Would most likely pick the Formula if they're both in good shape. Another boat that I think is great in that size is the Sonic Prowler 26. The only boat in that size, that I'm aware of, with a room for porta potty. Many of them have a pump out potty as well.

I wish my Scarab 29 had the layout of the Sonic 26 with the dedicated room for porta potty.

We ran our 1993 271 for 17 years and had over 800 hours on the 502 Mag when we decided it was time for another Formula. Not a stress crack any where and the gel coat still shined. Enough said I think.

I had a 271 Fastech, Whippled 509, XR drive 26P Bravo 1 boat ran 80 on a good day.