Offshoreonly.com

Offshoreonly.com (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/)
-   General Q & A (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q-20/)
-   -   Engine tick/knock? Please help!!! (https://www.offshoreonly.com/forums/general-q/241323-engine-tick-knock-please-help.html)

Philm 10-28-2010 09:14 PM


Originally Posted by dennis r (Post 3241349)
Your welcome rob with all the help.If I would have knowing you would give the work to someone else I would not have come over on a Sunday afternoon

uh oh.... :party-smiley-004:

MILD THUNDER 10-28-2010 09:25 PM


Originally Posted by dennis r (Post 3241349)
Your welcome rob with all the help.If I would have knowing you would give the work to someone else I would not have come over on a Sunday afternoon

Doh! :party-smiley-004:

Sounds like a honest misunderstanding though

mcollinstn 10-29-2010 11:20 AM

I've happily given out FAR more FREE work than I'll ever get in PAID work. I view it as a blessing that keeps on giving. If I treat people well, and help them when I can, maybe I don't get the cherry jobs, and maybe I do. The cutthroat guy down the street charges for every second of his time, and all his stuff is paid for. He's known as "Rapin' Ray" but people keep going back over and over and paying his rates. I'm starving to death, but I will never operate like he does. Goes against the way I was raised.

If I'm going to "drop by" and help somebody, I don't consider it billable time. If I plan to offer paid services for additional work, I make it clear that I'm interested in carrying the job farther for pay.

But like I say, I'm starving so maybe I'm not the right guy to listen to about what's the right way and what's the wrong way..

MC

RunninHotRacing163.1 10-29-2010 12:23 PM


Originally Posted by mcollinstn (Post 3241835)
I've happily given out FAR more FREE work than I'll ever get in PAID work. I view it as a blessing that keeps on giving. If I treat people well, and help them when I can, maybe I don't get the cherry jobs, and maybe I do. The cutthroat guy down the street charges for every second of his time, and all his stuff is paid for. He's known as "Rapin' Ray" but people keep going back over and over and paying his rates. I'm starving to death, but I will never operate like he does. Goes against the way I was raised.

If I'm going to "drop by" and help somebody, I don't consider it billable time. If I plan to offer paid services for additional work, I make it clear that I'm interested in carrying the job farther for pay.

But like I say, I'm starving so maybe I'm not the right guy to listen to about what's the right way and what's the wrong way..

MC


Ditto MC can't count how many drives,transmissions,water pumps,fuel pumps,impellors, we've changed/swapped out for fellow boaters on the weekend for Pizza & pitchers of beer when the town marina service shop was closed just so they could still enjoy there boat .:drink::drink::drink::drink::drink::drink:

rob vanharten 10-29-2010 01:31 PM

I guess I have the same mind set that you guys do. But everybody is different.

jeffswav 10-29-2010 02:38 PM


Originally Posted by Griff (Post 3239043)
I would definately get rid of the solid lifters and switch to hydraulic lifters. I really can't understand why the builder did that in the first place.
You only need to pull the intake to swap lifters.

x2 the morals are the best.

jeffswav 10-29-2010 04:03 PM


Originally Posted by mrfixxall (Post 3240541)
you say the engines only have 5 hr's on them? talk to the builder and see if theirs any warranty!! also cut open the oil filter on the other motor and compare the metal particles,could be from brake in..if the cam is going south it usually starts at the top of the lobe and not the side..

as for your next cam talk to bob madara @ marine kinetics,he is to cam god on here..

x2

FloridianSon 10-30-2010 08:27 PM

I think I would only put solid lifters in something that was a little easer to work on. Harley motor comes to mind. Then again if you were raceing your boat guess you take advantage of what you can.

mustangmark 10-31-2010 11:15 AM

that sucks!
 

