Oil pump thread
#51
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 9,969
Likes: 6,461
From: Chicago
L19 for that motor is simply the wrong choice, everyone except you and some secret engineers knows this. I`m sorry I brought it up, you know best, everyone else is an idiot, I had forgeten that rule.
Maybe one day you will have an open mind.
Thats what makes a smart man, an open mind .... knowing that one does NOT know it all and someone who is willing to listen and learn. Mike is such a man even after all these years he is willing and open to other ideas.
Ive had many experiences working with Engineers, they think they know it all, Id rather listen to someone who has real life experiences than someone who is book smart.
I had one engineer that always thought he was smarter than me and one day came out of nowhere and stuck his hand in a 240v. disconnect box I was working on. I had a smile on my face for a week after he got the jolt of his life. Lucky he didn`t kill himself.

Maybe one day you will have an open mind.
Thats what makes a smart man, an open mind .... knowing that one does NOT know it all and someone who is willing to listen and learn. Mike is such a man even after all these years he is willing and open to other ideas.
Ive had many experiences working with Engineers, they think they know it all, Id rather listen to someone who has real life experiences than someone who is book smart.
I had one engineer that always thought he was smarter than me and one day came out of nowhere and stuck his hand in a 240v. disconnect box I was working on. I had a smile on my face for a week after he got the jolt of his life. Lucky he didn`t kill himself.
#53
Registered

Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 14,094
Likes: 3,684
From: On A Dirt Floor
Thread is on page 6. Could have been derailed by 1st or 2nd page.
#54
L19 for that motor is simply the wrong choice, everyone except you and some secret engineers knows this. I`m sorry I brought it up, you know best, everyone else is an idiot, I had forgeten that rule.
Maybe one day you will have an open mind.
Thats what makes a smart man, an open mind .... knowing that one does NOT know it all and someone who is willing to listen and learn. Mike is such a man even after all these years he is willing and open to other ideas.
Ive had many experiences working with Engineers, they think they know it all, Id rather listen to someone who has real life experiences than someone who is book smart.
I had one engineer that always thought he was smarter than me and one day came out of nowhere and stuck his hand in a 240v. disconnect box I was working on. I had a smile on my face for a week after he got the jolt of his life. Lucky he didn`t kill himself.

Maybe one day you will have an open mind.
Thats what makes a smart man, an open mind .... knowing that one does NOT know it all and someone who is willing to listen and learn. Mike is such a man even after all these years he is willing and open to other ideas.
Ive had many experiences working with Engineers, they think they know it all, Id rather listen to someone who has real life experiences than someone who is book smart.
I had one engineer that always thought he was smarter than me and one day came out of nowhere and stuck his hand in a 240v. disconnect box I was working on. I had a smile on my face for a week after he got the jolt of his life. Lucky he didn`t kill himself.
#55
Banned
Joined: Jun 2013
Posts: 1,014
Likes: 0
From: AZ
Do you have any data from the engineers regarding the use of the L19 bolts?
I don't think Mike was trying to insult you with his post. I think he was questioning why you chose the parts you did. Of course you took offense as usual.
I do see Callies only offers the compstar rod with the L19 bolts. All other H beam rod manufactures do have bolt options, as well as oliver and their I beam rods. I know manley stopped offering the L19 bolts in their rods last year I think.
I know you may think Mike Tkach or myself are morons. Mike has probably a few dozen engines out there ranging from 500hp to 1200hp using all different kinds of rod bolts, and many melling pumps without failure.
I simply asked the limits of the 8740 bolts in a 900hp blown marine setup spinning 6k rpm.
I don't think Mike was trying to insult you with his post. I think he was questioning why you chose the parts you did. Of course you took offense as usual.
I do see Callies only offers the compstar rod with the L19 bolts. All other H beam rod manufactures do have bolt options, as well as oliver and their I beam rods. I know manley stopped offering the L19 bolts in their rods last year I think.
I know you may think Mike Tkach or myself are morons. Mike has probably a few dozen engines out there ranging from 500hp to 1200hp using all different kinds of rod bolts, and many melling pumps without failure.
I simply asked the limits of the 8740 bolts in a 900hp blown marine setup spinning 6k rpm.
#56
Registered
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 2,640
Likes: 4
#58
I have used 8740, L-19, ARP2000,ARP WSB, ARP 3.5. I have used plenty of L-19 with no problems, if you get water in the oil, yes it can be a issue if not caught, either way at that point you better tear it down. The 8740 isn't going to fail on a NA at 6000 RPMs and neither will a L-19.
#59
I was only asking as I am a member of electricians local 38, Cleveland Ohio.
I wasn't trying to discredit the man.
I wasn't trying to discredit the man.
#60
Registered
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 2,640
Likes: 4
Just curious - not likely that I will ever have a need for L19's with my rig. Something to talk about on a bring day stuck at work.




