Notices
General Boating Discussion

hard lessons.

Thread Tools
 
Old 04-13-2017 | 03:02 PM
  #111  
Registered
20 Year Member
 
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 3,861
Likes: 793
From: St. Pete Beach, FL
Default

Originally Posted by sprsptr
Hey jusabum, You are naive if you think any of these super high performance cats are "designed by guesswork at best" and have not been engineered. Computer Aided Design has been in use for many years now. I can assure you that there are thousands of hours in hydrodynamic testing both real and computer generated to insure quality products that are viable for the intended market. There is no manufacturer that wants the stigma of this tragedy associated with it's brand.
False, it's all done by trial and error, theories and ideas. Design changes occur model by model, perhaps boat by boat. The judgment criteria is speed. If the handling "feels" really bad, they might rework it. Computer aided design is just that, design software. It's not a dynamic model.
hogie roll is offline  
Reply
Old 04-13-2017 | 03:14 PM
  #112  
Registered
20 Year Member
 
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 3,861
Likes: 793
From: St. Pete Beach, FL
Default

No one knows how much which factors contributed to the crash. You're all speculating based on your personal biases.

Obviously alcohol rarely helps. the risks are well known documented. But I think everyone wants to blame that because they love big high performance boats.
Fast cats have a couple of crash modes, and due to their high speeds, passenger ejections aren't very survivable in them.
A. Backflip due to packing air and cg being near the back of the boat
B. Roll due going on one sponson which then steers itself under the boat.
C. Fast singles have added risk of not having props with countering forces.

I think a big light cat probably gives a false sense of security. If the tunnel area to weight ratio is similar, and the speeds scaled up, its no less of risk to flip than as smaller cat.
hogie roll is offline  
Reply
Old 04-13-2017 | 03:31 PM
  #113  
Registered
15 Year Member
 
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 1,119
Likes: 2
From: Central IL / Green Bay, WI
Default

Originally Posted by hogie roll
False, it's all done by trial and error, theories and ideas. Design changes occur model by model, perhaps boat by boat. The judgment criteria is speed. If the handling "feels" really bad, they might rework it. Computer aided design is just that, design software. It's not a dynamic model.
Ever heard of CFD....Computational Fluid Dynamics?

Dynamic is right in the name.
Wasted Income is offline  
Reply
Old 04-13-2017 | 05:08 PM
  #114  
Registered
 
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 608
Likes: 1
From: Plano, Texas
Default

Originally Posted by Wasted Income
Wreckless behavior is good. This thread wouldn't exist if these guys were wreckless.


Reckless behavior however, is not good.
I'll agree with you, not good. Maybe you didn't get the intended pun but that's ok.

Any trouble with the rest of my spelling or punctuation?
Hook'em is offline  
Reply
Old 04-13-2017 | 05:16 PM
  #115  
Registered
10 Year Member
 
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 331
Likes: 84
Default

Originally Posted by Wasted Income
Ever heard of CFD....Computational Fluid Dynamics?

Dynamic is right in the name.
Yes, I have heard of it. And like I said before, the flow of "fluid" is only part of it...BUT, none of the boat manufacturers use it, or any other data-driven testing.

HOGIE ROLL SAID IT PERFECTLY:
it's all done by trial and error, theories and ideas. Design changes occur model by model, perhaps boat by boat. The judgment criteria is speed. If the handling "feels" really bad, they might rework it. Computer aided design is just that, design software. It's not a dynamic model.
jusabum is offline  
Reply
Old 04-13-2017 | 06:21 PM
  #116  
Registered
10 Year Member
 
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 331
Likes: 84
Default

CATAMARAN.
Hydrodynamics - sponson lift.
Aerodynamics - a semi-wing effect creating lift.
The tunnel design creates compression, lightening the boat, reducing drag.
Thrust trying to overcome Drag, moving the boat forward creating inertia.
Lift trying to overcome Gravity and Drag to create speed.
Water changing the angle of attack, mixed signals.
Throttles creating more push, or less, depending on perceived circumstance
Driver, thinking he has control, adjusting the angle of attack and direction.

