Carb vs fuel injection?
#51
Registered

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 714
Likes: 4
Last edited by bajabob; 03-19-2013 at 08:52 PM.
#52
Registered

Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
From: Mokena,IL
NOT SHORE LORAZO BUILT MY MOTOR. 10 to 1 comp. 675 lift on the cam . dyno sheet i can not post picture here.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eL8i0Tnw7Qk 32degree timing . next run the timing was 34 . now i have it at 36 and i got a bigger carb 1050 dom
#53
Registered

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 9,973
Likes: 6,467
From: Chicago
Well my first experience was with a 600sc that even after having rebuilt both carbs and fu%#@king with both of them for hours on end ...on the water and on the hose, I could never get to idle decent or low enough.
Heres to my second carb boat experience being better.
Heres to my second carb boat experience being better.
#54
Registered

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 11,332
Likes: 73
From: chicago
This is where EFI has a advantage. You can have a 650RPM idle in neutral, and a 650RPM idle in gear. The IAC controls idle speed. Carbs, you just cant do it. The in gear idle will always be less than the in neutral idle. You just cant expect a big high performance carb'ed engine to idle at 600RPM.
A carb'd 1976 500CI Cadillac engine, sure. You can idle it down to 400RPM and it will still run. But a 190HP 500CI engine isn't gonna act the same as a 800HP 500CI engine. You cant expect it to.
I have a high performance boat. I grew up as a kid loving drag racing, loud engines, going fast and wrenching on my toys. I do it because I have a passion for it. If adjusting a carb screw, or idling 200rpm higher than my neighbors minivan bothers me, I need to get out of the hobby.My boat does transport my kids to school, I do not drive it cross country for business, it does not take me to the doctor for checkups. Its simply their to put a smile on my face when I lite the motors off, and go for a ride. If EFI makes you smile, by all means go for it.
#55
Registered
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 907
Likes: 4
From: Baton Rouge, La
I tune fuel injected motorcycles on my dyno on a daily basis and fully understand what it takes to tune one. That being said, I have a 750 rwhp twin turbo lightning (old 351 version) that I pulled the fuel injection off to try a blow thru carb setup. Reason is I get bored fast and I'm always doing something new with it and have grown sick of buying new injectors. I have at least 5 sets sitting in my shop. (19lbs, 24,30,42,72). Is that normal? Probably not. I know guys who built there hot rods 15 years ago and have done nothing, but change the oil since then. I can't do that. I am for ever changing stuff and just got sick of all the extra supporting equipment that changes on a fuel injected setup as you change or modify things. At least that's been my experience with my lighting that I've owned since 94' and had 3 different blowers, two different turbo setups I've built, two different nitrous setups, multiple head changes and who knows how many custom cams. I suppose I have a sickness and can't leave stuff alone. I'm not going to even mention bikes because its 5 times worse.
My current boat boat that I'm building I did pull the fuel injection off to build a carbed 509 for a couple reasons mentioned in this post. Since I can tune fuel injection I would want to try and tune the boat, but what I've read is that the mefi1 is not so great when it comes to tuning for many of the reasons listed in this thread. The thought of buying more fuel injection setups to replace the version I had wasn't even a thought. My last boat was a carb and in 150 hours (1.5 seasons) I never had a single issue related to the carb. If I have similar results with this new boat I will be more than happy.
On a personal level I think the mpi intake looks like poo and like the look of single plane intake and carb setup. That goes triple for a roots blower with carbs on top. I'm drawn to any and all roots blown cars at the shows like a bug to a bug zapper. Not sure why...probably the root to this sickness that I call my hobby.
My current boat boat that I'm building I did pull the fuel injection off to build a carbed 509 for a couple reasons mentioned in this post. Since I can tune fuel injection I would want to try and tune the boat, but what I've read is that the mefi1 is not so great when it comes to tuning for many of the reasons listed in this thread. The thought of buying more fuel injection setups to replace the version I had wasn't even a thought. My last boat was a carb and in 150 hours (1.5 seasons) I never had a single issue related to the carb. If I have similar results with this new boat I will be more than happy.
On a personal level I think the mpi intake looks like poo and like the look of single plane intake and carb setup. That goes triple for a roots blower with carbs on top. I'm drawn to any and all roots blown cars at the shows like a bug to a bug zapper. Not sure why...probably the root to this sickness that I call my hobby.
Last edited by cp5899; 03-20-2013 at 07:30 AM.
#56
Registered

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 9,973
Likes: 6,467
From: Chicago
#58
Registered

Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 1,689
Likes: 115
From: Slidell, La.
The majority of 25 OL are beginner performance boat buyers.
When I was buying my 25OL.. I was definitly looking for reliability and ease of operation. My last boat was a carbed 350 and ran well.. still had to pump throttle at cold start but wanted to turn key and voila!
its like selling your house with a pool. You limit your demographics and it will affect price.
if your selling... stay with EFI!
When I was buying my 25OL.. I was definitly looking for reliability and ease of operation. My last boat was a carbed 350 and ran well.. still had to pump throttle at cold start but wanted to turn key and voila!
its like selling your house with a pool. You limit your demographics and it will affect price.
if your selling... stay with EFI!
#59
Registered

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 714
Likes: 4
EFI is dummy proof, only on a stock motor if you add more hp to your motor you have to charge alot and you have to have a a/f box and computer hook to your motor to reprogram the computer. how many guys no how to do that??????? i like efi only when you have a stock motor. like me i am always making more hp on my motor .so carb is for me. i got a m1 a/f box and dail my motor in and gain 2mph because i was to rich, went down two size on the jets
Last edited by bajabob; 03-20-2013 at 02:01 PM.


