Solid roller adjustments or check intervals?
#122
Thread Starter
Gold Member

Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,688
Likes: 216
From: Olmsted Falls,Ohio Marblehead,Oh
Tim I think your getting the pros and cons from some pretty good members here. All about what you wanna do. Black baja among others pretty much covered it with your situation stay hydraulic especially if you go with a non aggressive a cam. That's the only way I'd go hyd. With any aggressive lobe solid all the way. It sucks to be at a dyno session and find out right off the bat some lifters failed. I had the problem and didn't even bother with sending the lifters back to have cked bla bla bla. I imeadiately put isky solids on and changed the springs. Done deal. I know my luck I woulda replaced the lifters and still had a problem with the cam I used which wasn't really even that severe. 244/248-647/641. I know this isn't a cam thread but again find a proven hyd roller cam with your combo that is easy on the valvetrain. I think most the failure hyd roller cam threads stem from aggressive lobes. I'm going solid only cause I'm looking for max hp and don't wanna be chasing down lifter issues but that's cause of my cam choice. I know there's plenty of options but again I think that grind howards has that MT posted a while back was an easily achieved 700 plus @6k. At this point in the game and considering what you went through I wouldn't get out the lobe catalog and start designing your own that's for sure. There's a lot to it and more than just lift and duration obviously so why gamble. If money and time wasn't an issue I'd say go for it with the right help. Understanding valve timing is not a guessing game.
I think your new intakes will be a huge improvement and assume you had those worked over some by the same guy who worked on your heads. That is huge... Another note but just my advice is I would look for peak hp at 6k only cause of your weight and hull design. I'm just saying don't cam it to see happy numbers at 6,500 plus rpm. I'd wanna be running 1k over peak torque min. Others may disagree and that's ok but it just my experience from years of boating and building.
i would imagine you would however for whatever cam you end up with I'd use the recommended lifters to go with regardless or at the very least seek their advice on what to use.
I think your new intakes will be a huge improvement and assume you had those worked over some by the same guy who worked on your heads. That is huge... Another note but just my advice is I would look for peak hp at 6k only cause of your weight and hull design. I'm just saying don't cam it to see happy numbers at 6,500 plus rpm. I'd wanna be running 1k over peak torque min. Others may disagree and that's ok but it just my experience from years of boating and building.
i would imagine you would however for whatever cam you end up with I'd use the recommended lifters to go with regardless or at the very least seek their advice on what to use.
Props to spin, that's the goal. Can specs won't even be talked about until I have flow numbers but I can say one thing I he info from a very highly respected engine builder today say that there's absolutely no reason to have the lift I have, kinda interesting to hear from him, I won't say who due to keeping some things private.
#124
Registered
Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 487
Likes: 23
From: Salisbury N.C.
[QUOTE=Black Baja;4506349]I'm not a rookie. We check that stuff while the motor is being assembled. A flashlight in the oil galley hole tells that story. These lifters come tested from Morel. It takes two revolutions of the motor to adjust pre
Didn't say you were a rookie , but if a lifter that takes 9 months to get , and you have a bucket full that wont pump up . I'd say either the lifters are a POS , or you got other issues .
Just me but if these lifter issues are common I would say the Mongrel lifters are not top of the line.
Didn't say you were a rookie , but if a lifter that takes 9 months to get , and you have a bucket full that wont pump up . I'd say either the lifters are a POS , or you got other issues .
Just me but if these lifter issues are common I would say the Mongrel lifters are not top of the line.
#125
Registered
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 2,733
Likes: 8
From: bel air, md
Why would you want to add more maintenance to your boat? Leave it Hydraulic , Solid Lifters are for High RPM ( above 7000 ) they also Induce high frequency harmonics into the valvetrain . They are loud , they need to be adjusted Hot , they are a pain in the ass . Yes people use them , stud girdles , shaft rockers , big pushrods etc ,etc , but why ? Good Hydraulic rollers are unbeatable in these kind of applications . Its kind of like riding a Hardtail chop compared to a Softail Bagger for your valvetrain. You wont notice any improvement in performance with comparable cam profiles , just noise and maintenance on the solids. They chatter like a hog eatin hickory nuts when they are running , it will scare the **** out of you the first time you fire it up with the solids it makes so much noise .
The Morel lifters are bad azz when they work. However it's a crap shoot if you are going to get a good set or not. Based on my experience if the Morel's were 100% reliable right out of the box and availability was not an issue its a no brainier. And this is talking about an application that we are going to run an aggressive lobe that requires solid roller type spring pressures. But given the availability issue along with the initial parts reliability. A solid lifter starts looking better and better.
#126
Registered

Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 14,094
Likes: 3,684
From: On A Dirt Floor
$880 a set and a bucket of bad lifters is acceptable ?
===========================
I see they discontinued these:
CHEVY BB HYDRAULIC ROLLER LIFTERS - DISCONTINUED
Set# Pair# BodyD RollD Description Avail
5475 5925 0.842 0.750 DISCONTINUED 07/21/2016
MERC MARINE DOG BONE .842D HYD ROLLER N\A
6427 6469 0.842 0.750 DISCONTINUED 07/21/2016
MERC MARINE DOG BONE .842D (HLT) HYD ROLLER N\A
===========================
I see they discontinued these:
CHEVY BB HYDRAULIC ROLLER LIFTERS - DISCONTINUED
Set# Pair# BodyD RollD Description Avail
5475 5925 0.842 0.750 DISCONTINUED 07/21/2016
MERC MARINE DOG BONE .842D HYD ROLLER N\A
6427 6469 0.842 0.750 DISCONTINUED 07/21/2016
MERC MARINE DOG BONE .842D (HLT) HYD ROLLER N\A
#128
Registered

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 11,332
Likes: 73
From: chicago
$880 a set and a bucket of bad lifters is acceptable ?
===========================
I see they discontinued these:
CHEVY BB HYDRAULIC ROLLER LIFTERS - DISCONTINUED
Set# Pair# BodyD RollD Description Avail
5475 5925 0.842 0.750 DISCONTINUED 07/21/2016
MERC MARINE DOG BONE .842D HYD ROLLER N\A
6427 6469 0.842 0.750 DISCONTINUED 07/21/2016
MERC MARINE DOG BONE .842D (HLT) HYD ROLLER N\A
===========================
I see they discontinued these:
CHEVY BB HYDRAULIC ROLLER LIFTERS - DISCONTINUED
Set# Pair# BodyD RollD Description Avail
5475 5925 0.842 0.750 DISCONTINUED 07/21/2016
MERC MARINE DOG BONE .842D HYD ROLLER N\A
6427 6469 0.842 0.750 DISCONTINUED 07/21/2016
MERC MARINE DOG BONE .842D (HLT) HYD ROLLER N\A
I do agree, that if you do some searching, you will find some morel lifter issues out there for sure. Of course, for the past decade, they have been supplying lifters to Lunati, Howards, Isky, Crower, Erson, PBM, Bullet cams, Cam Motion, Herbert Cams, Madera, Straub, and a bunch of others. Summit Racing, and Jegs, probably the two biggest retailers in our hobby, have probably sold tens and tens of thousands of those bbc morel based lifters, between the lunati, howards, isky and crower label. They were basically everywhere. Recently, isky and crower have switched to johnson. How long ago was that? For years, the "GO-TO" bbc hyd lifter, was morel on all the forums. From yellowbullet, speedtalk, chevelles.com, offshoreonly , speedwake, BUTTFREAKS, and serious offshore. Marine builders like eddie young, Zul, phaff, teague, chief, and many others were using those lifters for years without issue.
Of course, I do understand the complaints about them. You certainly will have stories of issues, when your product is in the hands of many. Aside from product failure itself, you also have the things that cannot be verified, like lifter bore clearance, cleanliness of engine builds, and overall machine/assembly questions. The tiniest piece of debris, can clog a lifter orifice and wreak havoc. I know I've taken a few engines apart that someone else put together, and finding little bits and pieces of silicone rtv floating around and random dirst is always good for the lifters.
I did have a morel collapse on me. It was a pain in the azz, had to pull the blower, intake, distributor and everything off to replace it. 80 bucks and 2 days later, I had a single pair of lifters here from summit racing, and had it back together. That particular set of lifters, did suffer from about 20 quarts of lake water pumped into the crankcase , due to a split cylinder wall on a shortblock assembly I had purchased, that was never sonic checked. Kinda hard to blame the lifter, when the engine was filled with raw lake water and debris. Anyhow, since then, they have not skipped a beat. Thier time will be up though after another season or two. At that point, I probably will go with a solid setup.
fwiw, you can get the morel 4603 lifter series, for under 700 dollars a set from various sources.
#129
Registered

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,613
Likes: 375
From: Traverse City MI
Tim stay hydraulic and focus on reliability, the 1mph your looking for will easily come from induction and exhaust upgrades without sacrificing valve train instability
Unleashed is run harder and longer then any boat participating in this tech section (with videos to prove), and my morel lifters have been flawless :-)
Unleashed is run harder and longer then any boat participating in this tech section (with videos to prove), and my morel lifters have been flawless :-)


