Whats TO HOT FOR OIL TEMP
#21
Thread Starter
Registered
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 25
Likes: 0
I just spoke with the Rd Guy at Cenpeco Racing oil, Told him my application and what my oil temp was getting up to, 230-235 when running wide open, He told me that he would not be worried at all, He said heat will hurt the life span of the oil but not so fast that i have anything to worry about. He told me he has many customers that run cars and dragsters up around 300 degree oil temps, dirt cars at 50+ plus laps at 290 -300 degree oil temps and the oil holds up. Mild thunder are you running a blower or pro charger any kind of forced air. Usually these applications cause alot more heat than naturally aspirated engine.
#22
Registered
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 879
Likes: 0
From: Annapolis, MD
I had my self worried a few weeks back... My gauges both started reading 320 degrees so I was getting concerned.. The second I slowed back down the temps dropped.. I decided to hit it with a gun at the filter (also where the sending unit is). When I hit it with a gun, I was reading 260 on the gauge and 220 on the gun... Gauges are way off... That being said, I'd be running about 280 while running hard.
#23
Registered

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 222
Likes: 1
From: Newbury Park Ca
I had my self worried a few weeks back... My gauges both started reading 320 degrees so I was getting concerned.. The second I slowed back down the temps dropped.. I decided to hit it with a gun at the filter (also where the sending unit is). When I hit it with a gun, I was reading 260 on the gauge and 220 on the gun... Gauges are way off... That being said, I'd be running about 280 while running hard.
#24
Registered

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 11,332
Likes: 73
From: chicago
I have the one with a 1" bypass hose which is much larger than stock, it honestly flows an absolute ton of water through the exhaust lol. Registering no water pressure on gauge (water line is same place yours is, port side drain on block) with this set up. I can pinch down the bypass hose and get it to register, have to pinch it down a good bit. I think I am going to just block off the bypass and remove the thermostat for now untill I get a bigger oil cooler. Atleast that will get my oil temps down some so I have more head room with temps there
#25
Banned
Joined: Jun 2013
Posts: 1,014
Likes: 0
From: AZ
Engineers at mercury aren't dummies. There's a reason they specd the oil stats to open around the 210 range. I believe on the newer merc racing engines the alarm will sound if the oil temp reaches like 220 or 230.
Bottom line is oil breaks down with heat. Synthetics hold up better but still can breakdown.
I've never hurt an engine from running the oil on the cooler side of the scale. 212 is boiling for water. However, put a pot of water on the stove at 175 degrees, and you'll see steam vapors. Point is the 212 number isn't crucial . Most engine oils are designed around a operating temp of 200 degrees.
I'm not gonna get into the debate on oil shearing , oil brand, base stocks, blah blah blah. After several hundred hours the proof is in the pudding. If mercury or any other manufacturer wanted high oil temp, they would design it to have high oil temp , but they dont. I don't hold my engine wide open for a few seconds and let off like a sissy. I wanna be able to hold my ****t on the dash and watch the oil temp hold steady. That's where a good oil stat unit and large cooler come in. But even they can't overcome a poor oiling setup, extreme valve spring surge, or lean fuel system.
As far as the 502mpi seeing 235 deg with 520hp and stock cooler ,.....I would install a larger cooler rather than remove the water stat.
Bottom line is oil breaks down with heat. Synthetics hold up better but still can breakdown.
I've never hurt an engine from running the oil on the cooler side of the scale. 212 is boiling for water. However, put a pot of water on the stove at 175 degrees, and you'll see steam vapors. Point is the 212 number isn't crucial . Most engine oils are designed around a operating temp of 200 degrees.
I'm not gonna get into the debate on oil shearing , oil brand, base stocks, blah blah blah. After several hundred hours the proof is in the pudding. If mercury or any other manufacturer wanted high oil temp, they would design it to have high oil temp , but they dont. I don't hold my engine wide open for a few seconds and let off like a sissy. I wanna be able to hold my ****t on the dash and watch the oil temp hold steady. That's where a good oil stat unit and large cooler come in. But even they can't overcome a poor oiling setup, extreme valve spring surge, or lean fuel system.
As far as the 502mpi seeing 235 deg with 520hp and stock cooler ,.....I would install a larger cooler rather than remove the water stat.
Cooler oil is most definitely NOT better in many circumstances. I'm not saying a thermostat is mandatory, however if you are running a 140 thermostat in your engine (naturally aspirated) and no thermostat with a large oil cooler, your oil temps will more than likely be too cold. The oil is not going to be at the temperature for optimal operation. Let alone to burn off the water introduced by the product of combustion.
#26
Registered

