Broker vs. Privite party sale
#1
VP of the tickfaw200
Thread Starter
Broker vs. Privite party sale
Have been looking into a few boats over the past 2 weeks some are brokered boats and some are not. What are the pro's to a brokered boat compaired to privite party or the other way around. Have had a few dealing that were not so pleasent with both.
#2
Registered
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Northern, KY (Cincinnati) Lake St Clair, MI Norris Lake, TN
Posts: 1,130
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
1 Post
I've bought 3 private party and 2 brokered boats.
There may be more wiggle room on price if a private party doesn't have to pay the 7-10% brokerage fees.
Hopefully the broker is also a dealer that can scan and verify hours, facilitate a sea trial, help with some paperwork, etc. Maybe they serviced the boat in the past? Sold it new? At the same time they could know absolutley nothing about the boat. Broker may have to collect sales tax.
One of the brokered boat I bought, the dealer was helpful in tracking down a trailer title. Boat was in a title state originally, being sold in a non-title state. I flipped it and was going to a title state....it was a mess.
In the end it's up to you, the buyer, to cover your bases. Get a survey, arrange financing, a test ride and cut your best deal.
There may be more wiggle room on price if a private party doesn't have to pay the 7-10% brokerage fees.
Hopefully the broker is also a dealer that can scan and verify hours, facilitate a sea trial, help with some paperwork, etc. Maybe they serviced the boat in the past? Sold it new? At the same time they could know absolutley nothing about the boat. Broker may have to collect sales tax.
One of the brokered boat I bought, the dealer was helpful in tracking down a trailer title. Boat was in a title state originally, being sold in a non-title state. I flipped it and was going to a title state....it was a mess.
In the end it's up to you, the buyer, to cover your bases. Get a survey, arrange financing, a test ride and cut your best deal.
Last edited by Baja_342; 01-12-2012 at 09:12 AM.
#3
Registered
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: The Woodlands, TX
Posts: 830
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I always prefer a private party sale over any middleman taking a cut of my sale or the inability of my offer price to cover the sellers lowest price and his brokers fee.
I like to offer 20% with my "offer to purchase contract" for the down payment and subject the unit to a survey.
I do this on used truck and car, excavation equipment, dumptrucks, and boats etc..
If a seller gets edgy or unwilling I retract my offer and move on.
I hate to say that I think they're hiding something but you never know until a mechanic looks at it. During a sale I also offer my buyer the opportunity to do the same and will deliver to the auto shop of his choice.
Your BEST SERVED having a Pro look at any used mechanical vehicle before you consummate the deal, especially older ones.
See ya,
Kelly
I like to offer 20% with my "offer to purchase contract" for the down payment and subject the unit to a survey.
I do this on used truck and car, excavation equipment, dumptrucks, and boats etc..
If a seller gets edgy or unwilling I retract my offer and move on.
I hate to say that I think they're hiding something but you never know until a mechanic looks at it. During a sale I also offer my buyer the opportunity to do the same and will deliver to the auto shop of his choice.
Your BEST SERVED having a Pro look at any used mechanical vehicle before you consummate the deal, especially older ones.
See ya,
Kelly
#4
VP of the tickfaw200
Thread Starter
Seeing fast I like the privit sellers much better. No offense to any brokers on here. Just getting answers and dealing with 3 people in 3 diffrent places with each state having diffrent ways of doing things. It's a lot of hassle. Plus knowing the market isn't great and still not wanting to deal or even call you with what you inquired about.
#6
Registered
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Thousand Islands area
Posts: 2,349
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
3 Posts
Private party. Broker is just a middle man and is going to end up costing you 10-20%. If i found a boat at a broker Im not saying I wouldnt buy.
The last boat I had was a nightmare with the broker, never go that route again. They want to be so helpful then when something goes wrong they drop you like a box of rocks and claim no ownership
The last boat I had was a nightmare with the broker, never go that route again. They want to be so helpful then when something goes wrong they drop you like a box of rocks and claim no ownership
#8
Gold Member
Gold Member
I've bought from a broker and private party. As far as selling, I've only done that myself. Overall, my experiences were good on all purchases and sales.
I guess I prefer private party. I've become friends with the guy who bought my last boat and he knows he can call me anytime with questions. Same thing with the guy I bought my current boat from. He is just a phone call or email away.
I guess I prefer private party. I've become friends with the guy who bought my last boat and he knows he can call me anytime with questions. Same thing with the guy I bought my current boat from. He is just a phone call or email away.
#10
Registered
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Thousand Islands area
Posts: 2,349
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
3 Posts
But I agree not dealing with an owner can be a bonus. A lot of current owners are way upside down on their boats right now. But thats what you get for taking out a 20 year loans on something you couldnt afford from the start.