XD short travel lifter update
#71
Registered

Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 570
Likes: 47
From: cincinnati,oh.
I had Morel hyd. roller lifters on a .660 lift hyd. cam. Tried every thing known to man get them to quiet down thin oil, lots of preload oil galley work on and on. The only thing that worked was to jerk them out and then install them in the garbage can. bought a set of Howards solid rollers with pin oilers. works great so far.
#72
Thread Starter
Registered

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 9,961
Likes: 6,444
From: Chicago
Before they moved operations to CHINA I ran the good morels from 9 years ago for 7 season with 235/585 spring pressure and zero issues. Only replaced them because I thought it was time .
The XD`s lasted 2 seasons.
From a cam 'guru' :
I work with 2 of the biggest offshore boat engine builders in the country, and after fighting with hydr rollers for the last 2 decades, they have both switched to mechanical rollers, and have had much better reliability.
When a hydr lifter works correctly, it's great. When it doesn't, it's a disaster.
If for some reason the oil foams, the lifters will quickly collapse, and beat the heck out of the valvetrain.
If you decided to go mechanical roller, we could reliably add some lift, and still be easy on the valvetrain
We also offer a mechanical roller lifter with no needle bearings and no bronze bushings.
It's the most durable lifter available, and have been running them in boats for years.
They're $1,260 a set for the .904" diameter.
The XD`s lasted 2 seasons.
From a cam 'guru' :
I work with 2 of the biggest offshore boat engine builders in the country, and after fighting with hydr rollers for the last 2 decades, they have both switched to mechanical rollers, and have had much better reliability.
When a hydr lifter works correctly, it's great. When it doesn't, it's a disaster.
If for some reason the oil foams, the lifters will quickly collapse, and beat the heck out of the valvetrain.
If you decided to go mechanical roller, we could reliably add some lift, and still be easy on the valvetrain
We also offer a mechanical roller lifter with no needle bearings and no bronze bushings.
It's the most durable lifter available, and have been running them in boats for years.
They're $1,260 a set for the .904" diameter.
#73
Registered

Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 2,227
Likes: 547
From: Cape Coral FL
I hate to see this. I put the XD's in the last 5 engines that I built. As a matter of fact, I was sort of recommending them when everyone else was having all of the trouble with the Morel's. To the best of my knowledge though, none of these engines have had any trouble.
Here is a related/unrelated question. Why do the tie bars and forks/axles live on a solid lifter with more lift and higher spring pressures, but won't live on a hydraulic?
Here is a related/unrelated question. Why do the tie bars and forks/axles live on a solid lifter with more lift and higher spring pressures, but won't live on a hydraulic?
#74
I hate to see this. I put the XD's in the last 5 engines that I built. As a matter of fact, I was sort of recommending them when everyone else was having all of the trouble with the Morel's. To the best of my knowledge though, none of these engines have had any trouble.
Here is a related/unrelated question. Why do the tie bars and forks/axles live on a solid lifter with more lift and higher spring pressures, but won't live on a hydraulic?
Here is a related/unrelated question. Why do the tie bars and forks/axles live on a solid lifter with more lift and higher spring pressures, but won't live on a hydraulic?
#75
Registered

Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 14,090
Likes: 3,678
From: On A Dirt Floor
We touched on soreading forks in this mega thread:
Cam and valvetrain longevity....??? low duration high lift...
mt thinks it’s (spreading forks) massive set up issue.
Before i forget: quick before i forget: you have dart pro m block ?
Cam and valvetrain longevity....??? low duration high lift...
mt thinks it’s (spreading forks) massive set up issue.
Before i forget: quick before i forget: you have dart pro m block ?
#76
Registered

Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 8,356
Likes: 1,515
From: NW Michigan
im just throwing this out as a possibility and may not be relevant at all but if the foaming of the oil is bleeding down the lifters is it throwing off the geometry resulting in worn forks/axles?
icdeppl - pretty sure I bought those same EVO steel on steel solid roller lifters your referring to. Not certain however I got mine through jones cams. Mike’s a pretty good dude. I believe a company close to his manufactures them. I read a very similar if not the same post as you pasted. I was completely sold on the concept as it makes a lot of sense in hi performance marine and other endurance builds.
Last edited by getrdunn; 11-17-2021 at 02:01 PM.
#77
Registered

Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 874
Likes: 46
From: Charleston, il
I believe at this point a Johnson sourced lifter is best for our needs (outside of going keyed lifter). When I spoke with Isky they had some great options. Teague has his done a little differently as they are Johnsons sourced from Isky.
#79
Registered
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 156
Likes: 3
From: So Cal
It looks to me like most have gone to the Johnsen's. I'm running the 2126's in a 555 i replaced that engine with. so far so good.
#80
Registered

Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 14,090
Likes: 3,678
From: On A Dirt Floor
You have no idea on the history, was way further back than that, i’ll just leave it at that. I’m serious about the dart block oiling though. Broken record, skip, broken record, skip…..lolololol


