What Drive?
#1
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 793
Likes: 59
From: Sandusky/Olmsted Falls, OH
Like others, I've had to rebuild my XR's with Sportmaster shorties. In the very near future, I'm going to rebuild my 575's to +700hp. What drive would you go with? Arneson's, B-Max, or Imco?
#3
Registered

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,613
Likes: 375
From: Traverse City MI
areneson bravo conversion. You have no excuse not to. You will BLOW your bravos with that power.
Imco scx = loss of speed, more moving parts, still wears out gears about 4-500 hours, better then 50-80 in a bravo but not as good as the arneson!
B-max = xr lower gears (junk) upper is strong but ugly, are they even making drives??? taking orders but actually shipping? Are there any parts in stock for warranty? I have not called in months to know but something to check. John is a super guy though.
You have it easy compared to most because someone on OSO has already put arnesons on your boat with amazing results. I believe 11-14mph gain!
So....Proven design, all new parts from the transom back, sell your current parts from the transom back, if you can affford to do the motors then do the drives or you will hate your decison to build the motors. The broken drives will ruin your summer on the water.
70 on the water is better then 0mph at the dock!
Arneson Arneson Arneson!!!
Imco scx = loss of speed, more moving parts, still wears out gears about 4-500 hours, better then 50-80 in a bravo but not as good as the arneson!
B-max = xr lower gears (junk) upper is strong but ugly, are they even making drives??? taking orders but actually shipping? Are there any parts in stock for warranty? I have not called in months to know but something to check. John is a super guy though.
You have it easy compared to most because someone on OSO has already put arnesons on your boat with amazing results. I believe 11-14mph gain!
So....Proven design, all new parts from the transom back, sell your current parts from the transom back, if you can affford to do the motors then do the drives or you will hate your decison to build the motors. The broken drives will ruin your summer on the water.
70 on the water is better then 0mph at the dock!
Arneson Arneson Arneson!!!
#5
Registered

Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 212
Likes: 0
From: COAL CITY IL.
My Scx/sc Combo Is Workin Great,and I Believe Everyone Else That Has Them Will Say The Same(i Have Not Herd Of Any Failures),i Did Not Loose Any Mph!!!.they Are Easy To Install,and Easy To Take Off If You Want To Sell The Boat!!! I Believe If Your Gona Bite The Arneson Bullet,u Better Like Your Boat And Plan On Owning It For A Long Time!!!
#6
Registered
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 1,852
Likes: 1
From: Denmark and hopefully some place nice
#7
My 382 made 630hp fully dressed on a dyno....but made 700 ft/lbs of torque. I got 3 years out of standard length XR's but boated mainly in fairly calm waters.
I talked heavily with Arneson. They claimed a good 10mph gain with the exact same engines.....both at WOT AND cruise. The cost is high but you'll be replacing not only the drives but transom assemblies, inner plates, trim pumps, even the hydraulic steering. These are all things you can sell to offset the costs. You'll be replacing props too, which you would be with a power upgrade anyway. I was worried about how far back these things would stick out but was told it's about 4 inches further than a boat with extension boxes (which I did not have).
FYI: I ran 32P bravos or 28P 15 5/8 labbed maximus. The boat was a little over propped for cruise speed. 3,500 was 58GPS, 5,300 was 82-83. (30P bravos would run 5,600 at 86). All speeds are listed in flat calm water.
I talked heavily with Arneson. They claimed a good 10mph gain with the exact same engines.....both at WOT AND cruise. The cost is high but you'll be replacing not only the drives but transom assemblies, inner plates, trim pumps, even the hydraulic steering. These are all things you can sell to offset the costs. You'll be replacing props too, which you would be with a power upgrade anyway. I was worried about how far back these things would stick out but was told it's about 4 inches further than a boat with extension boxes (which I did not have).
FYI: I ran 32P bravos or 28P 15 5/8 labbed maximus. The boat was a little over propped for cruise speed. 3,500 was 58GPS, 5,300 was 82-83. (30P bravos would run 5,600 at 86). All speeds are listed in flat calm water.
#8
I'm running twin 700hp thru Imco SC's and have blown both uppers, the lowers seem to hold up fine. i'll be switching over to SCX'a as soon as my pockets get $20K deeper. That seems to be the best choice SCX uppers and SC lowers with the simplest conversion. just need to change the Gimble helmet and bolt on. I like the Arnesons but don't want to do the re-rigging nd would need transmissions?
#9
I'm running twin 700hp thru Imco SC's and have blown both uppers, the lowers seem to hold up fine. i'll be switching over to SCX'a as soon as my pockets get $20K deeper. That seems to be the best choice SCX uppers and SC lowers with the simplest conversion. just need to change the Gimble helmet and bolt on. I like the Arnesons but don't want to do the re-rigging nd would need transmissions?
__________________
Arneson Surface Drives www.arneson-industries.com
Arneson Surface Drives www.arneson-industries.com



