First Drive Failure, Swinging for the Fence
#1
For background info 2005 Formula Fastech 353, 525EFI, XR drives, 28P 5 Blade Maximus, with ITS. Our boat has 311 hours on it, we purchased it January 2013 with 260ish hours, 1 previous owner. Boat always would chatter getting on plane whether it was a slow gradual feed or pushing it a little harder but never high RPM. Sent props to BBlades over the winter and Brent dialed out the chatter and we only lost 1.5 MPH off top speed. We were cruising along on the second leg of LEOPA Thunderfest and the boat went into a neutral, it took me a few seconds to gather myself off the dash and get situated boat kicked back in and that's when you really hear the coffee grinder at full tilt.
Reason I bring up the chatter and my fix, is it possible the gears were just weak or beat over time from that condition? The people who owned the boat before us had kids and idled for nearly 200hrs on a river and when they did use the boat it was in the very low RPM range.
Anyway, the drive is broke and replacing with a whole new unit. Do I get some kind of Bravo "kill" sticker or at least a smiley face for the fridge?
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvdMtd2npM8
[ATTACH=CONFIG]527269[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]527270[/ATTACH]
Reason I bring up the chatter and my fix, is it possible the gears were just weak or beat over time from that condition? The people who owned the boat before us had kids and idled for nearly 200hrs on a river and when they did use the boat it was in the very low RPM range.
Anyway, the drive is broke and replacing with a whole new unit. Do I get some kind of Bravo "kill" sticker or at least a smiley face for the fridge?
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvdMtd2npM8
[ATTACH=CONFIG]527269[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]527270[/ATTACH]
#5
Registered
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 715
Likes: 0
From: Michigan
5 blades on XR's are a grenade waiting to happen. Just talked to a buddy today with the same boat, he went through 4 drives with the 5 blades before switching to a 4 blade(not sure pitch but think 32's) and no problems since.
#7
Consistent 83 MPH with occasional 84. The 84s were before I had BBlades work the props to eliminate the chatter getting on plane. It runs out well, not the fastest 35' out there but it fits what we need it to do.
#8
Registered

Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 3,648
Likes: 32
From: Oneida Lake NY
For background info 2005 Formula Fastech 353, 525EFI, XR drives, 28P 5 Blade Maximus, with ITS. Our boat has 311 hours on it, we purchased it January 2013 with 260ish hours, 1 previous owner. Boat always would chatter getting on plane whether it was a slow gradual feed or pushing it a little harder but never high RPM. Sent props to BBlades over the winter and Brent dialed out the chatter and we only lost 1.5 MPH off top speed. We were cruising along on the second leg of LEOPA Thunderfest and the boat went into a neutral, it took me a few seconds to gather myself off the dash and get situated boat kicked back in and that's when you really hear the coffee grinder at full tilt.
Reason I bring up the chatter and my fix, is it possible the gears were just weak or beat over time from that condition? The people who owned the boat before us had kids and idled for nearly 200hrs on a river and when they did use the boat it was in the very low RPM range.
Anyway, the drive is broke and replacing with a whole new unit. Do I get some kind of Bravo "kill" sticker or at least a smiley face for the fridge?
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvdMtd2npM8
[ATTACH=CONFIG]527269[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]527270[/ATTACH]
Reason I bring up the chatter and my fix, is it possible the gears were just weak or beat over time from that condition? The people who owned the boat before us had kids and idled for nearly 200hrs on a river and when they did use the boat it was in the very low RPM range.
Anyway, the drive is broke and replacing with a whole new unit. Do I get some kind of Bravo "kill" sticker or at least a smiley face for the fridge?
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvdMtd2npM8
[ATTACH=CONFIG]527269[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]527270[/ATTACH]
Time to tear down the other one as well.
#9
VIP Member

Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 4,176
Likes: 333
From: ankeny,ia.
Kind of ruins your day doesn't it ?
I've had the pleasure of experiencing that twice....at least the 2nd time wasn't on my boat.
With XR's, your new drive may last a while, or the gears may start falling apart real soon...I've seen it go both ways.
I've had the pleasure of experiencing that twice....at least the 2nd time wasn't on my boat.
With XR's, your new drive may last a while, or the gears may start falling apart real soon...I've seen it go both ways.




