Carbs vs FI... Pros/cons
#72
Driver-441
Racer
In a nut shell, you will need an ACCEL Fuel Pump, Computer, Ignition System and return lines. The hardest part will be the fuel system rigging and ignition system change, although it really isnt that bad.
You could put EFI on those blowers, although it wont work as well as a Whipple style system for EFI.
At the very least, Jason can tell you what specifically to look for and take pictures of.
518-644-3080
You could put EFI on those blowers, although it wont work as well as a Whipple style system for EFI.
At the very least, Jason can tell you what specifically to look for and take pictures of.
518-644-3080
#73
Registered
Its by far the best system we've used. We have used quite a few as well. Thruster, Gen7+, all fantastic. All our customers are thrilled with it. From 1500hp supercharged engines, to 450hp smallblocks.
Heres a shot of our bilge. Old school look, but idles, sifts, starts, backs timing out around 5400 (near our breakout speed), all kinds of stuff.
Heres a shot of our bilge. Old school look, but idles, sifts, starts, backs timing out around 5400 (near our breakout speed), all kinds of stuff.
We considered using our DFI unit to trigger the nitrous system, instead used a progressive NOS controller to trigger the DFI timing retard. Worked flawlessly, spraying 300hp, dozens of bottles, and never so much as burned a electrode.
Bam, biggest issue I see with converting your [most beautiful] setup to multi-port is finding lower intakes with injector bosses. Those charge coolers make it a bit tight, but the rest should be pretty straight forward.
#74
Registered
Platinum Member
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Vancouver BC
Posts: 1,181
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For basic set up on engines like yours, I like to have a guardian system that will reduce engine power and rpm if it detects a parameter that is out of range. They are totally user programmable and I usually set it up for oil pressure, fuel pressure, water pressure, coolant temperature, inlet air temp, and battery voltage. You can also do AFR if you leave the sensor in, and a bilge alarm. You can choose to trigger a caution light first at say 150 degrees coolant temp, and then reduce rpm to 1200rpm if the temp gets to 180. You can choose the ranges for each parameter and trigger a light and buzzer only, or reduce rpm too. As soon as the parameter is back in range, full power is available again. I'd add a couple knock sensors too, and that should take care of the basic engine safeguards. With total control of your timing and fuel curves, and additional tuning options available to protect against detonation, you will have the ability to truly control your engine and make it do exactly what you want, when you want. No bad habits.
I'm not trying to spam this thread, I only included prices because Bam has repeatedly asked how much it costs. There's lots of good systems and tuners out there. If you do take the plunge, make sure at the very least that you're getting a CG approved fuel system to keep the insurers happy, that it comes with all the features you'd want, any replacement part/component is available almost anywhere, and the guy doing it has experience with your specific application.
#76
Registered
Why would you be dying to hear what Eddie Young has to say? Or even Haxby for that for that matter? They are both advertisers that specialize in EFI. There are guys that specialize carbs...what do you think they might say? Of course the marine industry is going to be trending towards EFI, it has always rode the coat tails of the automotive industry. Whats not being mentioned here is that there has been alot going on with carb development (of course on a smaller scale) in the last 10-15 years; stuff that was considered the hot set up then is now considered junk. Remember Bob Teague pushing the 830 Holley years ago? Anyone into carbs these days would tell you to throw it in the trash. A good carb guy claims he can set you up from accross the country, you can bolt it on and just adjust the idle. I guess I'm going to find out.
Eddie
#77
Registered
I have worked with a few engines that have had some custom mail order carbs from big name carb shops, built for my friends applications. Unfortunately they were not anywhere near ideal as far as tune goes.
First set of carbs were on a roots blown 871 setup. The carbs came shipped with 82 jets squared, and 6.5 PVs front and rear. In order to get the AFR in the 12 range, they needed 90 jets in the primary. Carbs were not boost referenced. The power valve channel restrictions were drilled so large, that once the PV opened in the curve, the AFR plummeted into the low 10's at 4000RPM. At 3500RPM, they were at 12.3ish. Had they been run out of the box, the AFR at 3500, where the engine in this particular boat is starting to see a little boost, the AFR would have been in the 13's.
Another deal was a blow thru setup. The metering on these particular carbs were so off, that at 3000RPM, the AFR was in the 9's. By the time it got to 6000, the AFR was 13ish.
