Offshoreonly.com

Offshoreonly.com (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/)
-   General Q & A (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q-20/)
-   -   Water in oil with pics (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q/205813-water-oil-pics.html)

tssteph 03-31-2009 03:43 PM

I know the feeling. Bought a boat over the winter a couple years ago. In the spring started to do a service on everything and I found the same thing. Pulled the motor and took it to the shop and all that was wrong internally (besides rust) was a very slightly bent valve. I would pull it and go through it if I were you.

I even applied pressure to the complete water system and found nothing wrong. The only change I made was to add flaps to the exhaust.

I will have to say the seller paid a large portion of the rebuild. Not too often you find a seller like that.

jeff1000man 03-31-2009 04:06 PM


Originally Posted by jeffswav (Post 2833255)
With oil that looked like that I would recomend a rebuild. I am not a machinist but that could not have been good on the bearings. If you spin a rod or main during the season you could be down for a while and cost a lot more money.

There is way more truth to what this guy said than you can imagine unless you have ever missed a good run because of laziness when you knew there was a problem in an engine that could have been fixed.

My suggestion is to go ahead and tear down the engine and put in new bearings and rings and oil pump. Flush the engine while you have it apart.

Bearings and ringe are only a couple hundred extra bucks and head gaskets are cheap also. You all ready have most of the engine torn down anyway.

You can lead a horse to water. Better safe than sitting on the shore thinking about what might have been.

Have a good summer

Vinny P 03-31-2009 04:45 PM


Originally Posted by jeff1000man (Post 2833286)
Bearings and ringe are only a couple hundred extra bucks and head gaskets are cheap also. You all ready have most of the engine torn down anyway.

I agree with the tear down. BUT, along with the cost of the rings and bearings, you have to figure on a full tear down, at least have the block honed, the crank polished, the list goes on. Before you know it, you spent alot of $$.

jeff1000man 03-31-2009 08:49 PM


Originally Posted by Vinny P (Post 2833335)
I agree with the tear down. BUT, along with the cost of the rings and bearings, you have to figure on a full tear down, at least have the block honed, the crank polished, the list goes on. Before you know it, you spent alot of $$.

Depends. I know a lot of engines that have been PUT back together.

But with just polishing the crank and poishing the bore it is only a couple hundy also.

Just depends on who is doing the work, If you are doing it, get after it and spend the extra dough, If you are having all the work done, then I guess maybe it is worth the gamble. It just depends on how much you enjoy and look forward to your boating during the season.

Raylar 04-01-2009 11:45 AM

Don't cut the corner!
 
As an engine builder and pretty good engine tech I can tell you absolutely that your engine has to come out and either Redone , Rebuilt or Replaced! Whatever allowed that much moisture and water in the engine has already done enough damage with rust and water alone to seriously damage the rotating assembly and rings and valves. Depending on what your engine actually is, an exchange long block may be the way to go and all your manifolds, coolers, etc. need to be cleaned and pressure tested before reusing them!
I would not try a cheap temporary fix as it will probably give up quick, destroy your core value and ruin your boating season early.
Best of Luck on your misfortune.

Best Regards,
Ray @ Raylar

crapr6 04-03-2009 07:44 PM

Thanks guys for the advice, but iam not going lie. Iam going to use the motor the way it is but flush out the oil as best as possible. I just got my trans fixed in my f350 dually and funds are kinda tight. If the motor does blow up then i'll start to look for a new motor then. I know this isnt the want add's but if anybody has a good rebuildable short block please pm me or email me at [email protected]
thanks
Erik

US1 Fountain 04-03-2009 08:53 PM

Well then, might as well give it hell when you hit the water, but carry a tow rope. :)

crapr6 04-03-2009 09:12 PM


Originally Posted by US1 Fountain (Post 2835786)
Well then, might as well give it hell when you hit the water, but carry a tow rope. :)

Not giving it hell but will be equiped with tow rope and a member of tow boat US. :eek:

point92mach 04-04-2009 05:14 AM


Originally Posted by crapr6 (Post 2835809)
Not giving it hell but will be equiped with tow rope and a member of tow boat US. :eek:

This may not go over well on this site, but I have actually revived a submerged and rusted car engine without tearing it down and it was fine for a long time.

I did several oil changes in a row over very short intervals.

Crapr6, I think if you simply change the oil every couple of hours till the oil comes out clean you'll stand the best chance of success with this engine.

I would stay away from flushing the engine with any diesel or kerosene, and I would also avoid the urge to scrape rust off of parts you can't fully remove and wirewheel real good.

The worst case scenario here is that a bunch of rust will damage the bearings and oil pump and you'll lose oil pressure. If caught early enough, you won't destroy anything, and the damage will be well within the limits of a core engine for exchange purposes.

Also, make sure you have fixed the water intrusion issue as well.

Best of luck to you on this one,

Greg

Pismo10 04-04-2009 05:36 AM


Originally Posted by point92mach (Post 2835914)
This may not go over well on this site, but I have actually revived a submerged and rusted car engine without tearing it down and it was fine for a long time.

I did several oil changes in a row over very short intervals.

Crapr6, I think if you simply change the oil every couple of hours till the oil comes out clean you'll stand the best chance of success with this engine.

I would stay away from flushing the engine with any diesel or kerosene, and I would also avoid the urge to scrape rust off of parts you can't fully remove and wirewheel real good.

The worst case scenario here is that a bunch of rust will damage the bearings and oil pump and you'll lose oil pressure. If caught early enough, you won't destroy anything, and the damage will be well within the limits of a core engine for exchange purposes.

Also, make sure you have fixed the water intrusion issue as well.

Best of luck to you on this one,

Greg

Just run it till it blows....Bring that tow rope.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:20 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.