Trailer Winch
#1
Thread Starter
Platinum Member

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2,241
Likes: 263
From: Jackson, n.j. ~ Brooklyn, n.y.
I orderd 2 bow blocks from Myco and will be fabing up a new bow stop for the Mistress also changing out the old
original rusted trailer winch...........What would be a good replacement?...and what's better cable or strap?.....thnx
original rusted trailer winch...........What would be a good replacement?...and what's better cable or strap?.....thnx
#2
The strap is easier to deal with and install, but it's a bigger pain the ass to get wound tight. The strap stretches as it tightens down on the spool for the first few uses. The cable doesn't really do that, but the cable can get bound over itself which is another PITA, and that's when you will cut your hand. Ask me how I know that.
Regardless, if you have a straight bottom boat, ensure you have a safety chain that you latch before you pull up the ramp. Both straps and cables can break.
#3
Thread Starter
Platinum Member

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2,241
Likes: 263
From: Jackson, n.j. ~ Brooklyn, n.y.
I've had both. Prefer strap. The strap will never cut your hand open.
The strap is easier to deal with and install, but it's a bigger pain the ass to get wound tight. The strap stretches as it tightens down on the spool for the first few uses. The cable doesn't really do that, but the cable can get bound over itself which is another PITA, and that's when you will cut your hand. Ask me how I know that.
Regardless, if you have a straight bottom boat, ensure you have a safety chain that you latch before you pull up the ramp. Both straps and cables can break.
The strap is easier to deal with and install, but it's a bigger pain the ass to get wound tight. The strap stretches as it tightens down on the spool for the first few uses. The cable doesn't really do that, but the cable can get bound over itself which is another PITA, and that's when you will cut your hand. Ask me how I know that.
Regardless, if you have a straight bottom boat, ensure you have a safety chain that you latch before you pull up the ramp. Both straps and cables can break.
#6
Registered

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 1,102
Likes: 11
From: Granger, Indiana
I've had both. Prefer strap. The strap will never cut your hand open.
The strap is easier to deal with and install, but it's a bigger pain the ass to get wound tight. The strap stretches as it tightens down on the spool for the first few uses. The cable doesn't really do that, but the cable can get bound over itself which is another PITA, and that's when you will cut your hand. Ask me how I know that.
Regardless, if you have a straight bottom boat, ensure you have a safety chain that you latch before you pull up the ramp. Both straps and cables can break.
The strap is easier to deal with and install, but it's a bigger pain the ass to get wound tight. The strap stretches as it tightens down on the spool for the first few uses. The cable doesn't really do that, but the cable can get bound over itself which is another PITA, and that's when you will cut your hand. Ask me how I know that.
Regardless, if you have a straight bottom boat, ensure you have a safety chain that you latch before you pull up the ramp. Both straps and cables can break.
3pointstar
#7
If I was starting from scratch with a winch setup today, it would be these two:
https://www.crofttrailer.com/fulton-...y/#page=page-1
http://www.etrailer.com/Accessories-...n/F501204.html
Fulton also makes a 3200 lbs. winch, which is easier to find. But I think with the heavier setup, they give you better gearing/leverage.
https://www.crofttrailer.com/fulton-...y/#page=page-1
http://www.etrailer.com/Accessories-...n/F501204.html
Fulton also makes a 3200 lbs. winch, which is easier to find. But I think with the heavier setup, they give you better gearing/leverage.
#8
Registered
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 1,879
Likes: 8
From: Southeast Michigan
Dutton-Lainson. You can call them and get someone knowledgeable on the phone if you need a replacement part. I had rebuild kits for my tongue jack and winch within a few days. They've been in business since 1886 for a reason. I also prefer strap over cable.
https://www.dutton-lainson.com/prodd...php?prod=15440
https://www.dutton-lainson.com/prodd...php?prod=14881
https://www.dutton-lainson.com/prodd...php?prod=15440
https://www.dutton-lainson.com/prodd...php?prod=14881
Last edited by Speedracer29; 01-13-2017 at 01:21 PM.
#9
Registered

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 1,102
Likes: 11
From: Granger, Indiana
[QUOTE=Sydwayz;4519333]If I was starting from scratch with a winch setup today, it would be these two:
[url]https://www.crofttrailer.com/fulton
I just purchased a F2 Fulton, 3200# 2 speed trail winch- it just arrived today. I purchased it from Star Marine - (I have not connection with Star Marine) - it was less than Amazon and shipping was very inexpensive - I believe I got it in less than a week- it was a little shy of $150.00. Obviously I haven't put it on our trailer but it sure looks and feels very robust. It has the standard mounting and came with a "strap with hook". Spring can't come fast enough to northern Indiana
3pointstar
[url]https://www.crofttrailer.com/fulton
I just purchased a F2 Fulton, 3200# 2 speed trail winch- it just arrived today. I purchased it from Star Marine - (I have not connection with Star Marine) - it was less than Amazon and shipping was very inexpensive - I believe I got it in less than a week- it was a little shy of $150.00. Obviously I haven't put it on our trailer but it sure looks and feels very robust. It has the standard mounting and came with a "strap with hook". Spring can't come fast enough to northern Indiana
3pointstar
#10
Registered
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 2,960
Likes: 7
From: Sandown, NH - Sebago Lake Region, ME
I would seriously consider electric! I don't power load so I typically shallow dip the trailer so I can use the bunks to help align the hull with the trailer. This allows me to float the boat about 3/4 of the way on. I then hook up the winch and jump in the truck. I start winching with the remote while slowly backing in so the boat isn't dragging on the bunks. Once the boat is on the rubbers in the front the girlfriend hooks the safety chain and away we go.
Makes for super fast loads!


Makes for super fast loads!





