Cat v Vee ... a seriously, curiously ignorant question
01-25-2013, 06:45 PM
#1
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: SW1
Posts: 141
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cat v Vee ... a seriously, curiously ignorant question
I have just finished re-reading both of T2x 'History of ...' threads. Fascinating and informative, but also curiosity-making.
Caveats to my question:
<drumroll> Why are Cats not on more open ocean podiums? </drumroll>
Bob
Caveats to my question:
- I would have to go to school for three years to get up to the level of 'Ignernt' about American racing, so if I step on toes, it's b/c I have big feet, not that I am looking for toes to mash.
- I am (only minimally) less ignorant abt UIM rules and classes; European marathon & endurance racing.
Those two stipulations having been given: I did not fall off a turnip truck when it crossed the RR tracks coming into town. I absolutely know that Politic$ and Rule$ are $ignificant in all $port$.- I am (only minimally) less ignorant abt UIM rules and classes; European marathon & endurance racing.
<drumroll> Why are Cats not on more open ocean podiums? </drumroll>
Bob
Gold Member
...
01-25-2013, 06:57 PM
#4
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: SW1
Posts: 141
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
VIP Member
01-25-2013, 10:54 PM
#6
Registered
iTrader: (5)
I understand where the OP is coming from. Its hard to honestly understand and believe in ANYTHING that has to do with Go Fast boats.
Politics
Money
Marketing (false/exaggeration)
No real test Data
No honest opinion from professionals
Rumors
Lies
Every boat manufacture does "great in rough water", "fastest", "best handling" etc etc. They all claim this and that but never have proof. There are no head to head tests like there are in sports cars. No test showing how many G's they can take in a corner.
I understand both sides but yes it would be nice to see some science, test, and proof on if a Cat actually is good in the rough, do step hulls really help, etc etc.
No matter what I am addicted to Powerboats and understand how challenging what I ask for is (not going to list all the B.S) but that still does not mean we can't wish for it.
Politics
Money
Marketing (false/exaggeration)
No real test Data
No honest opinion from professionals
Rumors
Lies
Every boat manufacture does "great in rough water", "fastest", "best handling" etc etc. They all claim this and that but never have proof. There are no head to head tests like there are in sports cars. No test showing how many G's they can take in a corner.
I understand both sides but yes it would be nice to see some science, test, and proof on if a Cat actually is good in the rough, do step hulls really help, etc etc.
No matter what I am addicted to Powerboats and understand how challenging what I ask for is (not going to list all the B.S) but that still does not mean we can't wish for it.
01-25-2013, 10:59 PM
#7
Banned
iTrader: (1)
I have just finished re-reading both of T2x 'History of ...' threads. Fascinating and informative, but also curiosity-making.
Caveats to my question:
<drumroll> Why are Cats not on more open ocean podiums? </drumroll>
Bob
Caveats to my question:
- I would have to go to school for three years to get up to the level of 'Ignernt' about American racing, so if I step on toes, it's b/c I have big feet, not that I am looking for toes to mash.
- I am (only minimally) less ignorant abt UIM rules and classes; European marathon & endurance racing.
Those two stipulations having been given: I did not fall off a turnip truck when it crossed the RR tracks coming into town. I absolutely know that Politic$ and Rule$ are $ignificant in all $port$.- I am (only minimally) less ignorant abt UIM rules and classes; European marathon & endurance racing.
<drumroll> Why are Cats not on more open ocean podiums? </drumroll>
Bob
Why start a new thread? Post this on one of the two threads already there..........HELLO!
01-25-2013, 11:57 PM
#8
01-26-2013, 12:10 AM
#9
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: SW1
Posts: 141
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
... Every boat manufacture does "great in rough water", "fastest", "best handling" etc etc. They all claim this and that but never have proof. There are no head to head tests like there are in sports cars. No test showing how many G's they can take in a corner.
I understand both sides but yes it would be nice to see some science, test, and proof on if a Cat actually is good in the rough, do step hulls really help, etc etc.
...
I understand both sides but yes it would be nice to see some science, test, and proof on if a Cat actually is good in the rough, do step hulls really help, etc etc.
...
There are Cats in Europe, and like in the USA, there are more Vee than Cats, but the Cats are still entered in CTC, Naples to Montecarlo, RoundBritain ... Round Long Island, Bimini & Back, KW-Cancun.
Cats are entered, but I have seen few podiums.
With the exception of Dubai, the UIM is not Cat-friendly, but I am referring more to the Open Entry, run-what-you-brung events.
It seems that in the USA, Poker Runs have taken over from 'Offshore,' but not in Europe.
L3 ... b/c this curiousity was not on topic for either of T2x' threads, I didn't think.
01-26-2013, 09:49 AM
#10
Registered
Actually there ARE 'comparison tests' - the various racing series: who stands on the podium and gets to spray champagne.
There are Cats in Europe, and like in the USA, there are more Vee than Cats, but the Cats are still entered in CTC, Naples to Montecarlo, RoundBritain ... Round Long Island, Bimini & Back, KW-Cancun.
Cats are entered, but I have seen few podiums.
With the exception of Dubai, the UIM is not Cat-friendly, but I am referring more to the Open Entry, run-what-you-brung events.
It seems that in the USA, Poker Runs have taken over from 'Offshore,' but not in Europe.
L3 ... b/c this curiousity was not on topic for either of T2x' threads, I didn't think.
There are Cats in Europe, and like in the USA, there are more Vee than Cats, but the Cats are still entered in CTC, Naples to Montecarlo, RoundBritain ... Round Long Island, Bimini & Back, KW-Cancun.
Cats are entered, but I have seen few podiums.
With the exception of Dubai, the UIM is not Cat-friendly, but I am referring more to the Open Entry, run-what-you-brung events.
It seems that in the USA, Poker Runs have taken over from 'Offshore,' but not in Europe.
L3 ... b/c this curiousity was not on topic for either of T2x' threads, I didn't think.
ede
