32 active thunder or 35 fountain
#21
Registered
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 4,496
Likes: 1
From: Lk. st. Clair MI
Cabin? Fountain is way small. AT is ok with a sink and head. PP is biggest but lacks amenities...
#26
Most of our boating is on a very big lake that can get very rough. my concern is being bored with driving it. I'm coming from a 26 American Offshore that is a blast to drive but requires skill to handle in the rough. I'm looking for something that can handle the rough but you have to drive it not just point & go. I like the deep cockpit of the AT but have never been in one. I've driven a couple 33 powerplays & I love them except for the driving position & somewhat shallow cockpit. There's nothing like running a boat with good balance that responds to the trim & throttles.
#27
Registered
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 177
Likes: 0
From: Kemah,TX
You can't really go wrong with either boat. Both have classic lines, the 35 with a fairing looks awesome. The 35 will run away from the thunder with the same power. That being said, having driven a 35 for a distance and owning an AT, I personally like the feeling of the AT's deep cockpit, You are really "in the boat" at the helm. It's really a matter of comfort for your choice (deep cockpit,right hand throttles vs. shallower cockpit and left hand throttles), and the difference of having a production boat or one that is more exclusive. Both will hold their value, but I like pulling up somewhere and not seeing three or four of my boat already there.....
#28
You can't really go wrong with either boat. Both have classic lines, the 35 with a fairing looks awesome. The 35 will run away from the thunder with the same power. That being said, having driven a 35 for a distance and owning an AT, I personally like the feeling of the AT's deep cockpit, You are really "in the boat" at the helm. It's really a matter of comfort for your choice (deep cockpit,right hand throttles vs. shallower cockpit and left hand throttles), and the difference of having a production boat or one that is more exclusive. Both will hold their value, but I like pulling up somewhere and not seeing three or four of my boat already there.....

#29
There is some skewing here as some people are comparing the 37 AT to the 35 Fountain.
Some facts:
The 32 AT is a deeper boat. You will be more IN the 32 AT, vs. ON the 35 Fountain.
The 32 AT rides like a bigger boat. It's a wave crusher of a hull.
The 35 Fountain will be faster, HP for HP all things equal.
The 35 Fountain will be "wetter." OSO member ActiveShack had a 35 Fountain, and he said in the chop and slop, the boat was always throwing water in the cockpit and over the boat. Those are his words, not mine. I've never seen, or heard this complaint of the 32 AT.
The 32 AT will be a bit easier to work on. Get inside the bilge on both boats and picture yourself changing sparkplugs and impellers.
(Couple good pics of 32 AT access here: http://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/a...pic-heavy.html )
Depending on the 32 AT you are looking at... side entry or center entry, the cabin will have a completely different "feel" compared to the Fountain.
Good luck with your decision. You can't go wrong either way--all depends how you want the boat to perform for your needs.
Some facts:
The 32 AT is a deeper boat. You will be more IN the 32 AT, vs. ON the 35 Fountain.
The 32 AT rides like a bigger boat. It's a wave crusher of a hull.
The 35 Fountain will be faster, HP for HP all things equal.
The 35 Fountain will be "wetter." OSO member ActiveShack had a 35 Fountain, and he said in the chop and slop, the boat was always throwing water in the cockpit and over the boat. Those are his words, not mine. I've never seen, or heard this complaint of the 32 AT.
The 32 AT will be a bit easier to work on. Get inside the bilge on both boats and picture yourself changing sparkplugs and impellers.
(Couple good pics of 32 AT access here: http://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/a...pic-heavy.html )
Depending on the 32 AT you are looking at... side entry or center entry, the cabin will have a completely different "feel" compared to the Fountain.
Good luck with your decision. You can't go wrong either way--all depends how you want the boat to perform for your needs.
Last edited by Sydwayz; 04-26-2013 at 11:13 AM.
#30
Registered

Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 785
Likes: 84
From: Lake Wallenpaupack, PA
this is an interesting thread and I'm enjoying the info. I'm surprised that people say the Fountain has a small cabin. I always thought that cabin looked really luxurious and roomy (never been in one). My impression of the Powerplay has always been that it looks really low and small. Never been on one of them either! The AT looks very deep and large. I have no valuable insight here, just commenting from a newbie.





