On the subject of Safety.....and flames
#51
Registered
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 1,134
Likes: 160
From: central IL
I know exactly what that looks like lol. 99% of the field failures I've seen are a lack of routine maintenance because it wasn't "in the budget". Let them sit in a farm field all year untouched and then fire them up on a moments notice when they need the "peaker" to help keep up with demand. Routine maintenance is cheap compared to what I/we bill out at lol
#54
Registered

Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 340
Likes: 35
#55
#56
Registered

Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 59
Likes: 38
…but he has the most lovely wife that more than makes up for his indiscretions
.
Seriously though, he is correct in that there are many applications where SMALL turbines are installed in less than perfect operating environments due to their high specific power. My understanding is the Abrams utilise elaborate multi-stage filters (which of course are conspicuous by their absence in the race boats). I can’t comment on each turbine’s physical shock load endurance but the vertical accelerations planing hulls exert on anything rigidly connected to them whilst travelling at high speeds on rough water are almost unparalleled -save for perhaps carrier landings. However I don’t have the numbers for the carrier landings either so it may be that these shock loads are in fact within a given turbine’s design specification. Perhaps someone with direct turbine design engineering experience can educate us here. In any event I think the point is turbines of all sizes have been proven to work reliably and safely in many environments provided their installation and operating parameters are properly engineered.
ND1
.Seriously though, he is correct in that there are many applications where SMALL turbines are installed in less than perfect operating environments due to their high specific power. My understanding is the Abrams utilise elaborate multi-stage filters (which of course are conspicuous by their absence in the race boats). I can’t comment on each turbine’s physical shock load endurance but the vertical accelerations planing hulls exert on anything rigidly connected to them whilst travelling at high speeds on rough water are almost unparalleled -save for perhaps carrier landings. However I don’t have the numbers for the carrier landings either so it may be that these shock loads are in fact within a given turbine’s design specification. Perhaps someone with direct turbine design engineering experience can educate us here. In any event I think the point is turbines of all sizes have been proven to work reliably and safely in many environments provided their installation and operating parameters are properly engineered.
ND1
#58
Thread Starter
Allergic to Nonsense
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 5,007
Likes: 21
From: Granite Quarry, NC
One point of note here is that all of the talk around the Abrams fails to recognise the 'gynormous" DOD budget that went into perfecting the design and the uncountable man years of engineering behind the entire tank program. We must be keenly aware that a rather small bunch of boat racer/runners have waded into the deep water of turbine technology (no pun intended) with nowhere near the resources used in developing these motors in the first place. Therefore I agree that we should find and leverage the best data available on fire suppression and avoidance in military, aircraft, and other turbine implementations. Obviously , each time we board a jet or turbo prop plane we feel secure in the knowledge that fire avoidance and suppression systems work seamlessly around the world on a 24/7 basis in these aircraft. The Geico guys are, as usual, out front in this, but it looks like there is still ample room between the current state of the art in high speed marine turbine applications and the established safety norms for real world turbine usage.
Last edited by T2x; 11-19-2013 at 01:56 PM.
#60
Registered

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 5,008
Likes: 752
From: Traverse City, Michigan
…but he has the most lovely wife that more than makes up for his indiscretions
.
Seriously though, he is correct in that there are many applications where SMALL turbines are installed in less than perfect operating environments due to their high specific power. My understanding is the Abrams utilise elaborate multi-stage filters (which of course are conspicuous by their absence in the race boats). I can’t comment on each turbine’s physical shock load endurance but the vertical accelerations planing hulls exert on anything rigidly connected to them whilst travelling at high speeds on rough water are almost unparalleled -save for perhaps carrier landings. However I don’t have the numbers for the carrier landings either so it may be that these shock loads are in fact within a given turbine’s design specification. Perhaps someone with direct turbine design engineering experience can educate us here. In any event I think the point is turbines of all sizes have been proven to work reliably and safely in many environments provided their installation and operating parameters are properly engineered.
ND1
.Seriously though, he is correct in that there are many applications where SMALL turbines are installed in less than perfect operating environments due to their high specific power. My understanding is the Abrams utilise elaborate multi-stage filters (which of course are conspicuous by their absence in the race boats). I can’t comment on each turbine’s physical shock load endurance but the vertical accelerations planing hulls exert on anything rigidly connected to them whilst travelling at high speeds on rough water are almost unparalleled -save for perhaps carrier landings. However I don’t have the numbers for the carrier landings either so it may be that these shock loads are in fact within a given turbine’s design specification. Perhaps someone with direct turbine design engineering experience can educate us here. In any event I think the point is turbines of all sizes have been proven to work reliably and safely in many environments provided their installation and operating parameters are properly engineered.
ND1



