Drive recommendations please
#11
VIP Member

Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 4,176
Likes: 333
From: ankeny,ia.
So XR's are still on the bad list? There are a couple of 100mph cats on my lake that are running them, I know cats are a whole different game. One guy says the old XRs are better and the other guy says he used to blow up old ones, and the newest versions are the best. I have noticed most of the guys on here dont have very nice things to say about XR's, so unless something has recently changed, I kinda figured XR's would not be the choice. I would need standard length lowers, as the boat handles, planes and performs awesome right now. I have transom mount water pick ups and the drive pick ups are used for the IMCO showers, would this be a problem with your 2 suggested picks ?
break a tooth off and that loose tooth will try to make its way between
the drive and driven gears, then something has to move to allow that to
happen, and it’s generally the case snout right behind the pinion retainer nut, when that happens, you’re replacing the upper.
The 1st set of gears I bought were $1400 in 05’. now they’re $2500
thats about all the “improvement” I’ve witnessed.
Several years ago I sent several failed sets to BUP (that use to be on here)
he had a a gear guru he knew and his findings were that they were getting hot.
I had the same set up as yours ( boxes , external pick ups)
I also did mods to dump a lot of water to the top of the drives,
but ended up selling the boat later in the year, so I really don’t
have any results if it helped that much.


#13
Registered

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,613
Likes: 375
From: Traverse City MI
Get a spare set of bravos of whatever variation, swap when it's time to rebuild yours, and repeat. Less downtime and cheaper boating. Don't go crazy with upgrades cause you will never be happy. Try your best to just be happy with what you have and spend your money on using the boat more, and maintaining it.
Too much to explain but there's no drive upgrade that makes financial sense.
Nice boat though 342 run good and have a nice cabin and cockpit. Enjoy!
Too much to explain but there's no drive upgrade that makes financial sense.
Nice boat though 342 run good and have a nice cabin and cockpit. Enjoy!
#14
VIP Member

Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 1,225
Likes: 769
From: Wichita, Kansas
It does seem somewhat at odds with having made a statement about finances being limited (or at least that is how I took it) and then considering a series of upgrades that are very expensive...and likely far less reliable. Yes, it is hard to "leave things alone", lol...but there is the point of diminishing returns to consider, too. You never did say what sort of speed gains you're looking for? I am no expert but it seems a 400 - 500 hp increase from where you are at now, running 80 mph, might only yield another 12 - 15 mph? Just curious. There have been a lot of threads over the years where people spent big money on power upgrades yet didn't see anywhere near the expected results.
That 342 is a great boat, I'll bet it's a blast!
That 342 is a great boat, I'll bet it's a blast!
__________________
Baja 252 Islander
Baja 252 Islander
#15
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 197
Likes: 259
From: park hill OK
The weak link is the XR upper gears, the’ll chunk out or in some cases,
break a tooth off and that loose tooth will try to make its way between
the drive and driven gears, then something has to move to allow that to
happen, and it’s generally the case snout right behind the pinion retainer nut, when that happens, you’re replacing the upper.
The 1st set of gears I bought were $1400 in 05’. now they’re $2500
thats about all the “improvement” I’ve witnessed.
Several years ago I sent several failed sets to BUP (that use to be on here)
he had a a gear guru he knew and his findings were that they were getting hot.
I had the same set up as yours ( boxes , external pick ups)
I also did mods to dump a lot of water to the top of the drives,
but ended up selling the boat later in the year, so I really don’t
have any results if it helped that much.


break a tooth off and that loose tooth will try to make its way between
the drive and driven gears, then something has to move to allow that to
happen, and it’s generally the case snout right behind the pinion retainer nut, when that happens, you’re replacing the upper.
The 1st set of gears I bought were $1400 in 05’. now they’re $2500
thats about all the “improvement” I’ve witnessed.
Several years ago I sent several failed sets to BUP (that use to be on here)
he had a a gear guru he knew and his findings were that they were getting hot.
I had the same set up as yours ( boxes , external pick ups)
I also did mods to dump a lot of water to the top of the drives,
but ended up selling the boat later in the year, so I really don’t
have any results if it helped that much.


#16
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 197
Likes: 259
From: park hill OK
It does seem somewhat at odds with having made a statement about finances being limited (or at least that is how I took it) and then considering a series of upgrades that are very expensive...and likely far less reliable. Yes, it is hard to "leave things alone", lol...but there is the point of diminishing returns to consider, too. You never did say what sort of speed gains you're looking for? I am no expert but it seems a 400 - 500 hp increase from where you are at now, running 80 mph, might only yield another 12 - 15 mph? Just curious. There have been a lot of threads over the years where people spent big money on power upgrades yet didn't see anywhere near the expected results.
That 342 is a great boat, I'll bet it's a blast!
That 342 is a great boat, I'll bet it's a blast!
#17
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 197
Likes: 259
From: park hill OK
Get a spare set of bravos of whatever variation, swap when it's time to rebuild yours, and repeat. Less downtime and cheaper boating. Don't go crazy with upgrades cause you will never be happy. Try your best to just be happy with what you have and spend your money on using the boat more, and maintaining it.
Too much to explain but there's no drive upgrade that makes financial sense.
Nice boat though 342 run good and have a nice cabin and cockpit. Enjoy!
Too much to explain but there's no drive upgrade that makes financial sense.
Nice boat though 342 run good and have a nice cabin and cockpit. Enjoy!
#18
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 197
Likes: 259
From: park hill OK
I’d have to agree with Quinlan. Refresh what you have, if need be, and stay in the reliable bravo range. 82 is a very respectable speed and Bajas just weren’t designed to go much faster. Doesn’t matter what make it is, do you really want to dump $40k+/- on just drives on 22yr old boat?
#19
VIP Member

Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 4,176
Likes: 333
From: ankeny,ia.
#20
Registered
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 8,527
Likes: 706
From: Taunton Ma
I’d love to add whipples to my boat and get it well past 100, but right now it runs great, pretty fast, and doesn’t break. If I spend 25k putting whipples on I’ll need to spend another 35+ for imco scx drives. At that point I’d just sell it and buy a 700/nxt boat.



