyelet out if you don't have enough trailer in the water. Roller though seems like the way to go. I see a lot of trailers with electric jacks and only a few with electric winches. In your case I don't see why not. But don't know a whole lot about them, sorry.
The eyelet in a well built boat will hold the weight of the boat vertical
#4
Registered

Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 3,648
Likes: 32
From: Oneida Lake NY
My parents 242 Formula is sitting on a roller trailer and has a hand crank winch on it now. To me it is a pain in the ass to have to winch it up the trailer about 8 feet. If I dunk the trailer deeper the boat WILL NOT center itself on the trailer, I have to just keep 1/2 the trailer in the water so the boat will center itself when coming up. I have thought about getting an electric winch and found a guy that has two Powerwinch RC-30 for sale on CL for a good price. My question is an electric boat trailer winch like the Powerwinch worth it? I trailer the boat quite a bit since I do not keep it in a well.
#5
Registered
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 956
Likes: 2
From: NE Indiana
I installed a 5,000 lb winch on the front of my trailer for my 272. It is also a bunk trailer.
Where I boat, the launch is nice and the boat hand floats onto the trailer until the bow touches the front v-guide. Let out about 2 more feet of cable and snap it on, then just hit the button. I have never been afraid about pulling the u-bolt out of the boat, but I am carful to not bend my trailer in half. 5,000 lbs is a bit much for a 6,000 pound boat!
One thing I did is I removed most of the cable from the winch, that way it is always on it's first wrap which gives you the most torque with the least amperage.
4bus, I am curious why you say a water tight box. I thought deep cycle batteries had to have airflow so they do not build up hydrogen gas. Is water tight for if you are around salt water or if the battery will be submerged? Mine is in a standard battery box on the front of the trailer. The bottom will touch the water, but it does not go in. Fresh water only. Same setup as my travel trailer actually, except I never back that down a boat ramp! The locking part I get though.
Brian
Where I boat, the launch is nice and the boat hand floats onto the trailer until the bow touches the front v-guide. Let out about 2 more feet of cable and snap it on, then just hit the button. I have never been afraid about pulling the u-bolt out of the boat, but I am carful to not bend my trailer in half. 5,000 lbs is a bit much for a 6,000 pound boat!
One thing I did is I removed most of the cable from the winch, that way it is always on it's first wrap which gives you the most torque with the least amperage.
4bus, I am curious why you say a water tight box. I thought deep cycle batteries had to have airflow so they do not build up hydrogen gas. Is water tight for if you are around salt water or if the battery will be submerged? Mine is in a standard battery box on the front of the trailer. The bottom will touch the water, but it does not go in. Fresh water only. Same setup as my travel trailer actually, except I never back that down a boat ramp! The locking part I get though.
Brian
#7
Registered
Joined: Sep 2011
Posts: 557
Likes: 4
From: Fox Island, WA
I have an RC30 and use the included pully block. I have a bunk trailer and a 29' Fountain with twin smallblocks and Bravo 1 drives. Since I load and unload the boat solo the wench makes this do-able. It comes with a remote (like a car keyfob) so you can get your boat centered, be inside the truck, and backup slowly as you power wench the boat on the trailer. I can't imagine not having it.
BTW - I have the wench powered by the standard car battery, an Optima Red Top, and keep the truck running while I am using the wench.
BTW - I have the wench powered by the standard car battery, an Optima Red Top, and keep the truck running while I am using the wench.
Last edited by Wes Burmark; 10-07-2013 at 08:23 PM.
#8
Registered

Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 3,648
Likes: 32
From: Oneida Lake NY
I
.
4bus, I am curious why you say a water tight box. I thought deep cycle batteries had to have airflow so they do not build up hydrogen gas. Is water tight for if you are around salt water or if the battery will be submerged? Mine is in a standard battery box on the front of the trailer. The bottom will touch the water, but it does not go in. Fresh water only. Same setup as my travel trailer actually, except I never back that down a boat ramp! The locking part I get though.
Brian
.
4bus, I am curious why you say a water tight box. I thought deep cycle batteries had to have airflow so they do not build up hydrogen gas. Is water tight for if you are around salt water or if the battery will be submerged? Mine is in a standard battery box on the front of the trailer. The bottom will touch the water, but it does not go in. Fresh water only. Same setup as my travel trailer actually, except I never back that down a boat ramp! The locking part I get though.
Brian
I said water tight for no maintenance. Of course you would need to run a sealed battery such as a vibration resistant AGM. I should have been more clear, maybe water resistant? And I was speaking more for road travel than launching. Our spring salt combined with rain will make quick work of exposed electrical connections on a trailer placed behind a vehicle. And yes sometimes we still have salt on the roads in May
#9
Registered

Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,361
Likes: 7
From: Delaware, OH
That's good to know that it won't pop out. Not to high jack this thread but what is it that people have to stop the boat instead of the rubber v stop or grooved wheel, instead there's to small carpeted blocks the stop the boat a little lower on the haul. I've seen a lot of fountain boats have them.
#10
Registered

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,306
Likes: 39
From: lockport ny
i have an electric winch on my top gun trailer. its nice not gonna lie. but in your situation i think boat guides in the rear of your trailer would be a lot more economical and would center your boat on the trailer allowing you to back your trailer in farther. not to sound like a d!ck by any means but i think a electric winch on a roller trailer is a little overkill for a 24ft boat.



