How long will these xr drives last???
#11
Registered

Joined: May 2009
Posts: 3,895
Likes: 124
From: Chicago, IL; Onekama, MI
I have a 39 Cigarette with 600 SCIs. I had fresh XRs, this spring they were rebuild by Offshore Outdrive in Florida. I was very easy on the boat all summer knowing they were a weak link. I blew a drive within 15 hours. Unless you like to idle all day, I don't think they will last long at all with your engines and boat. Sell them while you can, and buy SCX drives.
#14
Registered

Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 922
Likes: 54
From: Lago Vista TX

5000 lb 29' single tho'. No comparason to what the OP is running
(PS.. but I guess THIS one of yours wasn't built br Frank's marine hence the extended life
)Last edited by Boatally Insane; 10-05-2020 at 06:24 PM.
#15
Registered

Joined: May 2018
Posts: 593
Likes: 111
From: Western Pennsylvanoa
What is XR rated HP/torque from mercury?
I had a "NEW" from mercury B1 drive behind stock 496HO and top gears destructed after 10months. Merc warrantied and I paid the difference for the X drive and from day 1 noticed it's noisy which I presume from the top gears. Now got 50hrs and nothing on magnets. Shouldn't the XR handle more power, why the failure?
I had a "NEW" from mercury B1 drive behind stock 496HO and top gears destructed after 10months. Merc warrantied and I paid the difference for the X drive and from day 1 noticed it's noisy which I presume from the top gears. Now got 50hrs and nothing on magnets. Shouldn't the XR handle more power, why the failure?
#16
Registered
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 1,621
Likes: 402
From: Cheboygan, MI
There are some serious design flaws in the Bravo drives that need to be fixed to handle any kind of power. When I blew my first drive in a 5500lb boat with about 700hp, I took it to George at AADS. He showed me boxes of broken shafts and they were all broken in exactly the same spot. When the bearing goes it puts more load on the gears so they chew themselves up. He redesigned the bearing and shaft which is huge for extending the life of the drive. I've had him do a level 3 rebuild along with having the gears cryo'd. So far so good, just finished my third season and I just can't bring myself to baby it like I know I should. I also have a pretty big cam which doesn't really develop power until I get on plane which helps the life of the drive. You definitely need better oil then the Merc stuff. I run NEO oil which after 3 seasons is still clear and in good shape. I drain some every season when I check the magnets and check for water or degradation. Best part is the 24 month warranty from AADS even with your power level.
#17
Yup, I was breaking XR's on a 30' boat w/525efi. Pretty sure it was the 5 blades that was doing it. The boat had close to 200 hrs. running a bravo prop. After switching to a Maximus I broke the drive twice in the next 150 hrs.
#20
Gold Member

Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 3,748
Likes: 869
From: Delray Beach, FL
From 2 minutes to 40 hours its a crapshoot. I prefer the heavier weight unicorn oils that promise the world but it still doesnt change the true destiny of an XR. I think a few other guys running on XR's do the same as me, whenever I saw one that looked good I bought it and kept in in the corner till I needed it.




