What if only a couple are out of spec? Is it half ass-ed just to fix the ones that are bad, or should they all be sleeved at that time?

. . .Pay me know or Pay me later. Since you have it down, I would do them all.

DO them all save the aggrivation. And only use the maching method to replace the guides with bronze to prevent leaking.

I hear yea, the thing is I paid X amount of dollars to have the thing rebuilt. I told him to price it to last another 1000 trouble free hours. I wasn't looking for the best deal, I just wanted reliability. Sounds like he is trying to take a short cut.

Not every thing is listed on the quote, I wouldn't think you would reuse the rings if they were OK.
Please let me know what you think.