another b1 vs. xr question
02-12-2013 | 04:07 PM
#1
Thread Starter
Registered
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 1,248
Likes: 3
From: indianapolis
another b1 vs. xr question
I know this has been gone over a zillion times but just to recap.
I broke a b1 at the end of the season last year, it broke the upper gears. Boat is a 96 31' scarab with procharged 502's. I was thinking about switching over to xr's but it seems like they break just as much as the b1's. So on to my question, are they really that much stronger to quantify the expense over the b1's? Im leaning towards keeping the b1's on the boat and just building some spares. If im going to break them at close to the same rate I would rather be building and buying b1's over the xr's. Am i close on my thinking?
I broke a b1 at the end of the season last year, it broke the upper gears. Boat is a 96 31' scarab with procharged 502's. I was thinking about switching over to xr's but it seems like they break just as much as the b1's. So on to my question, are they really that much stronger to quantify the expense over the b1's? Im leaning towards keeping the b1's on the boat and just building some spares. If im going to break them at close to the same rate I would rather be building and buying b1's over the xr's. Am i close on my thinking?
02-12-2013 | 04:25 PM
#2
Registered
Joined: Jul 2011
Posts: 821
Likes: 0
From: mirabel,qc
The XR's are stronger....theoretically....but the quality/finish of the gears leaves a lot to be desired...there is a member here working on an improved set...if you want an XR,try to find an older one...apparently the gears are of better quality...
not a drive expert,but i do run an xr...so far,no problems
not a drive expert,but i do run an xr...so far,no problems
02-12-2013 | 09:24 PM
#8
Registered
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 209
Likes: 0
From: Windsor, Canada
I know this has been gone over a zillion times but just to recap.
I broke a b1 at the end of the season last year, it broke the upper gears. Boat is a 96 31' scarab with procharged 502's. I was thinking about switching over to xr's but it seems like they break just as much as the b1's. So on to my question, are they really that much stronger to quantify the expense over the b1's? Im leaning towards keeping the b1's on the boat and just building some spares. If im going to break them at close to the same rate I would rather be building and buying b1's over the xr's. Am i close on my thinking?
I broke a b1 at the end of the season last year, it broke the upper gears. Boat is a 96 31' scarab with procharged 502's. I was thinking about switching over to xr's but it seems like they break just as much as the b1's. So on to my question, are they really that much stronger to quantify the expense over the b1's? Im leaning towards keeping the b1's on the boat and just building some spares. If im going to break them at close to the same rate I would rather be building and buying b1's over the xr's. Am i close on my thinking?
