Cast vs ductile(nodular) vs billet flywheels
#1
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Nov 2015
Posts: 207
Likes: 8
Building another blower motor 454 with a 6-71. Has a forged eagle internal balance crank and won't be spun past 5500 rpm. Should be around 600hp and 600 ft lbs. I have a cast flywheel but I'm wondering if I should step up to ductile iron(nodular) or billet.
Edit: Forgot to mention this is a standard bravo type application.
I thought the billet pieces were mostly for high rpm and I'm not sure if anything other than cast is necessary in a marine application where there is no clutch/shock loading.
Opinions?
Thanks,
Travis
Edit: Forgot to mention this is a standard bravo type application.
I thought the billet pieces were mostly for high rpm and I'm not sure if anything other than cast is necessary in a marine application where there is no clutch/shock loading.
Opinions?
Thanks,
Travis
Last edited by 89Force235; 12-04-2017 at 01:42 PM.
#2
Registered
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 240
Likes: 2
From: Mt Martha Australia
Travis
This is good question as I was also going through sorting out my flywheels and wasn't sure whether should run aluminium (10lb), or steel flywheel, as have one steel flywheel which is 13lb, 28lb and 30lb in weight
In fact got me thinking of actually using my trans-blanket previously used on power glide dragcar and adapting to mercruiser bell-housing for safety
You can never be too careful, I suppose it comes down to what gear you got lying around
This is good question as I was also going through sorting out my flywheels and wasn't sure whether should run aluminium (10lb), or steel flywheel, as have one steel flywheel which is 13lb, 28lb and 30lb in weight
In fact got me thinking of actually using my trans-blanket previously used on power glide dragcar and adapting to mercruiser bell-housing for safety
You can never be too careful, I suppose it comes down to what gear you got lying around
#3
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Nov 2015
Posts: 207
Likes: 8
Thanks for the reply. I don't know if a flywheel has ever exploded without the shock loading of a clutch and hard shifting but certainly don't want one going through my engine hatch or the bottom of my boat or worse... I ran a cast one at the same rpm and around 525 hp or so previously. It didn't occur to me that it could be an issue until I considered the new engine. Not really too concerned about the weight, if anything I'll stay heavy to help with shifting at idle.
I think this time around I will at the least I'll step up to the ductile(nodular).
I think this time around I will at the least I'll step up to the ductile(nodular).
#4
Registered

Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 8,356
Likes: 1,515
From: NW Michigan
I'm not so sure the rpm would be an issue as much as the heat is with cast. I've heard some horror stories over the years. Cast and hp and heat can be catastrophic. If your only dealing with one engine I'd consider spending the extra money to be on the safe side. Like you mentioned though most the bad day stories I've heard about where at the track and not marine. We've run stock 454/365 mag flywheels in blown applications pushing 700 hp without any issues.
Will be interesting to see what others have have to say. You can always search for a good used one at half the price or purchase a new one from 250-300 if your concerned. Cheap insurance policy. One thing I know for sure is I wouldn't wanna be in the back seat if one ever let go in a boat.
Will be interesting to see what others have have to say. You can always search for a good used one at half the price or purchase a new one from 250-300 if your concerned. Cheap insurance policy. One thing I know for sure is I wouldn't wanna be in the back seat if one ever let go in a boat.
#6
Registered

Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 8,356
Likes: 1,515
From: NW Michigan
Also the cast flywheel you currently have I'm assuming is or you had neutrally balanced and same goes for balancer as f-2 mentioned. What gen 454 do you have? My ati flywheels are near 50 pds if I recall. Not a bad thing for marine but....
#8
Registered

Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 14,100
Likes: 3,687
From: On A Dirt Floor
Please laugh (vs getting rubbed the wrong way) at this statement. That makes as much sense as buying a 1986 Hyundai Excell for your Significant other whom has along commute thru bad neighborhoods.



