CMC

http://www.orchidkey.com/

SLOWRIDE-388

Pier House, right across street from Ocean Key, lil pricy but very nice, right on the water, small beach, pool, etc..

Fast-Truckin

We stayed at the Westin Right on the mallory pier.Nice pool+hot tub.Loved the breakfast on the water.I used my american express starwoods points.It was 12000 pts for a garden view room with a balcony.Ive also stayed at the pier house.Long ago with my x-wife.We came down by boat and on the way back home(key largo)I cracked the hull.We took on water and just made it back to the ramp. I got it out before it sank and saved the motor.

BRAVEHEART

Try VRBO.com Lots of inventory, multiple locations and prices. I use them all the time. We booked another week there the beginning of March too...