outerlimits rolled?
#201
Registered

Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 965
Likes: 123
Wish they would just respond to the original reports where the two in the boat said they caught a bad wave and were not going that fast. Then someone said it was a tab down to far and the boat was out for a speed run at over 100mph, which was it? Just tell us all the truth so the rumors are stopped.
#202
Registered
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 1,491
Likes: 0
From: LI, New York
Fine with me as long as the salesman discloses that before the boat is sold. These guys won't even say how fast they were going or if they were turning so really hard to make any of these statements or assumptions without more information. People want to know how risky the boat is. Doesn't seem like OL really cares. When some people die they will care.

#204
Banned
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 121
Likes: 0
It is not hard to understand but you have two different versions of the same incident with two people who were in the SAME boat. Driver says tab down, passenger says hit a wave. Which one factor was the cause? Or was it both factors (tab and wave) simultaneously? Or is there just some bullsh*t factor going on here? You are a frequent defender of the infallableness of OL. I like OL, I just don't buy the bullsh*t. It is getting old pretty quick.
#205
Banned
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 121
Likes: 0
If asking a simple question about the safety of a new boat for any potential ol customers is such a secret there might be a problem. I just think the truth should be told once and for all by ol so we all know the facts. Who knows i may be a customer in the near future.
#206
Registered

Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 2,796
Likes: 396
1. http://www.eastbayri.com/news/2012/may/15/boat-flip/ -1direct passenger statement:
A rescue boat transported one of the boat’s occupants, John Makepeace, to the shore where rescue personnel were awaiting.
“We weren’t going very fast,” Mr. Makepeace said, as he was being tended to by medical personnel. “We just kind of caught a wave.”
2. http://midwestboatparty.com/forum/sh...-the-29OL-Roll
Second-hand information:
Mike Fiore and friend were out pushing the limits and having fun in the 29. It ran well into the 100's with some tweaks. Mike called me last night and said he had a tab dragging and the indicator did not reflect that. He went into the turn, said it didn't feel quiet right an pushed through it. Rolled and ejected them. Both are alright. Mike was upbeat about the issue. Said its a mechanical issue and the supplier would rectify the issue. It will be back on the water ASAP!
This is all in earlier posts, hope that answers your question. There is not a direct statement from Michael Fiore, there are statements in this thread from WhippleCharged and Animalhouse (OL affiliated) that support the trim indicator failure/tab deployed scenario.
I like the boat, but I wouldn't spend $200K for it, if it were $100K then I would be real intertested; I am not their target customer.
Last edited by Smarty; 05-22-2012 at 08:53 PM. Reason: correction (second hand)
#207
What the hell is going on here. it's a boat, any boat can flip/roll/sink, Look at the Titanic for crying out loud.
That is why they test and test boats, if there is a problem it will be fixed, no matter if its a tab or whatever it's not like we are talking about a Commander boat here. ( but that's another story and Outerlimits is way above and beyond the quality of a Commander)
Ask Tres Martin how many times he has been thrown from his own boat, he pushed and pushed the limits so he knew what to look out for.
I doubt that there is a single high performance boat manufacture that hasn't had one of there boats underwater.
That is why they test and test boats, if there is a problem it will be fixed, no matter if its a tab or whatever it's not like we are talking about a Commander boat here. ( but that's another story and Outerlimits is way above and beyond the quality of a Commander)
Ask Tres Martin how many times he has been thrown from his own boat, he pushed and pushed the limits so he knew what to look out for.
I doubt that there is a single high performance boat manufacture that hasn't had one of there boats underwater.
#208
Registered

Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 2,796
Likes: 396
What the hell is going on here. it's a boat, any boat can flip/roll/sink, Look at the Titanic for crying out loud.
That is why they test and test boats, if there is a problem it will be fixed, no matter if its a tab or whatever it's not like we are talking about a Commander boat here. ( but that's another story and Outerlimits is way above and beyond the quality of a Commander)
Ask Tres Martin how many times he has been thrown from his own boat, he pushed and pushed the limits so he knew what to look out for.
I doubt that there is a single high performance boat manufacture that hasn't had one of there boats underwater.
That is why they test and test boats, if there is a problem it will be fixed, no matter if its a tab or whatever it's not like we are talking about a Commander boat here. ( but that's another story and Outerlimits is way above and beyond the quality of a Commander)
Ask Tres Martin how many times he has been thrown from his own boat, he pushed and pushed the limits so he knew what to look out for.
I doubt that there is a single high performance boat manufacture that hasn't had one of there boats underwater.
Now that the boat is finally here it has an accident, people are curious.
As far as getting wet, I have been boating for 40+ years and have only capsized once, I was six years old in an 11' aluminum boat with a 5.5 hp Evinrude with a tiller arm jumping boat waves in Absecon inlet (1971). As an adult either driving or a passenger, in a Cigarette, Magnum, Pantera, multiple Donzi's, and now a Phantom, I was never ejected or capsized, nor do I have an expectation of such an event occurring.
And I have been a passenger boat that made an extreme hard turn at 85 mph without hesitation (boat handled great) or incident (27' Magnum Sport, my father was driving had to make an emergency turn). So maybe it it not always the drivers fault, some boats just maybe be safer than other boats.
I am not the least bit concerned at the present time about whether the 29' OL is safe or unsafe, it has been written in post #161 that the boat felt fine when E Colby was driving it, and I will take his word as truthful and intelligent, so to me the boat is OK. I will not be buying this 29' OL so I am done with this thread, bottonline - no one was hurt, that is all that matters. Accidents happen.
It has been an interesting thread.
#210
Registered
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 2,057
Likes: 0
It is not hard to understand but you have two different versions of the same incident with two people who were in the SAME boat. Driver says tab down, passenger says hit a wave. Which one factor was the cause? Or was it both factors (tab and wave) simultaneously? Or is there just some bullsh*t factor going on here? You are a frequent defender of the infallableness of OL. I like OL, I just don't buy the bullsh*t. It is getting old pretty quick.