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 11,332
Likes: 73
From: chicago
Your statement that "most" oils are designed to operate at 200 degrees is false, the operating viscosity is spec'd @ 100 degrees Celsius (212 Fahrenheit). That's a fact. I think a major oil companies tribologysts knows a little bit more than mercury marine. And mercury uses 210 degrees set point on the modern oil thermostats, so I'm really not sure what your point is? I never said they are wrong. My thermostat is set 5 degrees higher. 220 degrees even in a conventional oils isn't an issue whatsoever. They put these cushions in to protect their interest for the sake of warranty.
Cooler oil is most definitely NOT better in many circumstances. I'm not saying a thermostat is mandatory, however if you are running a 140 thermostat in your engine (naturally aspirated) and no thermostat with a large oil cooler, your oil temps will more than likely be too cold. The oil is not going to be at the temperature for optimal operation. Let alone to burn off the water introduced by the product of combustion.
Cooler oil is most definitely NOT better in many circumstances. I'm not saying a thermostat is mandatory, however if you are running a 140 thermostat in your engine (naturally aspirated) and no thermostat with a large oil cooler, your oil temps will more than likely be too cold. The oil is not going to be at the temperature for optimal operation. Let alone to burn off the water introduced by the product of combustion.
I can tell you first hand for years I ran a pair of blown big blocks in my boat with no oil stats or water stats. Rarely ever got any oil temp. While I have since added a oil thermostat, prior to that the engines were tore down after at least 6 seasons on then running very hard, and there was almost no wear on anything. I never had chocolate milk under my valve covers. The bearings could have been reused they looked so good.
I know you are an oil expert , and that's fine. I try to stick with what works. I think if you go find a merc 1075, 1350, eddie young engines, sterlings, chief, teague, or any of the big builders, you won't find them setting up their engines to run 230+ oil temps. I can care less what redline, amsoil, or any of the oil companies claims that their product can withstand. I care about what the total package can withstand.
I agree with you that 220-230 really isn't a big problem. I was speaking towards the group that feels 275, 300 is just fine because they run a boutique oil. But hey, if they pull their engines down after a few hundred hours and all looks good, than I guess it works.
As for the oil tribalist that works for the big oil company, sure he may know a thing or two about oil. However, mercury knows a thing or two about marine engines and what works in them. How many tens of thousands of mercury engines are out there running great, compared to how many engines the oil specialist has built and ran "his way".
#27
Banned
Joined: Jun 2013
Posts: 1,014
Likes: 0
From: AZ
Ok so 212 not 200 is the spec. I was generalizing meaning that 300 degrees is no where near where oils are tested and rated.
I can tell you first hand for years I ran a pair of blown big blocks in my boat with no oil stats or water stats. Rarely ever got any oil temp. While I have since added a oil thermostat, prior to that the engines were tore down after at least 6 seasons on then running very hard, and there was almost no wear on anything. I never had chocolate milk under my valve covers. The bearings could have been reused they looked so good.
I know you are an oil expert , and that's fine. I try to stick with what works. I think if you go find a merc 1075, 1350, eddie young engines, sterlings, chief, teague, or any of the big builders, you won't find them setting up their engines to run 230+ oil temps. I can care less what redline, amsoil, or any of the oil companies claims that their product can withstand. I care about what the total package can withstand.
I agree with you that 220-230 really isn't a big problem. I was speaking towards the group that feels 275, 300 is just fine because they run a boutique oil. But hey, if they pull their engines down after a few hundred hours and all looks good, than I guess it works.
As for the oil tribalist that works for the big oil company, sure he may know a thing or two about oil. However, mercury knows a thing or two about marine engines and what works in them. How many tens of thousands of mercury engines are out there running great, compared to how many engines the oil specialist has built and ran "his way".
I can tell you first hand for years I ran a pair of blown big blocks in my boat with no oil stats or water stats. Rarely ever got any oil temp. While I have since added a oil thermostat, prior to that the engines were tore down after at least 6 seasons on then running very hard, and there was almost no wear on anything. I never had chocolate milk under my valve covers. The bearings could have been reused they looked so good.
I know you are an oil expert , and that's fine. I try to stick with what works. I think if you go find a merc 1075, 1350, eddie young engines, sterlings, chief, teague, or any of the big builders, you won't find them setting up their engines to run 230+ oil temps. I can care less what redline, amsoil, or any of the oil companies claims that their product can withstand. I care about what the total package can withstand.
I agree with you that 220-230 really isn't a big problem. I was speaking towards the group that feels 275, 300 is just fine because they run a boutique oil. But hey, if they pull their engines down after a few hundred hours and all looks good, than I guess it works.
As for the oil tribalist that works for the big oil company, sure he may know a thing or two about oil. However, mercury knows a thing or two about marine engines and what works in them. How many tens of thousands of mercury engines are out there running great, compared to how many engines the oil specialist has built and ran "his way".
So yes, mercury marine does know a great deal about their own product. I'm willing to bet they have a decent relationship with an adviser who likely works for ExxonMobil or shell who looks at the design and proposed use and let's them know what works best with regards to oil, temps etc...
Btw it's all good. If somebody has good luck using a certain approach, why fix what isn't broken. Cheers
Last edited by Borgie; 06-24-2014 at 12:37 PM.
#28
Registered
Joined: Aug 2013
Posts: 621
Likes: 0
From: Newark, DE
My line is good to go, can blow right through it. We just think the bypass is such an easier path that once the block is full and adding resistance all the water just flows through all the 1 inch hoses and out the exhaust. Have lightening headers with dry tails, so all of that flows water with little resistance.
#29
yes youres is the funny looking thing that necks down like a bottle on back of motor by coolor , that unit comes with two choices of thermostat .this post was for the fellar asking about where his is . sorry for confussion
Last edited by ROB FREEMAN; 06-24-2014 at 07:20 PM.


