Camshaft and reversion?
#11
Originally posted by KaamaScarab30
You are quite categorically WRONG!
You are quite categorically WRONG!
WELL I EXCUSE ME (quote from Steve Martin)
I held the exhaust as a constant and the 454/502 Mag cam as the reference.
I almost went on about exhaust but I figured some intelligent soul would do this.
FYI Look up proportional
Last edited by bajalion; 09-11-2003 at 08:34 PM.
#13
Originally posted by Pat McPherson
If you end up with negative 5°, is there any overlap?
Without both valves open, how you going to suck water in?
If you end up with negative 5°, is there any overlap?
Without both valves open, how you going to suck water in?
Overlap can be calculated in the overall sense. My cam is as follows:
Intake duration @ 0.050 = 228
Intake duration overall = 280
Exh duration @ 0.050 = 232
Exh duration overall = 284
Overlap @ 0.050 = +2 degrees
Overlap total = 54 degrees
I also run Stainless Marine Captain's call (short)
Last edited by bajalion; 09-11-2003 at 08:37 PM.
#17
Thanks for the replies,
First off, I did talk to Comp Cams.... not much help, more interested in selling me a new cam. B.S.
Camshafts to me are like an unknown science. I have water in the oil and just trying to rule out variables. Any more info would be great. Keep it coming!
Bajalion,
I am an engineer(propeller head) and very interested in the origin of your formulas for cam overlap.
If there is negative overlap, I assume the chance of reversion is eliminated?
Paul
First off, I did talk to Comp Cams.... not much help, more interested in selling me a new cam. B.S.
Camshafts to me are like an unknown science. I have water in the oil and just trying to rule out variables. Any more info would be great. Keep it coming!
Bajalion,
I am an engineer(propeller head) and very interested in the origin of your formulas for cam overlap.
If there is negative overlap, I assume the chance of reversion is eliminated?
Paul
#19
Originally posted by MAG502NUM
May I join in? I think you most certainly can have intake/exhaust reversion in any dry system....it's just not water reversion. I read this in Chevy HiPerf Mag about 45years ago.-non-member smilie-
May I join in? I think you most certainly can have intake/exhaust reversion in any dry system....it's just not water reversion. I read this in Chevy HiPerf Mag about 45years ago.-non-member smilie-
OUCH!!! I'm busted!!! Technically, I think you are correct, but as a practical matter, it isn't likely. In a dry exhaust system, I have heard that the danger is sucking a bit of cold air into a hot cylinder and warping a valve. The chances are fairly slim if you have a properly working exhaust system. However, if you have an exhaust leak near the cylinder or a great deal of overlap and a large amount intake vacuum with a short exhaust system such as a set of "zoomies" it could happen.I stand (sit) corrected.
By the way, Bajalion -- overlap CAN be proportional to reversion. Your statement was "IS proportional". But then I guess it depends on what your definition of what the word "IS" is.
(Someone please kill me -- I just quoted a Democrat.
)
#20
hey guys I'm not here to make judgements just a little education on Cam profile and what it is.
KAAMASCARAB30 and Formula31 are both correct you have other factors. I understand engine attitude and exhaust attitude are also involved. Formula31's knowledge of boats and engines makes me look like a dunce.
Cuda, Unless you have standard merc exhaust I bet your OK. Even if so your still pretty mild.
The best way to check for reversion is to pull off a riser after idling as low as she'll go for a while. Turn off, remove a riser. Do you see water down in the bottom of the manifold? If not no problem.
If you have water passing through the manifold to the riser (no hose bypass). You may need to drain the manifold first.
PB-reversion probably would not cause water in the oil. A leaky head gasket will.
Of course a rod through the side of the block will do it too
but I guess that's my problem
KAAMASCARAB30 and Formula31 are both correct you have other factors. I understand engine attitude and exhaust attitude are also involved. Formula31's knowledge of boats and engines makes me look like a dunce.
Cuda, Unless you have standard merc exhaust I bet your OK. Even if so your still pretty mild.
The best way to check for reversion is to pull off a riser after idling as low as she'll go for a while. Turn off, remove a riser. Do you see water down in the bottom of the manifold? If not no problem.
If you have water passing through the manifold to the riser (no hose bypass). You may need to drain the manifold first.
PB-reversion probably would not cause water in the oil. A leaky head gasket will.
Of course a rod through the side of the block will do it too
but I guess that's my problem


