Engine compression ratio relationship to compression test result?
#1
Registered
Thread Starter
Engine compression ratio relationship to compression test result?
I read on another forum that a "rule of thumb" is to multiple the compression ratio by 20 to get the expected compression test result. So for a 9:1 compespion ratio engine the expected result would be: 9 x 20 = 180 psi. I haven'the heard of this relationship before and wanted to see if it's at all valid? Thanks.
#2
Registered
iTrader: (1)
No.
A bunch of BBC near 9:1 motors will crank 140-150psi.
Engine cranking speed and camshaft has a bunch to do with cranking compression also. Not just static/physical compression ratio.
Way back when I discovered the cranking speed thing, already knowing the cam and static compression ratio effects. Our class was introduced with a compression ratio rule. I quickly discovered by luck (low battery) that cranking speed , when slowed down, compression test would read lower. Worked great until others discovered same thing.
Edited in: Best to do compression test with fully charged battery to keep that part of test consistent.
A bunch of BBC near 9:1 motors will crank 140-150psi.
Engine cranking speed and camshaft has a bunch to do with cranking compression also. Not just static/physical compression ratio.
Way back when I discovered the cranking speed thing, already knowing the cam and static compression ratio effects. Our class was introduced with a compression ratio rule. I quickly discovered by luck (low battery) that cranking speed , when slowed down, compression test would read lower. Worked great until others discovered same thing.
Edited in: Best to do compression test with fully charged battery to keep that part of test consistent.
Last edited by SB; 08-08-2017 at 09:24 PM.
#5
Registered
The more conservative the cam, the higher the compression test will read. Hotter cam has more overlap. You can have 30 to 40 degrees total overlap wipes out that much crank speed compression.
#6
Banned
iTrader: (9)
Mercruiser V 6 at 9:4 to 1 are 180 when solid
Mercruiser 350 can be 150 to 180 and I even see 180 to 200 on certain year models with the same comp ratio
I even see some Volvo's 190 to 210 in the past with 9.4 to 1 comp ratio
big block what was mentioned a lot are 140 to 150 Merc
Mercruiser 350 can be 150 to 180 and I even see 180 to 200 on certain year models with the same comp ratio
I even see some Volvo's 190 to 210 in the past with 9.4 to 1 comp ratio
big block what was mentioned a lot are 140 to 150 Merc
Last edited by BUP; 08-08-2017 at 09:23 PM.
#8
Registered
iTrader: (1)
It's actually IVC (intake valve closing) that effects cranking compression.
Overlap, during cranking (engine not running) causes the exhaust valve to act as an intake valve also. The exhaust valve closes (when piston is starting to go down) way before bottom dead center , but the intake valve closes as the piston is going up towards TDC. Cranking speed is slow, therefore piston is pushing air out of intake valve until the intake valve closes. The longer the intake valve stays open, the more air and thus psi is lost.
So, if you take two cams identical other than LSA, the tighter LSA cam will have more overlap, but will have an earlier IVC. Thus the tighter LSA cam will have more cranking compression, This effects an actual running engine too, but that is another topic.
Last edited by SB; 08-10-2017 at 04:17 AM.
#9
Registered
iTrader: (1)
No.
A bunch of BBC near 9:1 motors will crank 140-150psi.
Engine cranking speed and camshaft has a bunch to do with cranking compression also. Not just static/physical compression ratio.
Way back when I discovered the cranking speed thing, already knowing the cam and static compression ratio effects. Our class was introduced with a compression ratio rule. I quickly discovered by luck (low battery) that cranking speed , when slowed down, compression test would read lower. Worked great until others discovered same thing.
Edited in: Best to do compression test with fully charged battery to keep that part of test consistent.
A bunch of BBC near 9:1 motors will crank 140-150psi.
Engine cranking speed and camshaft has a bunch to do with cranking compression also. Not just static/physical compression ratio.
Way back when I discovered the cranking speed thing, already knowing the cam and static compression ratio effects. Our class was introduced with a compression ratio rule. I quickly discovered by luck (low battery) that cranking speed , when slowed down, compression test would read lower. Worked great until others discovered same thing.
Edited in: Best to do compression test with fully charged battery to keep that part of test consistent.
#10
Registered
the more I think about it, it isn't the overlap that lowers compression test numbers. it is the intake closing event. that is the only open valve on the compression stroke. but there is about 60 degrees ABDC the intake is open while the piston is trying to compress the air. and the hotter the cam, the longer the valve is open, cutting into compression time.