Originally Posted by rob vanharten (Post 3240512)
Well not the best night, re adjusted lash on all valves tonight which went really smooth. Took them to .010 like the engien builder said. Well after learning how to properly do it, realized they where all within .002 of .010 already. Even the one that was measuring .040 before. Well what I realized is that as the cam turns this one rocker/cam lobe would loosen up to about .040 as the cam turns. So basically my heart sank right there and then, cause I knew it was the cam. I adjusted it anyways so that when it came to the loosest part on the lobe is was measuring .012, re assembled everything and fired for just a second or two. Yep still knocks. Shut it down, pulled oil filter and cut it open with tin snips. It has a fair amount of very very small metal particles, sitting on the bottom of the fiilter housing. So I have come to the conclusion I have a **** cam lobe, does that sound correct? Next question is the rest of the motor trashed cause it ran for a little while with the metal in the oil? It still runs sweet, but I am not sure how to proceed forward at this point. My feelings are this, pull both motors, new more agressive cams, new hydraulic roller lifters, and new push rods for both. It is so freaking windy out there. Had this boat 6 days, feeling pretty sweet right now!!!

sorry to hear that! I would pull your v/c and check and see if that one rocker in question is loose again. from there, pull the rocker and inspect the pushrod to make sure it's not bent. if it's straight, pull the intake to get to the lifter so you can inspect that. if the lifter looks good, inspect the lobe on the cam. you should find the culprit somewhere in there. to answer your question about "is the motor trashed?".....ive been down this road twice! it sucks! DO NOT just flush the motor and replace the lifter if it's a bad lifter! eventually you will end up with a rod knock! the shavings that you have already found in the filter indicate that something is very wrong. if you where to keep running it, those shavings will embed themselves into your bearings and wipe out your crank journals, and also embed themselves in the sides of your pistons and wipe out the shirts.
if you are going to change the cams, i suggest you get in contact with Bob, "RMbuilder" of Marine Kinetics. he is very reputable and very good to work with! he will not steer you in the wrong direction! he'll be able to help you out with your whole valve train. i am very impressed with him personally!

mustangmark 10-31-2010 11:31 AM


Originally Posted by mustangmark (Post 3243042)
sorry to hear that! I would pull your v/c and check and see if that one rocker in question is loose again. from there, pull the rocker and inspect the pushrod to make sure it's not bent. if it's straight, pull the intake to get to the lifter so you can inspect that. if the lifter looks good, inspect the lobe on the cam. you should find the culprit somewhere in there. to answer your question about "is the motor trashed?".....ive been down this road twice! it sucks! DO NOT just flush the motor and replace the lifter if it's a bad lifter! eventually you will end up with a rod knock! the shavings that you have already found in the filter indicate that something is very wrong. if you where to keep running it, those shavings will embed themselves into your bearings and wipe out your crank journals, and also embed themselves in the sides of your pistons and wipe out the shirts.
if you are going to change the cams, i suggest you get in contact with Bob, "RMbuilder" of Marine Kinetics. he is very reputable and very good to work with! he will not steer you in the wrong direction! he'll be able to help you out with your whole valve train. i am very impressed with him personally!

sorry, when i posted the above post i hadnt read all the other post. i still recommend pulling the motor and going through it to clean all the shavings from it. you will be much better off in the long run. after my 2 experiences and the amount of $$$ i spent to fix it twice it wouldnt even cross my mind if it happen agaim. sounds like your headed in the right direction and doing the right thing....good luck to you!

ALSO...MOREL LIFTERS ARE TOP NOTCH! IF YOUR GOING HYD. ROLLER, I WOULDN'T PUT ANYTHING ELSE IN MY MOTOR. FOR SOLID ROLLER I FIRMLY BELIEVE IN THE BEST CROWERS YOU CAN BUY. (cheap solid roller lifters is what caused me to have to rebuild my motor twice. the second time it happen, I flushed the motor and stuck another lifter in it....it didn't last a long time and the shavings destroyed my crank and pistons).


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:14 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.