All of this was not a big deal at speeds in the 90's, gravity and drag seemed to always bring the boat back from borderline disaster (in most cases). But every length has its limit, or hull speed as the used to call it. So, the boats got longer, and lighter, allowing for more speed and some perceived stability.

But we are exceeding the limits now. At a certain point of speed, to weight, to running surface, there is no difference than strapping a jet engine on a flat board.

We are seeing speeds increased beyond the point of no return, the boat naturally wants to fly after a certain point. Gravity plays less of a role as lift becomes the dominate factor.

Without flight controls, the boat is at the mercy of lift and inertia. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUVSEcePCr8

Last edited by jusabum; 04-13-2017 at 06:24 PM.
jusabum is offline  
Reply
Old 04-13-2017 | 07:37 PM
  #117  
Registered
10 Year Member
 
Joined: Aug 2014
Posts: 250
Likes: 37
From: MN
Default

How many of you make better decisions when drunk?
How many domestics or stupid fights happen because people are drunk vs sober?
How many athletes perform better when they are drunk vs sober?
How many people have called a girl at night drunk and woke up the next morning thinking what was I thinking?

These are all decision making skills that are effected by being drunk!
Driving a boat requires decision making skills at all times as well as reaction time and processing skills to be at a high level. If your driving your car at 75 mph and you think its fast, now drive 125 mph and come up on a car going 75 mph. You better have your decision making skills on high alert.
Now do that in a boat that is not on a flat surface, in fact a very rough surface with rolling waves coming at you and no brakes.
Drunk skills will not make you react better or decide better things like maybe I should slow down or I cant read the water very good maybe I shouldnt push it.

People are loving to pick on the Cat boats for being unsafe. Every kind of boat has a safe speed they can and should be able to run. When you push it past that point your running into safety issues in a cat, a sport v bottom, a center console, fishing boat, every boat is designed to run safely to a certain speed. If you push them past that speed you could start to run into safety problems. This is no different from any type of car/truck/motorcycle,v bottom boat or Catamaran boat.
As the boats are getting faster the designs are getting different, move steps, strakes, notches, pads, width, on and on... I wouldn't want to take a 80's checkmate and go run 100 mph.
A 36' cat going almost 200 seems sketchy but honestly anything nearing that 200 mark on water or land seems sketchy.
There was a V bottom at the shootout last August who crashed by chine walking and spinning out at about 80 mph. That doesnt make all v bottoms unsafe it just means that particular setup and driver found the limits on that day.
All boats and cars have there limits, sometimes you may be able to push past them but it better be the right time and right place and then there still is no guarantees.
hustlerguy is offline  
Reply
Old 04-13-2017 | 07:45 PM
  #118  
Registered
20 Year Member
 
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 3,861
Likes: 793
From: St. Pete Beach, FL
Default

Originally Posted by Wasted Income
Ever heard of CFD....Computational Fluid Dynamics?

Dynamic is right in the name.
Would be impossible to develop anything but a model with perfectly flat water and no wind.
hogie roll is offline  
Reply
Old 04-13-2017 | 07:51 PM
  #119  
Registered
20 Year Member
 
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 3,861
Likes: 793
From: St. Pete Beach, FL
Default

I don't think it's fair to imply that all boat types are inherently as dangerous as each other. The only people with statistics to back that up would be insurance companies. The difference in insurance rates between boat types should give you a good idea of the relative risks.
hogie roll is offline  
Reply
Old 04-13-2017 | 08:01 PM
  #120  
Registered
10 Year Member
 
Joined: Aug 2014
Posts: 250
Likes: 37
From: MN
Default

A V running 150 and a cat running 150 mph rates are similar if value is similar
A V running 110 and a cat running 110 mph rates are similar if value is similar

The real difference is there is very few V's running 120+ and alot of Cats running 120+
There are no production V's running 165+ and several production 165+ cats
hustlerguy is offline  
Reply


Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service

Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.