Probably both are right. I have seen pics of a 40' or 41' Hustler with a paintjob very similar to that 46' Cig.

I have seen a 41ish,white w/blue spider web grafs on the St. Croix.Ben a few years,but I think this is a Minn. boat.

The one with the spider web on the side was a MN boat. I am not sure where it ended up, but the owner now owns a blue and yellow 50' Hustler "Nasty Girl"

the last time i saw that Hustler it was still on the isalnd and it was for sale , i'm gonna sya 6 years ago. Never seen it since
I have pictures of it somewhere from the 94 or 95 NY boat show. those motors looked awesome , never wanted to know the repair bills on those things

Where is nasty girl at , saw it was for sale again a couple of years ago and had not seen it since
great boat
knew of it when the original owner had it

Thats a 40 Hustler with copy graphics from the 46 Cigarette in question.

Nasty girl is north of Minneapolis and St Paul MN