Cig, Sutphen, scarab, sonic or Formula?
#11
VIP Member

Joined: Jun 2021
Posts: 3,486
Likes: 2,116
From: SW Ohio
Plan on getting a bigger boat next year, looking for an older wave crusher for Lake Michigan. Looking for 35ft +, ideally 38ft, was curious of everyone's opinions on what to go with. I've had my eyes on a few older cigs (35 mistress and 38 flat decks, 38 top gun),a 390 Sutphen, 38 Scarab KV, and a Formula 382 SR1. I'm coming from a 292 Fastech which simply isn't enough boat for what I want. Looking to stay under $80k. Would like to hear everyone's personal opinions on all of these boats and others you may recommend. Any input is appreciated!
Everybody knows I'm a bit biased, and it is outside your stated budget, but this seems like a really nice ride that fits your needs pretty well.
OffshoreOnly Classifieds - Boat Classifieds - Boat Parts
Thanks. Brad.
(937)545-8991
#12
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 311
Likes: 113
From: Oak Lawn IL
Frank,
Everybody knows I'm a bit biased, and it is outside your stated budget, but this seems like a really nice ride that fits your needs pretty well.
OffshoreOnly Classifieds - Boat Classifieds - Boat Parts
Thanks. Brad.
(937)545-8991
Everybody knows I'm a bit biased, and it is outside your stated budget, but this seems like a really nice ride that fits your needs pretty well.
OffshoreOnly Classifieds - Boat Classifieds - Boat Parts
Thanks. Brad.
(937)545-8991
#13
I agree! You said you are looking for a 38' wave crusher right? Here you go. The Scarabs are nice boats but one has TRS drives.. no thanks and the other has 502 mpi's with 522 hours. Sutphen boats are amazing and I am a big fan but they are dated looking and I think the resale will be tougher. Buy the right hull and engine and drive package. All the boats discussed and listed have dated paints but this subjected and could easily be changed with a wrap or some paint work. Again my vote is a Cigarette. The rigging is superior to the others with a proven rough water hull and when it comes to resale it will bring a bigger audience. Cigarette is often imitated never duplicated as the ad says.
#15
Registered
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 286
Likes: 33
From: Lake Charles, La
I agree with Pagraig, hogieroll, and 4195. Drive a Sutphen before you buy. JMO and 8 years driving one, the boat handling, the speed, the solid yet quick manuverabiity whether at speed or just cruising is sooo predictable and solid. They were designed for offshore racing conditions. Also the ease of moving around the boat with the wide gunnels even makes all the difference, everyday, all day when tying fenders or tying up. The hatches to the cabin are much easier to go through, at least on my 2000 32ft they are. Some other boats may be as good. A Lot are Not.
If i can find it it will attach a 4 page test that Boat Test Magazine did on this boat, the 32 Sutphen.
If i can find it it will attach a 4 page test that Boat Test Magazine did on this boat, the 32 Sutphen.
#16
Registered

Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 1,542
Likes: 55
From: Kingsville----lake erie
Where are you boating usually, conditions, driving style, speed your looking for? That will make a big difference in the hull and hardware needed...
There seems to be alot of 39 Sutphen's getting stripped out and sold for parts... #6 and arneson boats -- why is that? I was told that they get squirrely above 85-90mph -- i've never been in one
There seems to be alot of 39 Sutphen's getting stripped out and sold for parts... #6 and arneson boats -- why is that? I was told that they get squirrely above 85-90mph -- i've never been in one
#18
Registered

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 3,861
Likes: 793
From: St. Pete Beach, FL
I agree! You said you are looking for a 38' wave crusher right? Here you go. The Scarabs are nice boats but one has TRS drives.. no thanks and the other has 502 mpi's with 522 hours. Sutphen boats are amazing and I am a big fan but they are dated looking and I think the resale will be tougher. Buy the right hull and engine and drive package. All the boats discussed and listed have dated paints but this subjected and could easily be changed with a wrap or some paint work. Again my vote is a Cigarette. The rigging is superior to the others with a proven rough water hull and when it comes to resale it will bring a bigger audience. Cigarette is often imitated never duplicated as the ad says.
#19
Registered

Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 4,806
Likes: 891
#20
Registered

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 3,861
Likes: 793
From: St. Pete Beach, FL
Markets a little warm still but 2 382s and 4 353s under 90k on BT.



