Solid roller lifters?
#94
Registered

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,613
Likes: 375
From: Traverse City MI
Interesting info here and we will never know the truth. But I appreciate the option to open my mind and explore these thoughts.
I'm always nervous when talking with a company, even the engineers, if I'm just falling for a sales pitch or not, or maybe something in between.
30hp is a lot though
Everything's biased, all tests and articles are paid for by someone.
How often do you read "so and so new product, lifter, hull, snowmobile, dirt bike, crank, rod, is junk, Rob's horsepower, handles like garbage, etc.
I'm always nervous when talking with a company, even the engineers, if I'm just falling for a sales pitch or not, or maybe something in between.
30hp is a lot though
Everything's biased, all tests and articles are paid for by someone.
How often do you read "so and so new product, lifter, hull, snowmobile, dirt bike, crank, rod, is junk, Rob's horsepower, handles like garbage, etc.
Last edited by offshorexcursion; 12-11-2016 at 04:12 PM. Reason: 30hp is a lot though
#95
Registered
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 2,733
Likes: 8
From: bel air, md
"Blinded by the salesmen with the pitches". Beautiful. Are the enginelab articles a sales pitch. In my travels those articles are considered pretty reputable. So the definition of a horsepower I believe is the power to raise 550 pounds a distance of one foot in one second. Now I don't know exactly what that means in terms of human strength. But, if you take a lifter out of the box, hold it in one hand with 2 fingers and spin the roller with a finger on the other hand, which all of us are capable of doing what fraction of a horsepower is that? Times 16 what fraction of a horsepower? Seriously, how was your test conducted? Was it on the dyno the same day, same atmospheric conditions, same engine temperature? Did the first time you set the timing it came in a degree retarded from the last setting and "that was close enough". Maybe the lifters were tight in the bore. Therefore it was the lifter body causing a more drag and not the roller. That would make more sense than the drag of the roller. 30 horsepower is a big difference to lose from the roller resistance
#97
Registered

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 3,865
Likes: 793
From: St. Pete Beach, FL
Spintrons exist, this can be measured. 30hp sounds high, that's the difference between a flat tappet and a roller cam with a more aggressive profile! I agree about the heat too, that would be a ton.
#98
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 8,356
Likes: 1,515
From: NW Michigan
You know there's something to be said about those solid flat tappet. If I'm not mistaking Rookie ran them for years making great power on 468's I believe. I only heard second hand however believe this to be true. If you think back it wasn't real long ago there was a bunch of power being made with them and didn't seem to be all these issues with failures from rollers to hyd lifters. I wonder how many solid flat tappets go in builds nowadays? How much power loss estimated from solid roller to nonroller? 20-30?
With reading all the post there is some interesting info here. Something else to consider is other parts/applications that use bearing rather than bushing. Being a cam the pressures vary much but look at other parts like ujoints, wheel bearings, and so on. Now on the other hand in a sense our entire engine is assembles bushing (bearings). I haven't had the balls to try needle cam... I'm fine with the old school.
So is everyone pretty much on board with bushed lifters? As mentioned in earlier post I keep on on regular maintenance and would be lucky to see 60-70 hrs max a season. Rookie had a good point though with being able to send the isky's off for rebuild every couple hundred hours or whatever isky would recommend.
With reading all the post there is some interesting info here. Something else to consider is other parts/applications that use bearing rather than bushing. Being a cam the pressures vary much but look at other parts like ujoints, wheel bearings, and so on. Now on the other hand in a sense our entire engine is assembles bushing (bearings). I haven't had the balls to try needle cam... I'm fine with the old school.
So is everyone pretty much on board with bushed lifters? As mentioned in earlier post I keep on on regular maintenance and would be lucky to see 60-70 hrs max a season. Rookie had a good point though with being able to send the isky's off for rebuild every couple hundred hours or whatever isky would recommend.
#99
How much of an impact does prolonged idle times (no wake zones, long river out to the lake time etc.....) have on a bushed lifter?
I was under the impression that the bushed lifter needed some RPM to maintain the oil wedge and live.
I was under the impression that the bushed lifter needed some RPM to maintain the oil wedge and live.
#100
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 8,356
Likes: 1,515
From: NW Michigan
Does morel offer both bushed and needle or just bushed?