I guess what I am getting at, is I personally don't expect to buy a carb from a custom carb builder, bolt it on, and go. I know some have done it, but for what some of these custom carb builders charge, your better off getting a standard off the shelf carb and do your own tuning. I am a fan of the carbs from Quick Fuel. They offer so much in the way of tuneability. Not just air bleeds, but screw in idle feed restrictors, emulsion bleeds, power valve channel restrictions, big sight glasses, billet baseplates and metering blocks, and most of all, they look cool and aren't really much more if any than a stock holley, and usually cheaper than one of these ''custom worked over with a bunch of drill bit carbs". There is so much more to dialing in a carb than just jet swaps. If your gonna buy a carb, and want to get the cleanest most efficient setup, invest in a wideband, and prepare to spend some time tuning. Several years back, most installed a carb, did a wot pass, checked their plugs, and called it good. More people were running around with poor tunes, wasting fuel, washing rings, or burning pistons. While I think every engine should be dyno'd , a I feel tuning in the boat is also crucial, as the tune will change a bit.
Also, I have used the FAST wideband with good results, and the NGK Powerdex. AFX. The NGK can usually be found for around 250.00 if you shop around. Its simple easy to read, and can be calibrated for accuracy.
My opinion that's the bare minimum way to go nowadays, if EFI isn't in the budget. Otherwise, get your EFI ON!
First set of carbs were on a roots blown 871 setup. The carbs came shipped with 82 jets squared, and 6.5 PVs front and rear. In order to get the AFR in the 12 range, they needed 90 jets in the primary. Carbs were not boost referenced. The power valve channel restrictions were drilled so large, that once the PV opened in the curve, the AFR plummeted into the low 10's at 4000RPM. At 3500RPM, they were at 12.3ish. Had they been run out of the box, the AFR at 3500, where the engine in this particular boat is starting to see a little boost, the AFR would have been in the 13's.
Another deal was a blow thru setup. The metering on these particular carbs were so off, that at 3000RPM, the AFR was in the 9's. By the time it got to 6000, the AFR was 13ish.
I guess what I am getting at, is I personally don't expect to buy a carb from a custom carb builder, bolt it on, and go. I know some have done it, but for what some of these custom carb builders charge, your better off getting a standard off the shelf carb and do your own tuning. I am a fan of the carbs from Quick Fuel. They offer so much in the way of tuneability. Not just air bleeds, but screw in idle feed restrictors, emulsion bleeds, power valve channel restrictions, big sight glasses, billet baseplates and metering blocks, and most of all, they look cool and aren't really much more if any than a stock holley, and usually cheaper than one of these ''custom worked over with a bunch of drill bit carbs". There is so much more to dialing in a carb than just jet swaps. If your gonna buy a carb, and want to get the cleanest most efficient setup, invest in a wideband, and prepare to spend some time tuning. Several years back, most installed a carb, did a wot pass, checked their plugs, and called it good. More people were running around with poor tunes, wasting fuel, washing rings, or burning pistons. While I think every engine should be dyno'd , a I feel tuning in the boat is also crucial, as the tune will change a bit.
Also, I have used the FAST wideband with good results, and the NGK Powerdex. AFX. The NGK can usually be found for around 250.00 if you shop around. Its simple easy to read, and can be calibrated for accuracy.
My opinion that's the bare minimum way to go nowadays, if EFI isn't in the budget. Otherwise, get your EFI ON!
#78
Registered
#79
Platinum Member
Platinum Member
Kinda of related to this topic. Several years ago I installed a Megasquirt 3 ECu on my SBC 86 Vette. The tuning program will auto calibrate the main fuel table to correspond to the desired AFR table. One of the new features is the warmup autotune. It looks at the desired AFR table and the correction factor based on coolant temp and corrects the warmup enrichment. So now I go outside and start the car and just let it warmup and it corrects itself. Show me a carb that can correct it's self.
#80
Fast Singles Club
Gold Member
Kinda of related to this topic. Several years ago I installed a Megasquirt 3 ECu on my SBC 86 Vette. The tuning program will auto calibrate the main fuel table to correspond to the desired AFR table. One of the new features is the warmup autotune. It looks at the desired AFR table and the correction factor based on coolant temp and corrects the warmup enrichment. So now I go outside and start the car and just let it warmup and it corrects itself. Show me a carb that can correct it's self.