Water Heater question? Tankless??
#1
Trying to figure out if a Tankless water heater will supply enough hot/warm water for a short shower?
What units are being used for this?
Don't have space for a tank unit.
What units are being used for this?
Don't have space for a tank unit.
#2
Registered

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 1,102
Likes: 11
From: Granger, Indiana
We have an entire house operating a Bosch tank-less unit -- YOU CAN'T RUN OUT OF HOT WATER!!! Now this is a gas unit and I have no experience with electric systems but I'm sure they have been offered in other "RV" applications and I personally wouldn't think twice about getting one. The issue that you may experience is within your boat are you running a water softner - if not there is a potential for the heat exchange system to get mineral deposits and clog.
all the best
3pointstar
all the best
3pointstar
#3
With the on demand water heaters it is all about temperature rise. They will only raise X amount of gallons per minute X amount of degrees.
Up here in MI people that bought on demand water heaters when we have very cold winter temps have a surprise when they can't get a hot shower.
When you have city water the water lines are buried 6 or more feet down and can freeze if it is cold enough long enough. The on demand water heaters can't heat this very cold water up enough to have a decent hot shower.
Up here in MI people that bought on demand water heaters when we have very cold winter temps have a surprise when they can't get a hot shower.
When you have city water the water lines are buried 6 or more feet down and can freeze if it is cold enough long enough. The on demand water heaters can't heat this very cold water up enough to have a decent hot shower.
#7
Registered
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 1,879
Likes: 8
From: Southeast Michigan
With the on demand water heaters it is all about temperature rise. They will only raise X amount of gallons per minute X amount of degrees.
Up here in MI people that bought on demand water heaters when we have very cold winter temps have a surprise when they can't get a hot shower.
When you have city water the water lines are buried 6 or more feet down and can freeze if it is cold enough long enough. The on demand water heaters can't heat this very cold water up enough to have a decent hot shower.
Up here in MI people that bought on demand water heaters when we have very cold winter temps have a surprise when they can't get a hot shower.
When you have city water the water lines are buried 6 or more feet down and can freeze if it is cold enough long enough. The on demand water heaters can't heat this very cold water up enough to have a decent hot shower.
But regarding the underground water lines freezing, it was explained to me by a physics teacher long ago; the temperature of a well digger's arse near the surface is close to whatever the ambient temperature is, and the temperature of a well digger's arse at 6ft below the surface will be around 42-50*, and almost always above freezing. Yes, occasionally underground lines freeze and burst, but there's a reason you can get well water in the winter, a reason for the frost line, and a reason geothermal pumps work- geothermal heat. So even at 33*, a decent sized unit will churn it out at 105-110* and 3gpm. Below that, nobody gets a shower- not you, or the neighbors, because the pipes would be frozen.
https://www.libertywholesalesupply.c...ai_flow_chart/
Power outages....The power outage situation can be handled by a backup that sparks the pilot, so as long as you have fuel you have hot water. In the old days that 40 gallons of hot water in a tank meant you could shower before the power company got to work. With electric that's a moot point.
We have a Rinai in our house, never had a cold shower. Flushing the heat exchanger with a bucket, pump, and vinegar is a routine maintenance requirement. I would never recommend tankless to a man with a wife and daughters; your bathroom will be a sauna and you'll never be able to drop a deuce.
A friend had a couple 110v tankless units in his cottage when he first bought it. The sink was always good pressure and temp, but the shower didn't work as well. He switched to a whole house propane unit, they regularly have a half dozen people showering on weekends and no one gets a cold shower. Just prepare to have a bath fan the size of helicopter to get rid of all the moisture.
Last edited by Speedracer29; 01-13-2017 at 09:28 AM.
#9
Registered
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 1,879
Likes: 8
From: Southeast Michigan
The only way to really solve this is two boats, one with a tank, one tankless. Put good looking women in each, and record the results for scientific purposes. Feel free to post the video footage. Purely for science and advancement, of course.




