502 mpi gen v rebuild - advice needed
#11
Smitty the MEFI 3 and 4 do check to make sure the knock sensor is working, main reason I know is it kept showing up on my motor. It checks when the motor is first throttled up for a split second and does not check again until a restart. If it doesn't get a knock it sets a code 44 and doesn't allow the timing to fully advance. Mine was a bad connection on the connector, so I bought a pig tail and replaced and a MEFI 3.
Don't know if the 555 and higher does or not
Don't know if the 555 and higher does or not
#12
Registered

Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,211
Likes: 145
[QUOTE=articfriends;4486161]Yes by the bulletin date and more specifically the serial numbers mentioned within the bulletin. Merc altered the test later to preclude this as being an issue.
#13
[QUOTE=Trash;4486193]Ever heard of it on a mefi 3 or four?, I know on passenger car when you first start them if the KNOCK sensor is shorted out or has an open circuit with no resistance whatsoever it could throw a code but I've never heard of a mefi 3 or four testing actual knock upon start up based on octane and then deciding to go to a limp default mode?
#15
Thread Starter
Registered
Joined: Jul 2013
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
So I just left the engine shop and this motor has already been rebuilt once before. Also a roller cam was added at the first rebuild. Bearings are not horrible and Pistons have light scuffing on the skirts. Probably only needs a honing and new Pistons/rings and head job. Probably only needed to replace head gaskets. I should have pulled the heads before sending it off but oh well I'll have a fresh engine again. If I knew more about having the ECM programmed and wanted to buy some good exhaust I would try to wake it up a little bit but just staying stock.
#16
Registered

Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,211
Likes: 145
[QUOTE=articfriends;4486264]
I have not. This is the only bulletin I've seen regarding this issue. I ran into it way back in 1994 when these motors first came out.
Ever heard of it on a mefi 3 or four?, I know on passenger car when you first start them if the KNOCK sensor is shorted out or has an open circuit with no resistance whatsoever it could throw a code but I've never heard of a mefi 3 or four testing actual knock upon start up based on octane and then deciding to go to a limp default mode?
#17
[QUOTE=Trash;4486527]I called bob at mefiburn and he told me that indeed there IS this possibility on some, not all, mefi3's and 4s, he said. The essiest way to ensure it never happens Is to un-check the flag for code44, knock sensor will still work IF it sees knock but wont do no unexpected things do to a start up table.
#18
Registered

Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,211
Likes: 145
[QUOTE=articfriends;4488323]
I called bob at mefiburn and he told me that indeed there IS this possibility on some, not all, mefi3's and 4s, he said. The essiest way to ensure it never happens Is to un-check the flag for code44, knock sensor will still work IF it sees knock but wont do no unexpected things do to a start up table.
Thanks for passing that info on!
I called bob at mefiburn and he told me that indeed there IS this possibility on some, not all, mefi3's and 4s, he said. The essiest way to ensure it never happens Is to un-check the flag for code44, knock sensor will still work IF it sees knock but wont do no unexpected things do to a start up table.
#19
I looked at several tunes I have, looks like most the stuff Tyler crockett has done has #44 unchecked, a stock hp 500 does have it checked but there are other things in the tune that will affect wether it "test" knock sensor and what it does IF it doesnt see knock on intital startup, some you can see with std mefi burn, some you need mefi pro to see,seems strange that merc had a bulletin saying it was a concern on early mefi1s but not a concern later, Bob wasnt specific as to what had it and didnt have it ie maybe stock ramjet 502 does but not mercruiser fwiw, Smitty
Last edited by articfriends; 10-05-2016 at 01:19 PM.
#20
IF I dyno my stock hp500 efis this winter I will check timing at a certain map/rpm then disconnect the knock sensor and see if total timing is reduced somewhere and post my results, will be after January probably though, Smitty





